Home / Insights / Practising Rule 9: what the CLSB requires of a Costs Lawyer’s PI
Insights for legal service providers
Practising Rule 9: what the CLSB requires of a Costs Lawyer’s PI
The CLSB’s insurance rule is two sentences long. The first sets a floor of £100,000. The second, which matters more, makes each Costs Lawyer personally responsible for deciding how far above that floor the cover needs to go.
Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.
What Practising Rule 9 says
Rule 9.1 of the CLSB Practising Rules has two limbs. A Costs Lawyer must practise with the benefit of professional indemnity insurance of at least £100,000 for any one claim, to include loss of documents. A Costs Lawyer must also, on an ongoing basis, assess all the financial risk of the work they undertake and make sure that cover is in place above the minimum, at a level commensurate with that risk (CLSB, Practising Rules, version 4, 1 August 2020).
The rule has teeth. Insurance in accordance with Rule 9 is one of the four conditions of the right to practise in Rule 1.1. The CLSB will refuse a practising certificate to an applicant who has not shown that the condition is met, and may revoke a certificate if it stops being met.
A rule for individuals, not firms
The CLSB regulates people. A costs law firm is usually an unregulated business, and the rule bites on each Costs Lawyer inside it. The CLSB’s guidance note accepts that many Costs Lawyers are covered by their organisation’s policy, but says it is the individual’s responsibility to check that the policy adequately covers the work they do (CLSB guidance note, Indemnity Insurance, 8 April 2024).
- In an SRA regulated firm. The firm insures under the SRA’s rules and you are unlikely to need more, but the guidance still asks you to confirm that the policy covers your role and employment status.
- In an unregulated costs firm, or in house. The firm’s policy is your compliance. Ask to see the schedule and the wording.
- Between roles. The CLSB reads “practise with the benefit of” to mean that cover is not required while you are not actively practising. It adds that this does not remove the need for run off.
Law costs draftsmen who are not Costs Lawyers fall outside the rule. Their liability to an instructing solicitor is no smaller for that.
What the CLSB fixes and what it leaves to you
| Point | What the CLSB says | What is left to you |
|---|---|---|
| Minimum limit | £100,000 for any one claim, a level the guidance describes as broadly suited to a practice doing relatively low risk work | The real limit, under Rule 9.1(b) |
| Loss of documents | Must be included, at the minimum and above it | Any sub limit and conditions in the wording |
| Insurer | Open market. The CLSB keeps no list of participating insurers | The insurer and the wording |
| Policy terms | No minimum terms. The policy must not stop you following your complaints procedure or being open with the Legal Ombudsman or the CLSB | Whether Legal Ombudsman awards are covered, which the guidance gives as an example of a term you might need |
| Excess | Not specified | The level your practice can carry |
| Run off | Not mandated. At least six years after you cease to practise is recommended | The length, and what happens if a successor practice takes over your matters |
| Evidence | Requested at each practising certificate renewal, unless you work in an SRA regulated organisation | Keeping cover valid all year and telling the CLSB of any problem obtaining it |
How to assess the risk under Rule 9.1(b)
The guidance says there are no hard and fast rules, and reports that over 90% of Costs Lawyers buy cover above the minimum. It lists factors to weigh. They are also what an underwriter asks about.
- The number of clients you have and who they are.
- The value of your typical work and the probable maximum loss if something went wrong.
- Who you could be liable to: the instructing solicitor, the underlying client, or both.
- Your past claims, by value and type.
- The typical errors: a missed court deadline and the sanction that follows, a bill that undervalues the costs entitlement, a point of dispute not taken, a hearing not attended, a budget that underestimates costs and limits recovery.
- Supervision of junior colleagues, outsourcing, and the loss a data breach could cause your clients.
One costs budget can govern recovery in a claim worth many times your annual fees. We would start from your largest single instruction, not your turnover.
Where Costs Lawyers get caught
- Assuming the firm’s policy fits. A schedule that describes the business as bill drafting may not describe costs litigation, advocacy at assessment hearings or budgeting. Read the description against what you do.
- Delegation. The CLSB’s guidance of 2 November 2026 on delegation and supervision says the policy a Costs Lawyer relies on must extend to the outcome of delegated tasks. Work done by unauthorised colleagues under your direction needs to sit inside the same policy.
- What you tell clients. The guidance expects you to tell clients your current level of PI, including loss of documents cover, and that adequate cover will be in place throughout the instruction. A client care letter that states a figure needs updating when the figure changes.
- Complaints. PI wordings usually ask you not to admit liability without consent. The CLSB treats a policy that prevents you following your complaints procedure as unsuitable. The two have to be squared before a complaint arrives, not during it.
- Moving on. Run off is recommended, not required, so nobody will ask you for it. A sole practitioner who stops without it has no policy for the claim that arrives later. Run off cover explained
Five checks on your schedule
- Is every Costs Lawyer who relies on the policy within its definition of the insured, including consultants?
- Is the limit any one claim, and does it reflect your largest instruction and not the £100,000 floor?
- Is loss of documents included, and with what sub limit?
- Does the business description cover costs litigation, advocacy and budgeting as well as drafting bills?
- Does the wording let you follow your complaints procedure and cooperate with the Legal Ombudsman and the CLSB?
Relying on a firm’s policy for Rule 9?
Send us the schedule and wording and we will tell you how they measure against the rule and the work you actually do.
Related: PI for legal services and will writers · The clause guide · Renewal