Home / Insights / Liability caps in environmental consultants’ appointments: what makes them hold
Insights for environmental consultants
Liability caps in environmental consultants’ appointments: what makes them hold
Your fee is measured in thousands and the site in millions. The liability cap in your appointment is the one term that brings the two back into proportion. Three decisions show what makes a cap hold, and how easily one is lost.
Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.
Why the cap matters more for environmental work
A desk study or site investigation can support the purchase and development of land worth many times the fee. If the report is wrong, the loss claimed is the cost of putting the site right and the delay while that happens. A cap written into the appointment limits that liability to a figure both sides knew at the start.
It also needs to fit your insurance. Many PI wordings put pollution and asbestos claims under sub-limits lower than the main limit. A cap set at the main limit may therefore sit above the cover available for the claims you are most likely to face.
Three decisions on consultants’ caps
| Decision | The term | What the court decided |
|---|---|---|
| Persimmon Homes v Ove Arup, Court of Appeal, 2017 | Liability limited to £12 million overall, with pollution and contamination limited to £5 million in the aggregate and any claim in relation to asbestos excluded. | The words were clear. They were not confined to causing contamination, and reached claims that the engineers had failed to identify asbestos. |
| Elvanite Full Circle v AMEC Earth and Environmental, High Court, 2013 | An environmental consultant’s terms limited liability to the fees paid or £50,000, whichever was less, and required claims to be filed within one year of substantial completion. | The judge found the terms incorporated and reasonable, and held that the time bar prevented any recovery. The claim also failed on its facts. |
| Arcadis Consulting v AMEC (BCS), Court of Appeal, 2018 | Design work began under letters while a framework agreement was still being negotiated. It was never signed. | The trial judge found that no cap applied, on a claim put at about £40 million. The Court of Appeal held that the interim contract carried the limit in the terms the parties had been working under. |
The judgments: Persimmon v Arup [2017] EWCA Civ 373, Elvanite v AMEC [2013] EWHC 1191 (TCC) and Arcadis v AMEC [2018] EWCA Civ 2222.
What makes a cap reasonable
A term restricting liability for negligence is valid only so far as it is reasonable, and liability for death or personal injury caused by negligence cannot be restricted at all (Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977, section 2). The test is whether the term was a fair and reasonable one to include when the contract was made. Where a term limits liability to a fixed sum, the Act directs attention to the resources you could expect to have to meet the liability and how far it was open to you to cover yourself by insurance. It is for the party relying on the term to show that it is reasonable (section 11).
In Elvanite the judge relied on four things: the parties were in broadly equal bargaining positions, the client was not induced to agree, it knew the terms and raised no objection, and limits of this kind are common in such contracts. Each case turns on its own facts. A cap that is reasonable against a developer may be judged differently against a small landowner, so take advice on your own terms.
Getting the cap into the contract
- Send your terms with the fee proposal, not with the report or the invoice.
- Get a signature or a written acceptance that refers to the terms. In Elvanite the client’s director had signed an order confirmation saying he had read and accepted them.
- Do not start on a letter of intent or an email that is silent on liability. In Arcadis the limit was recovered only on appeal.
- If the client insists on its own form of appointment, carry the cap into that form. A client’s appointment usually replaces your terms altogether.
- Say whether the cap is a total for the appointment or applies to each claim, and consider a separate figure for pollution, contamination and asbestos, as the Persimmon agreement had.
- Keep the proposal, the terms and the acceptance for as long as a claim could be brought.
Where caps leak
- Reliance letters and warranties. A letter on a lender’s or purchaser’s own form, with no cap, may give that party a claim free of the limit your client accepted. Say that the cap applies to the appointment and every letter given under it, taken together.
- Time bars. The words matter. In Elvanite the judge held that “filed” did not require court proceedings, but did require something akin to a letter of claim. An earlier letter giving notice was not enough.
- Sub-contractors. If you accept a laboratory’s or driller’s cap at the price of its work while owing the client far more, the gap stays with you.
- Later instructions. A second phase or an update commissioned by email may not be on your original terms unless you say so.
How the cap sits with your policy
A cap does not replace insurance. A capped claim still has to be defended, and a term can be challenged. What the cap does is narrow the distance between what you could owe and what your policy provides.
Three clauses in most PI wordings are worth reading beside your terms. The contractual liability exclusion usually removes cover for liability you accept beyond what the law would impose, such as guarantees and fitness for purpose. Cover for warranties and reliance letters is often given only where the benefit is no greater or longer lasting than your client’s. And some wordings exclude claims where you have agreed to restrict your rights of recovery against a third party, which a sub-contractor’s cap may do. Hammond PI reads these clauses against your standard terms. The clause guide
Asked to sign without your cap?
Send us the appointment or reliance letter before you sign, and we will flag the insurance points while they can still be changed.
Related: PI for environmental consultants · Contract reviews · The clause guide