Home / Insights / ANC and IOA rules on PI: what “appropriate and proportionate” means for your limit
Insights for acoustic consultants
ANC and IOA rules on PI: what “appropriate and proportionate” means for your limit
No regulator sets a minimum PI limit for acoustic consultants. The ANC asks for cover that is “appropriate and proportionate”. The Institute of Acoustics asks members to assess their liability. Your appointments supply the numbers. Here is how the three fit together.
Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.
What the two bodies require
The Association of Noise Consultants binds member companies through its Rules and Bylaws, June 2025. The Institute of Acoustics binds individuals through its Code of Conduct, revised May 2025.
| Point | ANC | IOA |
|---|---|---|
| Who is bound | The member consultancy, from the date its application is approved | Each individual member |
| The duty | Carry appropriate and proportionate PI, consistent with the work the member undertakes (paragraph 4.6) | Assess relevant liability and, if appropriate, hold PI (rule A3.1) |
| Minimum limit | None stated | None stated |
| Evidence | On application: a certified copy of the insurance document, an affidavit or other documents the ANC prescribes (paragraph 2.4) | None stated in the Code |
| If you fall short | Disciplinary action, which can include suspension or expulsion (paragraph 14.2) | A panel assesses whether the Code was breached and decides what action to take |
Neither rule mentions an excess, a basis of cover or a period after you stop trading. Those decisions are left to you.
Other ANC conditions that reach your insurance
- Sub-contracting. A member may not sub-contract more than 25% of its acoustics turnover in a financial year, and is primarily responsible to its client for the quality of that work unless agreed otherwise (paragraph 4.1). A freelancer’s error is therefore your claim. Freelancers and sub-consultants
- Pre-completion testing. Members may test only if registered with the ANC scheme or applying to it, accredited by UKAS, or testing only in Scotland and registered with the IOA (paragraph 4.5). Tell us which route you use, because insurers ask.
- Products. Members must not take commissions for recommending acoustic products, and must declare any commercial relationship with them (paragraph 4.4). Supplying products may also sit outside a consultancy wording.
- Review before issue. The ANC recommends that reports are reviewed and countersigned by a senior consultant or the principal before issue, and may take account of this if a member’s work is audited after a complaint (paragraphs 13.2 and 13.4). Insurers ask the same question on the proposal form.
- Mergers. Where one party to a merger or acquisition is not a member, membership is reviewed (paragraph 4.10). Review the insurance for both firms’ past work at the same time.
Where the figures really come from
Because the rules give no number, the figures that bind you are the ones you sign. Appointments and collateral warranties usually name the limit the client wants, often for each and every claim, and expect it to be kept in place for years after the work is finished. That clause is a promise in its own right. If your policy is written in the aggregate, carries a lower limit for some kinds of claim, or ends when you retire, you may be in breach of the appointment even though no claim has been made.
Before you sign, we compare the insurance clause with your schedule: the limit, whether it applies to each claim or in total for the year, any lower limits inside the policy, and how long you are promising to keep cover. Contract reviews
How to judge “appropriate and proportionate”
The test is the size of the largest realistic claim, not the size of the fee. Ask what it would cost if your work on your largest project were wrong.
- Residential schemes. Count the homes that rely on one floor or façade specification. The remedial cost multiplies by the plot.
- Planning reports. Think of glazing and ventilation fitted to finished homes, or a permission delayed or quashed.
- Construction noise. A wrong section 61 prediction can cost a contractor weeks of delay.
- Repeated details. A standard detail or model used on several sites could produce several claims in one year. An aggregate limit can be used up by the first.
- Defence costs. Acoustics disputes need expert evidence on measurement and prediction. Check whether costs are paid in addition to the limit or from within it.
Then set that figure beside the highest limit any current appointment requires. The higher of the two is the starting point.
How long the cover has to last
PI is written on a claims made basis, so the policy that responds is the one in force when the claim is made, not when the report was issued. Neither body says how long to keep cover, so the answer comes from your contracts and the law. Negligence claims not involving personal injury have a 15 year long stop (Limitation Act 1980, section 14B). Claims over dwellings under the Defective Premises Act 1972 can be brought for 15 years, or 30 where the right to claim arose before the change (Building Safety Act 2022, section 135). In URS v BDW the Supreme Court held that a consultant can owe that duty to a developer.
For a consultancy with residential work, the retroactive date should reach back to your earliest reports, and cover after closure should be planned for longer than the six years many firms assume. Run off cover explained
Where consultancies get caught
- Evidence is not a wording check. The ANC asks for evidence that insurance exists. Whether the policy’s description of your business matches every service you invoice is for you to check.
- New services mid year. Air quality, vibration monitoring, product supply or expert evidence may fall outside the description. Tell us before the first job.
- A retroactive date that moves. Incorporating, or changing insurer, can bring the date forward and leave old reports uninsured.
- Work in your own name. The IOA duty is personal. A private commission or a personal expert appointment may not be covered by your employer’s policy.
- Signing a limit you do not hold. The appointment asks for more than the schedule shows, and nobody compares the two until a claim.
Not sure your limit is proportionate?
Send us your schedule and your three largest appointments and we will tell you where they match and where they do not.
Related: PI for acoustic consultants · Run off cover · Contract reviews