We would like to set optional cookies to understand how the site is used. Essential cookies keep forms working. Cookie policy.

Home / Insights / A failed sound test: how the claim is argued and what your PI does

Insights for acoustic consultants

A failed sound test: how the claim is argued and what your PI does

One failed set of tests can put every separating floor in a block in question. The contractor blames the specification, the designer blames the build, and the evidence disappears as floors are lifted. Here is how the argument runs and where your policy sits.

Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.

What counts as a failed test

Sound insulation between new homes must be tested by an approved procedure, and the duty to arrange the testing sits with the person carrying out the building work (Building Regulations 2010, regulation 41). For purpose built flats the standard is at least 45 dB airborne and no more than 62 dB impact. For homes formed by a change of use it is 43 dB and 64 dB (Approved Document E, table 0.1a).

There is no tolerance to argue about. Approved Document E says the values already include an allowance for measurement uncertainty, so a result that misses by any margin is a failure (paragraph 1.6). A set of tests fails if any single test within it fails (paragraph 1.32).

Why one failure becomes a claim about the whole block

The guidance turns one result into a question about every similar home. Results are treated as indicative of other constructions of the same type in the development (paragraph 1.11). After a failed set, the developer must satisfy building control about other rooms sharing the same separating element and about properties that were never tested, and the rate of testing rises until building control is satisfied the problem is solved (paragraphs 1.34 to 1.36). Where the cause lies in the construction, the document itself says untested rooms may also fail and may need remedial treatment (paragraph 1.38).

That is why the fee and the claim bear no relation to each other. The designer of one floor build-up may be asked to pay for lifting finishes across a scheme, retesting and delayed completions. Once homes are occupied, the guidance leaves further action to local negotiation (paragraph 1.35), which usually means buyers and their solicitors.

Design, build or test: how the claim is argued

The usual arguments after a failed sound test and the evidence that decides each
Where the blame is putWhat is saidThe evidence that decides it
The designThe specified build-up could never have met the standard, or left out a flanking or junction detailCalculations, the specification as issued, the product test data relied on, and what the drawings said about edges and junctions
The buildThe floor was not laid as specified: a bridged resilient layer, thin screed, missing edge strips or services cast inOpening up before more floors are lifted, site photographs, inspection records and who was appointed to inspect
A substitutionA different resilient layer, board or ceiling system was installedDelivery notes, requests for approval and any email in which you commented on the alternative
A later changeThe layout, structure or floor finish changed after your design was issuedRevision histories, and whether you were told and asked to check again
The testRooms were unfinished, the wrong pairs were tested or the procedure was not followedThe test report, the state of the rooms on the day and who selected the pairs

Most failures have more than one cause. The claim against the designer usually turns on whether the design, built as specified, would have passed.

What your policy does with each part

  • Negligent design. This is the core of PI: your legal liability for the client’s loss, and the cost of defending the claim, where the design fell below reasonable skill and care.
  • Putting your own work right. The time you spend redesigning is not usually a loss the policy pays. Some wordings cover costs incurred with insurers’ prior consent to reduce a claim. Check before you start.
  • A promised result. If the appointment said the floors “shall achieve” the standard, the contractor may claim on that promise without proving negligence. Many wordings exclude liability taken on by guarantee unless you would have been liable anyway.
  • Costs already run up. Remedial costs you agreed or encouraged without insurers’ consent can be disputed.
  • Withheld fees. A set off against your invoices is often the first sign of a claim. Tell us about it at once.
  • Adjudication. A design appointment on a building project is usually a construction contract (Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act 1996, section 104). The Act requires a decision within 28 days of referral unless the time is extended (section 108), and some wordings ask for notice within days.

The first week after a failure

  1. Tell us the day the result arrives and send the appointment, specification, test report and messages. A failed test is a circumstance to notify even if nobody has blamed you yet.
  2. Say nothing about fault. Keep helping the project team, expressly without admission and with insurers’ knowledge.
  3. Ask in writing for floors to be left in place until a joint inspection, and record what is found when they are opened.
  4. Gather the calculations, every revision of the specification, product data and site visit notes.
  5. Check whether you were appointed to design only or to inspect as well.
  6. Send any notice of adjudication to us the same day.

Designer duties and the record that defends you

Since 1 October 2023 a designer in England must take all reasonable steps to ensure that the design, if built, would comply with the regulations. The designer must also give sufficient information about the design, cooperate with the client, other designers and contractors, and report concerns about compliance to the principal designer (Building Regulations 2010, Part 2A, regulations 11J and 11K). Design includes specifications, so a separating floor specification is likely to be design work.

Those steps are also your defence file. State what the design relies on, name the junction and edge details that matter, and say in writing when a substitution has not been checked. Claims over dwellings under the Defective Premises Act 1972 can be brought for 15 years, or 30 for older work (Building Safety Act 2022, section 135), so the file needs to outlive the project. How we support you in a claim

Sound tests just failed?

Send us the result and the appointment before you reply to anyone, and we will put the matter to insurers properly.

Speak to a PI specialistPI for acoustic consultants

Related: PI for acoustic consultants · Claims support · The clause guide