---
title: "Fitness for purpose clauses and engineers’ PI cover"
description: "Where fitness for purpose and performance terms hide in engineers’ appointments, how PI wordings commonly treat them, and what to ask for instead."
url: "https://www.hammondpi.com/insights/engineers-fitness-for-purpose-clauses/"
updated: "2026-11-20T06:10:05.064Z"
---

[Home](https://www.hammondpi.com/index.md) / [Insights](https://www.hammondpi.com/insights.md) / Fitness for purpose: the contract term that can outrun an engineer’s PI

Insights for engineers

# Fitness for purpose: the contract term that can outrun an engineer’s PI

PI is built around reasonable skill and care. Contractors’ appointments and funders’ warranties often ask an engineer to promise the result. The difference can be one sentence in a technical schedule, and it can decide whether a claim is insured.

Two standardsRobin RiggWhere it hidesThe exclusionSafer wordingAlready signed

Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.

## Reasonable skill and care, and the promise of a result

If your appointment says nothing, the law fills the gap. A business supplying a service must carry it out with reasonable care and skill ([Supply of Goods and Services Act 1982, section 13](https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1982/29/section/13)), and the same term is written into consumer contracts ([Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 49](https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2015/15/section/49)). An engineer who designs carefully, to the standards of the day, has met that duty even if the structure later disappoints. In _Lendlease v Aecom_ the court treated the engineer’s duty as reasonable skill and care, not guaranteed compliance ([\[2023\] EWHC 2620 (TCC)](https://caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ewhc/tcc/2023/2620)).

A fitness for purpose term is different in kind. It promises that the design will work: carry the load, last the design life, meet the performance specification. If it does not, you are in breach, however careful you were. Contractors usually owe their employers something close to this, and they try to pass it down to their designers.

## What happened at Robin Rigg

The leading case is _MT Højgaard v E.ON_ ([\[2017\] UKSC 59](https://caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/uksc/2017/59)). A contractor designed and installed the foundations for offshore wind turbines at Robin Rigg in the Solway Firth, completing in February 2009. It used reasonable skill and care and followed the recognised international standard. The standard contained an error: one value was wrong by a factor of about ten, so the strength of the grouted connections was overestimated. They began to fail in April 2010, and remedial works were agreed at €26.25 million.

The contract required compliance with the standard. A paragraph of its technical requirements also said the design must ensure a lifetime of 20 years. The Court of Appeal thought that paragraph “too slender a thread” to carry a 20 year warranty. In August 2017 the Supreme Court disagreed and held the contractor liable. Under this contract, it said, the more demanding of the two requirements must prevail, and courts are generally inclined to give full effect to a requirement that the finished item meets stated criteria.

The defendant was a contractor, not a consultant. But the lesson for engineers is in where the obligation sat: not in the conditions, but in a schedule few people read as a legal document.

## Where the term hides in an engineer’s paperwork

The words “fitness for purpose” rarely appear. Look for these.

Contract wording that can create a fitness for purpose obligation, and how PI wordings commonly treat it

Wording you may see

What it asks of you

How PI wordings commonly treat it

“Fit for the purposes set out in the Employer’s Requirements”

A result, whatever care you took

Commonly excluded as a guarantee, or as liability greater than the law would impose

“Shall ensure” or “shall achieve” a design life or performance specification

The same promise as at Robin Rigg, often in a technical schedule

Usually treated in the same way. Check for an exclusion of express guarantees

“Shall comply with” all statutes and standards, with no qualification

Absolute compliance, not reasonable steps towards it

May fall outside cover unless qualified by reasonable skill and care

An indemnity for all losses “arising from” your services

Liability without proof of negligence, and for losses a court might not award

Commonly excluded so far as it goes beyond liability for negligence

A warranty in wider words than the appointment

A greater or longer lasting benefit than your client has

Warranties are usually covered only where the benefit is no greater or longer lasting

## How the contractual liability exclusion works

Engineers’ wordings commonly exclude liability you have assumed under a contract that goes beyond the liability you would have had without it. Many also exclude express guarantees and liquidated damages. Cover is usually given back for collateral warranties, but only where the benefit is no greater or longer lasting than your client’s.

In practice insurers split a claim in two. If the design was also negligent, the policy may respond to that part, because you would have been liable anyway. The gap is the claim where you took proper care and the result still failed. That is the claim a fitness for purpose term creates, and it is the one that may fall to the practice itself.

How any one policy treats a given clause depends on its exact words, which is why we read the clause and the exclusion side by side. [The clause guide](https://www.hammondpi.com/clauses.md)

## What to ask for instead

-   An overriding clause: whatever else the contract, its schedules or the Employer’s Requirements say, your duty is to use reasonable skill and care.
-   “Using reasonable skill and care to see that the design complies with”, in place of “shall ensure”.
-   An order of precedence that puts the appointment conditions above technical schedules and specifications.
-   In a warranty, a clause that you owe no greater duty, for no longer, than under the appointment, with the same defences.
-   Indemnities limited to loss caused by your negligence.
-   If the client will not move, we put the exact wording to insurers and ask for their written agreement before you sign, not after a claim.

## If you have already signed

Most practices have a few of these terms in the drawer. Do not leave them there. List the contracts, the wording and the projects behind them, and tell us before renewal. IStructE’s guidance asks members to tell insurers the precise nature of services provided to a contractor, whose own duty may be stricter than reasonable skill and care ([IStructE, responsibilities of a member](https://www.istructe.org/about-us/istructe-code-of-conduct/responsibilities-of-a-member/)).

Insurers can sometimes agree to a named contract once they have seen it, and a clear account of what you sign and who reviews it helps the whole presentation. If a claim arrives on one of these contracts, tell us at once and we will ask insurers to confirm which allegations they will defend.

## Been sent an appointment or warranty to sign?

Send it to us first and we will mark the terms that may sit outside your cover before you commit.

[Speak to a PI specialist](https://www.hammondpi.com/contact.md)[PI for engineers](https://www.hammondpi.com/who-we-cover/civil-and-structural-engineers.md)

Related: [PI for engineers](https://www.hammondpi.com/who-we-cover/civil-and-structural-engineers.md) · [Contract reviews](https://www.hammondpi.com/contract-reviews.md) · [The clause guide](https://www.hammondpi.com/clauses.md)
