We would like to set optional cookies to understand how the site is used. Essential cookies keep forms working. Cookie policy.

Home / Insights / The net contribution clause: what it protects an architect from, and where it fails

Insights for architects

The net contribution clause: what it protects an architect from, and where it fails

When a contractor becomes insolvent, the client looks to whoever is still insured. A net contribution clause is the term in your appointment meant to stop you paying the contractor’s share. Courts have upheld it. They have also found its limit.

Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.

The problem the clause solves

Building defects rarely have one author. A leaking roof may be partly a design fault, partly bad workmanship and partly a failure to spot it on inspection. Where an architect and a contractor are each liable for the same damage, the client can usually recover the whole loss from either of them. The one who pays may then claim a contribution from the other (Civil Liability (Contribution) Act 1978, section 1).

That right is only as good as the other party’s ability to pay. If the contractor has been wound up, the architect who was a small part of the problem can be left with all of the bill. A net contribution clause changes the starting point. It limits your liability to the client to your own fair share, worked out as if the others had paid theirs.

What the clause says

The clause considered in Vainker v Marbank came from RIBA’s standard conditions. It limited the architect’s liability to the sum that was “just and equitable” for the architect to pay, having regard to the extent of its responsibility. That sum was to be assessed on two assumptions: that the other consultants and contractors on the project had given the client undertakings no less onerous than the architect’s, and that each had paid the client its own just and equitable share ([2024] EWHC 667 (TCC), paragraph 26).

The assumptions do the work. Without them, a court asks what you are liable for. With them, it asks what you would have paid if everyone else had met their share, whether or not they ever do. A shorter, home made clause can aim at the same result, but every word will be tested. In West v Ian Finlay the argument was about whether “other consultants, contractors and specialists appointed by you” included the main contractor at all.

What the courts have decided

Two decisions on net contribution clauses in architects’ appointments
CaseThe factsWhat the court decided
West v Ian Finlay [2014] EWCA Civ 316Homeowners sued their architect over building work to their house. The main contractor had been wound up. The trial judge held the clause did not cover the contractor’s shareThe Court of Appeal held the words were clear and did cover the main contractor. The clause was not unfair under the consumer regulations then in force and was reasonable under the Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977
Vainker v Marbank [2024] EWHC 667 (TCC)Homeowners sued their contractor and their architect over defects in their house, including under the Defective Premises ActThe clause was part of the appointment and applied in contract and in negligence, without any contribution proceedings having been brought. But it could not be relied on for liability under the Defective Premises Act

The reason for the second result is in the statute. Section 6(3) of the Defective Premises Act makes void any term that excludes or restricts liability arising under the Act (Defective Premises Act 1972).

For consumer contracts made today the fairness test is in the Consumer Rights Act 2015. An unfair term does not bind the consumer, and fairness is judged on the circumstances when the term was agreed (Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 62).

Where the clause does not reach

  • Dwellings. On housing you may be pursued under the Defective Premises Act for the whole loss, whatever the appointment says.
  • People who never signed it. A funder, purchaser or tenant claims under a collateral warranty or third party rights, not under your appointment. If the clause is not repeated there, it may not apply to them.
  • Amended clauses. Clients’ solicitors often delete or narrow the clause. ARB’s renewal advice says net contribution clauses in the professional bodies’ standard appointments are encouraged and should not be amended (ARB, PII renewal advice).
  • Your own sub-consultants. The clause deals with others appointed by the client. A designer you appoint yourself is usually your responsibility as far as the client is concerned. Freelancers and sub-consultants
  • Consumers who were never told. With a homeowner, a clause buried in small print invites a fairness challenge. Make it plain, point it out and keep a record that you did.

How the clause sits with your PI

PI responds to your legal liability. The clause does not change the policy, but it changes the size of the liability the policy may be asked to meet. Three points follow.

  • The limit. Where the clause is missing, or cannot apply, the claim against you may be for the whole loss and not your share. Set the limit on that footing for housing work.
  • Warranties. Cover for collateral warranties is usually conditional on the beneficiary getting no greater or longer benefit than your client has. A warranty that leaves out a clause your appointment contains may give the beneficiary more than the client.
  • Rights of recovery. Some wordings exclude a claim where you have agreed to restrict your rights of recovery against another party. Waiving contribution rights, or accepting a sub-consultant’s low liability cap, can prejudice cover for the claim that follows.

ARB’s renewal advice also says you should be able to show insurers that you are not carrying liability for sub-consultants or other parties.

What to check before you sign

  1. Is the clause in the appointment, in the standard form’s own words?
  2. Is it repeated in every collateral warranty and third party rights schedule?
  3. If the client is a consumer, is the clause prominent, explained and recorded as discussed?
  4. Is the project a dwelling? If so, assume the clause will not limit a Defective Premises Act claim.
  5. Do your sub-consultants carry their own PI, and have you kept your rights against them?
  6. Has the client’s solicitor amended the clause? Send us the wording before you agree it. Contract reviews

Asked to delete your net contribution clause?

Send us the appointment before you agree, and we will flag the insurance points while you can still negotiate.

Speak to a PI specialistPI for architects

Related: PI for architects · Contract reviews · Freelancers and sub-consultants