We would like to set optional cookies to understand how the site is used. Essential cookies keep forms working. Cookie policy.

Home / Insights / How much PI must an engineering practice hold? Institutions, appointments and warranties

Insights for engineers

How much PI must an engineering practice hold? Institutions, appointments and warranties

Some professions are handed a minimum limit by their regulator. Engineers are not. Your institution expects appropriate cover, and your appointments and warranties decide the figure, the basis and the number of years. Here is how to read both.

Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.

What ICE, IStructE and the Engineering Council say

None of the three sets a minimum limit, an approved wording, a maximum excess or a run off rule. What they ask for is suitable cover and honesty with the client about it.

What the engineering institutions say about professional indemnity insurance
BodyWhat it saysWhat it leaves to you
IStructEMembers must comply where the law requires PI. Before accepting a commission they should tell the client if PI is not in place or the amount is inadequate for the services (IStructE, responsibilities of a member).The limit, the basis, the excess and how long cover is kept
ICEGuidance to Rule 1: members should, where appropriate, obtain PI for the risks and liabilities that could arise from the work, advise clients before the project starts if it is not in place, and set out the risks in writing (ICE, Code of Professional Conduct).What is “appropriate” for your work, and every policy term
Engineering CouncilUK-SPEC HRB is a competence standard for engineers working on higher-risk buildings. The standard page we read sets no PI limit (Engineering Council, UK-SPEC HRB).Everything about insurance. Registration does not replace PI

IStructE’s guidance adds one point that matters at renewal. Where you provide services to a contractor, whose own duty may be stricter than reasonable skill and care, you should tell insurers the precise nature of those services.

Where the real requirement sits: the insurance clause

The binding requirement is the insurance clause in each appointment, collateral warranty and framework agreement. It usually makes five separate promises, and each needs checking against your schedule.

  • The amount. A stated limit of indemnity. A warranty sometimes asks for more than the appointment behind it.
  • The basis. “Each and every claim” or “in the aggregate”. Your policy may give one basis for most work and another, usually aggregate, for fire safety, pollution or asbestos.
  • The period. Cover maintained for a number of years after completion, commonly six or twelve.
  • The proviso. Many clauses say cover need only be kept while it is available at commercially reasonable rates. Whether that helps you depends on the drafting, and some clauses leave it out.
  • The evidence. Proof of cover on request, and often a duty to tell the client if cover lapses or cannot be renewed on the promised terms.

A promise your policy does not match can leave you in breach of contract, and that breach is not usually an insured loss. Wordings commonly exclude liability you take on by contract beyond what the law would impose.

How long the promise, and the liability, last

The six and twelve year figures come from the law of limitation. A claim under an appointment signed under hand must be brought within six years of the breach (Limitation Act 1980, section 5). Where the appointment is executed as a deed, it is twelve (section 8). Most collateral warranties are deeds.

The contract period is not the end of the exposure. Negligence claims for damage discovered late face an overriding limit of 15 years (section 14B). Claims over dwellings under the Defective Premises Act can be brought for 15 years, or 30 where the claim accrued before 28 June 2022 (Building Safety Act 2022, section 135). PI is claims made, so a policy must be in force when the claim arrives, which is why retirement and closure need planning. Run off cover explained

Where practices get caught

  • Warranties signed years ago promise an each and every claim limit for all work, while today’s fire safety cover is aggregate.
  • The limit is copied from the last project, not checked against the largest promise in the current register.
  • The insurance clause has no commercially reasonable rates proviso, so the promise stands even if the market withdraws the cover.
  • A new role is accepted, such as principal designer or temporary works checking, that falls outside the policy’s description of the business.
  • Work for design and build contractors grows, but the proposal still describes the practice as it was five years ago.
  • The practice closes with twelve year warranties still running and no run off arranged.

Working out the limit when nobody sets it

Start with the largest realistic claim, not your fee. For a structural design that is the cost of putting the structure right, plus delay and loss of use, and it bears little relation to what you were paid.

Then test three things. First, the highest limit any live appointment or warranty promises. Second, whether defence costs are paid in addition to the limit or inside it, section by section. Third, aggregation: a standard connection detail or foundation design repeated across many plots may be treated as one claim with one limit, however many owners claim. A limit that satisfies every contract can still be too low for the work.

Keep a register of what you have promised

  1. List every appointment, warranty and third party rights schedule, with the completion date and whether it was signed as a deed.
  2. Against each, record the limit promised, the basis, the period and whether the proviso is there.
  3. Compare the register with your schedule and endorsements before each renewal, and tell us where they differ.
  4. Where a gap cannot be closed, take your solicitor’s advice on what to tell the beneficiary.
  5. On new work, promise only the cover you hold. Send us the insurance clause before you sign.

Not sure your limit matches your contracts?

Send us your schedule and your three most demanding appointments and we will compare them clause by clause.

Speak to a PI specialistPI for engineers

Related: PI for engineers · Contract reviews · Renewal