Home / Insights / Liability caps and reliance wording in a building surveyor’s terms of engagement
Insights for building surveyors
Liability caps and reliance wording in a building surveyor’s terms of engagement
RICS recommends that firms cap their liability and limit who may rely on a report. Whether those two clauses hold depends on who the client is, when the terms were agreed and who else has seen your work. Neither is a substitute for the policy.
Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.
A cap and a limit of indemnity are different things
RICS recommends that regulated firms use liability caps where the law allows, and that terms of engagement say advice may be relied on only by the named client (RICS, Risk, liability and insurance). Many building surveyors have both clauses in their standard terms and rarely look at them again.
A cap is agreed with your client at the start. It limits what that client can recover from you. Your limit of indemnity is agreed with your insurer and limits what the insurer pays. They are set with different people, on different dates, for different purposes. Where a cap fails, or the claimant never agreed to it, the limit of indemnity is what stands behind the practice.
Business clients: the reasonableness test
With a business client, a term restricting liability for negligence, other than for death or personal injury, works only so far as it satisfies the requirement of reasonableness (Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977, section 2). Section 11 says how that is judged.
- When. By the circumstances known to, or contemplated by, the parties when the contract was made, not when the claim arrives.
- A fixed sum. Where liability is limited to a specified sum, regard is had to the resources the firm could expect to have to meet the liability, and to whether it could have covered itself by insurance.
- Proof. It is for the firm relying on the term to show that it is reasonable.
So a cap is tested partly against your insurance. A cap of the fee, set by a practice that carries a far larger limit of indemnity, may be harder to defend than one set with the instruction and the cover in mind. The drafting is for your solicitors. We can tell you what the policy would support.
Consumer clients: a harder test
Most home survey clients are consumers, and the rules differ. A term cannot exclude your liability for failing to use reasonable care and skill, and cannot restrict it so that the consumer is unable to recover the price paid (Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 57).
Any other limit is open to the fairness test. A term is unfair, and does not bind the consumer, if contrary to the requirement of good faith it causes a significant imbalance in the parties’ rights and obligations to the consumer’s detriment. Fairness is judged by the circumstances when the term was agreed (section 62).
Timing matters most in practice. Terms sent with the report may be harder to rely on than terms the client accepted before the inspection. Keep the dated acceptance, and put the cap where a buyer will read it.
Who else can rely on the report
A cap binds the person who agreed to it. A lender, a later buyer, a funder or a tenant who relies on your report has agreed nothing unless you make it a condition. RICS advises firms to allow wider reliance only on recorded terms that bind the third party to the engagement, including any cap.
The courts decide whether a duty is owed to someone outside the contract. In Scullion v Bank of Scotland the Court of Appeal declined to extend the duty a lender’s valuer can owe to the buyer of a modest home to a buy to let investor ([2011] EWCA Civ 693). A building surveyor meets the same question with reliance letters on project monitoring, schedules of condition passed to lenders, and EWS1 forms read by people who never instructed the practice.
Each warranty or reliance letter you sign creates a new claimant on its own terms.
How the terms and the policy fit together
| In your terms | What to set it against in the policy |
|---|---|
| The level of the cap | Your limit of indemnity, and whether it is any one claim or aggregate. A cap above your limit can leave the difference with the practice. |
| Fire safety or external wall advice | The separate fire safety limit, which under the RICS minimum terms is aggregate with defence costs inside it. A cap equal to your main limit may be far above it. |
| A reliance letter to a lender or funder | Whether the letter binds the recipient to the engagement terms and the cap. |
| A collateral warranty | How many assignments it allows. The RICS minimum terms restrict assignment: two for a funder’s warranty, one otherwise. |
| A promise beyond reasonable skill and care | Fitness for purpose, express guarantees and liquidated damages are liabilities the minimum terms need not cover, with or without a cap. |
Before you issue terms or sign a letter
- Agree terms before the inspection or the first site visit, and keep the dated acceptance on the file.
- Set the cap by type of instruction, with your limit of indemnity and any separate aggregate limits in view.
- State who may rely on the report, and that no one else may without your written agreement.
- Give reliance letters only on terms that bind the recipient to the engagement, including the cap.
- Send us any appointment, warranty or reliance letter that departs from your standard terms before you sign it.
We read your terms of engagement alongside the policy wording, so the two are set with each other in mind. Contract reviews
Asked to sign a reliance letter or warranty?
Send it to us first, with your terms of engagement, and we will flag the insurance points before you commit.
Related: PI for building surveyors · Contract reviews · Freelancers and subconsultants