We would like to set optional cookies to understand how the site is used. Essential cookies keep forms working. Cookie policy.

Home / Insights / “Shall achieve”: the decibel guarantee in your appointment and what PI does with it

Insights for acoustic consultants

“Shall achieve”: the decibel guarantee in your appointment and what PI does with it

Acoustics is one of the few disciplines where the result can be measured to a decibel on handover day. That tempts clients to write the number into your appointment. Two words, “shall achieve”, may move part of a claim outside your cover.

Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.

Skill and care, or a result

The law implies into a contract for services a term that the supplier will carry out the service with reasonable care and skill (Supply of Goods and Services Act 1982, section 13). PI is built on that duty. You are liable if you fell below the standard of a competent acoustic consultant, not merely because the outcome disappointed.

A performance term is a different promise. “The installation shall achieve 35 dB at the nearest window” makes you answerable for the number itself. If the measured level is 4 dB over, the client does not need to show what you did wrong. It needs only the measurement.

How courts have read performance wording

Two decisions show how seriously the words are taken. Neither concerned an acoustic consultant’s appointment, but both turned on the same kind of clause.

In MT Højgaard v E.ON [2017] UKSC 59 a contractor designed offshore wind turbine foundations. It was found not to have been negligent, and it had followed the international standard the contract named, which contained an error. The connections failed. The technical requirements also called for a design life of 20 years, and the Supreme Court held the contractor liable. It said courts are generally inclined to give full effect to a requirement that the finished item meets stated criteria, and that where two requirements differ the more demanding prevails.

In Tejani v Fitzroy Place Residential [2022] EWHC 2760 (TCC) a flat buyer complained of clicking from the façade. The judge found the noise was not a nuisance. It was still a defect, because the specification required noise from thermal movement to be “unnoticeable under normal conditions”. The claim failed on other grounds, but the specification’s words, not the law of nuisance, decided whether there was a defect.

How PI wordings usually treat a guarantee

Most PI wordings contain a contractual liability exclusion. In broad terms it removes cover for liability you took on by agreement, such as a guarantee, a fitness for purpose term or liquidated damages, unless you would have been liable without that agreement. The effect depends on the exact words, so yours needs reading.

In practice a claim on a decibel guarantee can split in two. If the shortfall came from your negligent calculation, the policy may respond, because you would have been liable anyway. If nobody was negligent, for example because the plant supplied was louder than its data sheet, the guarantee may still make you liable and that part may be uninsured. Collateral warranties follow the same logic: cover is usually kept only where the warranty gives no greater benefit than the appointment and contains no guarantee of performance. The clause guide

Wording to look for, and what to ask for instead

Performance wording in acoustic appointments and insurable alternatives
What the draft saysWhy it mattersWhat to propose
“Shall achieve” or “shall ensure” a stated levelA promise of the result, whatever the cause of a shortfallReasonable skill and care to design the works to achieve the level
“Fit for purpose” or “fit for its intended use”A fitness for purpose term, which many wordings excludeDelete it, or tie it to reasonable skill and care
“Shall satisfy the planning condition”The decision belongs to the council, not to youA duty to prepare the submission with reasonable skill and care
“Shall comply with” a named standard and the client’s requirementsWhere two requirements differ, the stricter can prevailAn agreed order of precedence between the documents
Liquidated damages or an indemnity for delayA fixed sum or indemnity can exceed your liability at lawLiability for loss caused by your negligence, within an agreed cap
“Highest standards” or “best practice”A higher standard than that of the ordinary competent consultantThe skill and care of a competent acoustic consultant experienced in similar work

Performance wording is not always in the appointment itself. Look in the scope schedule, the employer’s requirements, the specification you are asked to adopt on novation and every collateral warranty.

If you have already signed one

Tell us. A guarantee you have accepted is something an insurer would want to know about, and it is better raised at renewal than discovered in a claim. Fair presentation explained

We would ask insurers how they view the term for that project. We would also look with you at the practical controls: a design margin below the limit, stated assumptions about the plant and layout, a point at which you check the design again if the selected plant changes, and commissioning measurements taken under conditions you define.

If the measurement comes in over

  1. Tell us before you reply to the client, and point out the performance wording openly so it is dealt with at the start.
  2. Find out why the level is over: a design error, different plant, a changed layout, the installation, or the measurement method and conditions.
  3. Do not offer to pay for an enclosure, or to redesign free of charge, without insurers’ consent.
  4. Ask the solicitors insurers appoint to answer the claim on the ordinary duty of skill and care as well as on the contract, so the insured part is identified early.
  5. Check the appointment for a cap or a net contribution clause, and whether the supplier or installer gave the same promise.

Asked to guarantee a decibel figure?

Send us the draft before you sign and we will mark the performance wording and suggest insurable alternatives.

Speak to a PI specialistPI for acoustic consultants

Related: PI for acoustic consultants · Contract reviews · The clause guide