Home / Insights / Home survey claims: the missed defect, the repair quotation and your PI
Insights for building surveyors
Home survey claims: the missed defect, the repair quotation and your PI
Most claims against a residential building surveyor start the same way: a buyer finds a defect, gets a builder’s quotation and writes to complain. How you answer in the first week, and what your report said about further investigation, decide most of what follows.
Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.
How a home survey claim usually arrives
The first letter rarely looks like a claim. It comes under your complaints handling procedure, months or years after the inspection, with photographs and a builder’s quotation attached. It asks for the cost of repairs, the survey fee back and something for the upheaval.
For insurance purposes it is a claim, or at least a circumstance, from the day it arrives. The RICS minimum terms bar admissions and offers without insurers’ consent, whatever your complaints procedure says and even where the sum is below the excess (RICS, PII requirements and minimum wording). A refund with an apology, sent to close the complaint, can prejudice cover for the larger claim behind it.
What the surveyor is judged against
The RICS Home Survey Standard has set mandatory requirements for members’ residential surveys since 1 March 2021, with three levels of service (RICS, Home survey standard). The first edition still applies. RICS intends to publish the second in the first quarter of 2027 (RICS update, September 2026). Claims usually turn on four questions.
- Level. Did the level of service sold suit the age, type and condition of the property?
- Terms. Were the terms of engagement agreed before the inspection, and do they say what the service leaves out? The standard requires them to say it does not include an asbestos inspection.
- What could be seen. What do the site notes, photographs and readings show was visible and accessible on the day?
- What came next. Where the surveyor could not see, did the report say so plainly and tell the client to investigate before committing to buy?
The last question is the one that decides the largest claims.
Repair bill or loss in value: how the claim is measured
Claimants lead with the repair quotation. The conventional measure is different: the gap between the property’s value in the condition reported and its value in the condition that should have been reported. The Court of Appeal restated this in Large v Hart, noting that the higher cost of repair is not the measure ([2021] EWCA Civ 24).
The same case shows how the measure can widen. In 2011 a surveyor gave a HomeBuyer Report on a rebuilt house in Devon, bought for £1.2 million. He did not report that he could not see the damp proofing, did not recommend further investigation and did not advise that a professional consultant’s certificate was essential. The judge found that with proper advice the buyers would not have bought. He assessed the loss on the property’s value with every defect that in fact existed, including those the surveyor could not have seen: £750,000 before credit for sums recovered from others, plus £15,000 for distress and inconvenience. The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal, while stressing that the facts were unusual.
What the policy does with each demand
One letter usually mixes several demands. Each meets the policy differently, and the answer always depends on your own wording.
| Demand | How PI usually treats it |
|---|---|
| Repair costs or loss in value | The core of the cover: your civil liability for the professional work. The argument is usually about value, not the quotation. |
| Return of the survey fee | Wordings differ on whether a fee refund is covered at all. Check yours, and do not refund before insurers agree. |
| Distress and inconvenience | Usually claimed as part of the damages. In Large v Hart this head was £15,000, beside £750,000 for loss in value. |
| An ombudsman or redress scheme award | Cover for awards usually depends on prompt notice of the referral. Tell us the day a complaint is escalated. |
| The excess | Yours to bear on each claim. For limits up to £10 million, RICS caps it at the greater of 2.5% of the sum insured or £10,000. |
How late a claim can come
A survey claim can arrive long after the fee is forgotten. A negligence claim can be brought within three years of the buyer having the knowledge needed to sue, if that is later than six years from when the claim arose (Limitation Act 1980, section 14A), subject to a 15 year long stop (section 14B).
PI is written on a claims made basis, so the policy that answers is the one in force when the complaint arrives, not the one in force on the day of the inspection. Two things follow. Keep site notes, photographs, terms and reports for the whole period. And when you retire or close, remember that the automatic run off in the RICS minimum terms is for consumer claims: £1,000,000 in all for six years. Run off cover explained
What to do in the first week
- Send us the complaint, the terms of engagement and the report the day it arrives, so insurers are notified at once.
- Acknowledge the complaint within your procedure’s time limit, without commenting on fault, the defect or the quotation.
- Secure the file: site notes, photographs, moisture readings, emails and the record of which level of service was agreed, and when.
- Do not revisit the property, instruct a builder or offer a refund unless insurers have agreed.
- Mark what the report said about concealed areas and further investigation. That passage is usually the centre of the defence.
- If the complaint is referred to an ombudsman or redress scheme, tell us the same day.
Hammond PI has specialised in professional indemnity since 1990. We put the matter to insurers in the right form and stay involved until it is closed. How we support claims
A complaint about a survey on your desk?
Send it to us before you reply, and we will help you answer the complaint and protect your cover at the same time.
Related: PI for building surveyors · Claims support · Run off cover