---
title: "When your contract promises more than your PI covers"
description: "Reasonable skill and care, fitness for purpose, liability caps, five ways to cap, net contribution clauses and collateral warranties."
url: "https://hpic-production.up.railway.app/design-and-construct/contractual-liability/"
updated: "2026-11-16T21:17:31.897Z"
---

[Home](https://hpic-production.up.railway.app/index.md) / [Who we cover](https://hpic-production.up.railway.app/who-we-cover.md) / [Design and construct](https://hpic-production.up.railway.app/design-and-construct.md) / Contractual liability

Technical guidance | Contractual risk

# When your contract promises more than your PI covers

Two professionals can carry identical PI limits while accepting very different contractual liabilities. The difference often comes down to a few words in an appointment, warranty, specification or technical schedule.

On this page

Skill and care v. fitness for purposeThe promise in a specificationPI limit v. liability capThe liability gap explainedHow cap wording changes the positionNet contributionTerms to refer

Last reviewed 11 November 2026 by Numan, Director, Hammond PI.

## Reasonable skill and care v. fitness for purpose

Duty of conduct

### Reasonable skill and care

You must exercise the care and competence reasonably expected of an appropriately qualified professional doing that work. A poor outcome does not by itself mean the duty was breached.

Duty of result

### Fitness for purpose

The contract requires a specified result or performance. Depending on the wording, liability can arise even where you took reasonable care.

PI policies commonly insure negligence, or other defined civil liabilities, arising from professional services. Liability taken on only through a guarantee or result based obligation may fall outside the insured basis. The exact wording matters, and a reasonable skill and care clause may not neutralise a more demanding promise elsewhere in the documents.

## The promise hidden in a technical specification

Public decision

### MT Højgaard v E.ON \[2017\] UKSC 59

The dispute concerned the foundations of offshore wind turbines. The contractor had complied with a specified design standard, but the technical requirements also imposed a separate obligation concerning the foundations' design life. The Supreme Court held that compliance with the prescribed standard did not displace that separate performance obligation.

[Read the judgment](https://www.bailii.org/uk/cases/UKSC/2017/59.html)

**The practical lesson.** Design duties are not always in the main appointment clause. Specifications, employer's requirements and technical schedules can create obligations that change your liability, so the contract has to be read as a whole, with its order of precedence.

Illustrative scenario

A specification requires an acoustic outcome, and an amendment describes it as "guaranteed". Decide whether the promise concerns design, product performance, workmanship or an express result. Keep the technical requirement, but allocate the responsibility clearly and insure or manage the risk that results.

## Your PI limit is not your liability cap

1

### Contractual liability

What you owe, defined by the contract and the law.

2

### Liability cap

The most you can be liable for under an effective contractual limit, subject to its terms and the law.

3

### PI limit

The stated limit for the liabilities it covers, subject to its terms. Check separately how defence costs, sublimits and aggregation work.

These are separate concepts. A £1 million PI policy does not cap your liability at £1 million. Equally, an agreed £1 million cap does not guarantee insurers will meet the whole liability: an exclusion, the excess, an aggregation provision or another restriction can reduce what is available. A cap tied to "insurance proceeds actually paid" leaves recovery uncertain if insurers decline.

Collateral warranties give a funder, purchaser or tenant a direct right against the designer. Compare the beneficiaries, assignment rights, duties, defences, caps and duration with the appointment rather than assuming the warranty mirrors it.

## The liability gap explained

Change the figures to see how a contractual cap compares with a headline PI limit.

Type of cap Multiple of the design fee

 Fixed amount

Design fee (£)

Fee multiple:

10

times

Headline PI limit

Contractual cap £1,500,000. Headline PI limit £1,000,000. Potential difference £500,000 above the headline limit.

This only compares two numbers. It is not a calculation of insured loss, recoverable damages, legal enforceability or what an insurer would pay. A cap below the PI limit does not guarantee the policy will respond, and a cap may not be enforceable in every circumstance.

Understand how your contract and PI insurance work together.

## How liability cap wording changes the position

Liability caps do more than set a number. They decide which losses fall within that number, how different losses share a limit and whether the limit works independently of insurance. These five structures come up repeatedly in our contract review work. They are illustrations, not recommended clauses.

1Separate workmanship and professional liability caps

The cost of putting right certain defective workmanship is capped against the subcontract sum, while design and other specified liabilities sit under a separate fixed cap. The challenge is deciding which losses belong where, especially where a defect involves both design and installation.

2Fixed cap for design, fee based cap for everything else

Design liability has a fixed monetary cap; other liabilities are limited to a multiple of the subcontract sum. How mixed losses are allocated, and the amount of each cap, need particular attention.

3Liability linked to available insurance

The cap refers to the insurance indemnity recoverable. This brings uncertainty, because the amount available can depend on exclusions, limits, claims handling or a dispute with insurers. Linking liability to insurance does not necessarily remove uninsured exposure.

4Fee multiple with a minimum or maximum

The cap is a multiple of the design fee, with an agreed floor or ceiling. Ten times a £150,000 fee gives £1.5 million. If the PI policy provides £1 million, the cap may be higher than the insurance. See the liability gap.

5Separate treatment for delay and consequential losses

Delay, disruption, loss of profit and other listed losses go to a separate fee based cap. This can reduce the specialist's exposure to large delay claims, but the main contractor must check whether that conflicts with its own obligations to the employer.

No single structure suits every appointment. A clause that helps a main contractor recover from a consultant may be resisted by the consultant, and a clause that protects the consultant may leave the main contractor carrying liability it cannot pass down. Bargaining power, project risk, the contract chain and the insurance available all count. Any drafting needs legal review.

## What happens when another responsible party cannot pay?

Illustrative scenario A properly drafted and effective net contribution clause may restrict the consultant's liability to its own £300,000 share, subject to the law and the precise wording. The claimant may be unable to recover the remaining £700,000 from that consultant.

A net contribution clause limiting your own liability to your client helps you. Accepting the same clause in a consultant's appointment can cut your recovery while your duty upstream stays whole. For a main contractor, compare upstream and downstream terms before agreeing it. The PI policy will not override a valid contractual limit.

## Three ways a gap appears, and the terms to refer

### Outside the insured scope

A guarantee or indemnity may create liability beyond the policy's scope. If it is established, you still owe it.

### A policy condition is not met

Late notification or an unmet insurance condition can give insurers an argument on cover.

### The cover is not enough

An excess, a sublimit or an exhausted aggregate leaves a shortfall even where the claim is covered.

Refer these before signing: fitness for purpose, guarantee, ensure or warrant applied to design; design life or performance figures in technical schedules; indemnities wider than negligence; uncapped liability or a cap above the PI limit; each and every claim cover where only aggregate is held; insurance maintenance periods of twelve years or more; unrestricted assignment of collateral warranties; and downstream terms weaker than upstream ones. [How our contract reviews work](https://hpic-production.up.railway.app/contract-reviews.md).

Insurance does not rewrite your contract. And your contract does not rewrite your insurance.

Terms used: [fitness for purpose](https://hpic-production.up.railway.app/design-and-construct.md), [contractual liability cap](https://hpic-production.up.railway.app/design-and-construct.md), [net contribution](https://hpic-production.up.railway.app/design-and-construct.md), [collateral warranty](https://hpic-production.up.railway.app/design-and-construct.md), [contractual recovery](https://hpic-production.up.railway.app/design-and-construct.md).

## Related guidance

[GuideWho is responsible for the design?](https://hpic-production.up.railway.app/design-and-construct/design-responsibility.md)[GuideIs your consultant's PI actually adequate?](https://hpic-production.up.railway.app/design-and-construct/checking-consultant-pi.md)[GuideWhen something goes wrong](https://hpic-production.up.railway.app/design-and-construct/construction-pi-claims.md)[HubAll construction guidance and the glossary](https://hpic-production.up.railway.app/design-and-construct.md)

## Discuss the insurance implications of your contract

Tell us about your professional activities, your insurance or the obligation you have been asked to accept. We explain the insurance implications and the terms available; legal interpretation or drafting needs a solicitor.

[Speak to Hammond PI](https://hpic-production.up.railway.app/contact.md)[Send a contract for review](https://hpic-production.up.railway.app/contract-reviews.md)[Get a PI quote](https://hpic-production.up.railway.app/quote.md)

This guidance is provided for general information and does not constitute legal advice or confirmation of insurance cover. Cover is subject to the terms, conditions and exclusions of the relevant policy. Contractual obligations should be considered with appropriate professional advice.
