---
title: "Fitness for purpose and contractors’ PI: where cover stops"
description: "PI insures reasonable skill and care. Many contracts ask for a result. How fitness for purpose terms arise, how courts read them and what to check."
url: "https://www.hammondpi.com/insights/contractors-fitness-for-purpose-pi/"
updated: "2026-11-20T06:10:05.236Z"
---

[Home](https://www.hammondpi.com/index.md) / [Insights](https://www.hammondpi.com/insights.md) / Fitness for purpose: the design promise a contractor’s PI may not follow

Insights for design and build contractors

# Fitness for purpose: the design promise a contractor’s PI may not follow

A contractor’s PI insures a failure of reasonable skill and care. Many building contracts ask for something else: a result. The distance between the two promises is uninsured unless you find it and close it before you sign.

Two standardsThe leading caseStandard formsWhere it hidesYour coverBefore you sign

Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.

## Two promises that sound alike

A designer who promises reasonable skill and care promises to do the job as a competent member of the profession would. If the design fails although it was competently done, there is no breach. A contractor who promises that the works will be fit for their purpose, will meet a performance specification or will last a stated number of years promises the result. If the result is not achieved there is a breach, however careful the design.

Consultants almost always give the first promise. Contractors are regularly asked for the second. PI for contractors is built around the first. Wordings usually exclude liability that is more onerous than the ordinary duty of skill and care, including guarantees and warranties of fitness for purpose.

## How the Supreme Court read a contract with both

In _MT Højgaard v E.ON_ the contractor designed and installed the foundations for an offshore wind farm at Robin Rigg in the Solway Firth ([\[2017\] UKSC 59](https://caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/uksc/2017/59)). It followed an international design standard, which was later found to contain an error that overstated the strength of the grouted connections by a factor of about ten. The connections failed, and the parties agreed remedial works costing €26.25 million.

The trial judge rejected the allegation of negligence. The contractor was held liable all the same, because the technical requirements also said the design “shall ensure a lifetime of 20 years in every aspect without planned replacement”. The Supreme Court held that where two provisions set different standards, the more demanding one prevails. The design standard was a minimum, not a defence.

The lesson for a building contractor is about reading, not about wind farms. One sentence in a technical schedule decided the case, although the contractor had followed the design standard the contract prescribed.

## What JCT and NEC say before anyone amends them

The standard forms start on the contractor’s side. The 2024 JCT Design and Build Contract says that, to the extent the Statutory Requirements permit, the contractor has no greater duty than reasonable skill and care and is not held to a fitness for purpose requirement for design ([Ashfords, JCT DB 2024 guide](https://www.ashfords.co.uk/insights/articles/jct-design-build-contract-2024-released-a-summary-guide-for-employers-and-contractors)). Commentators note that the opening words leave room for argument about duties that statute imposes ([Mills & Reeve, JCT DB 2024 design liability](https://www.mills-reeve.com/blogs/construction/august-2024/jct-d-b-2024-design-liability-and-fitness-for-purp/)). One such duty is clear. For dwellings, the Defective Premises Act requires work to be done so that the dwelling is fit for habitation, and any term that tries to exclude that duty is void ([Defective Premises Act 1972](https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1972/35)).

NEC4 reaches a similar place by option. Secondary option X15 sets the design duty at the skill and care normally used by professionals designing similar works, so check whether it has been selected. NEC’s own guidance says cover for a fitness for purpose standard is unlikely to be available ([NEC, insurance guidance](https://www.neccontract.com/news/insurance-what-every-ecc-pm-should-know)).

The printed form is rarely what you sign. In _Martlet Homes v Mulalley_ an amended JCT contract imposed an unqualified design duty, and the judge rejected the contractor’s argument that the owner had to prove professional negligence ([\[2022\] EWHC 1813 (TCC)](https://caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ewhc/tcc/2022/1813)).

## Where the stricter promise hides

Where fitness for purpose obligations appear in contract documents

Document

What the words look like

The question to ask

Schedule of amendments

The design duty clause is replaced, or the statement that there is no fitness for purpose requirement is deleted

Is reasonable skill and care still the only design standard?

Employer’s Requirements

A design life, load, energy or acoustic figure stated as something the works “shall” achieve

Is it a target to design towards, or a result you guarantee?

Priority clauses

Requirements described as minimums, or the more onerous document made to prevail

Which document wins if two standards differ?

Collateral warranties

A warranty that the works will be fit for purpose or will comply with the Employer’s Requirements

Does it promise more than the building contract?

Subcontracts

Main contract terms passed down in full to a design subcontractor

Does the specialist’s own PI follow the promise it is giving you?

Mills & Reeve draw a useful line between designing for fitness for purpose and promising that goods, materials and workmanship are fit for purpose. The second is an ordinary construction obligation. It belongs with workmanship, which PI does not usually insure.

## What the policy usually does

In most wordings the contractual liability exclusion is not all or nothing. Cover usually remains to the extent you would have been liable without the onerous term. In practice the claim is examined twice: once on the contract, where the employer needs only to show the result was not achieved, and once on negligence, where the question is whether the design fell below reasonable skill and care.

Where both are present, the policy may respond to the negligent part. Where the design was competent and only the guarantee was broken, there may be no cover at all. Either way, notify in full, because the two are often impossible to separate until experts have reported. [The clause guide](https://www.hammondpi.com/clauses.md) sets out how the exclusion is usually worded.

## What to do at tender

1.  Search the amendments, the Employer’s Requirements and every warranty for “fit for purpose”, “shall ensure”, “guarantee” and stated design lives.
2.  Ask for results to be redrafted as design objectives: the contractor will use reasonable skill and care to design the works to achieve the stated performance.
3.  Where the employer will not move, decide knowingly. A promise outside the policy is a balance sheet risk, and the board should know its size.
4.  Match your consultants’ appointments to what you have accepted. If they promise only skill and care and you have promised a result, the difference stays with you.
5.  Send us the documents before signature. [We read them for the insurance points](https://www.hammondpi.com/contract-reviews.md) and tell you which promises the policy may not follow.

## Fitness for purpose in your tender?

Send us the amendments before you sign and we will show you which promises may sit outside your policy.

[Speak to a PI specialist](https://www.hammondpi.com/contact.md)[PI for design and build contractors](https://www.hammondpi.com/who-we-cover/design-and-build-contractors.md)

Related: [PI for design and build contractors](https://www.hammondpi.com/who-we-cover/design-and-build-contractors.md) · [Contract reviews](https://www.hammondpi.com/contract-reviews.md) · [The clause guide](https://www.hammondpi.com/clauses.md)
