Home / Insights / Missed contamination: how the claim is argued and what your PI does
Insights for environmental consultants
Missed contamination: how the claim is argued and what your PI does
A Phase 2 report says the ground is clean. Two years later the earthworks contractor says otherwise. This is the claim that defines environmental consultancy, and three documents decide it: your appointment, your report and your policy wording.
Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.
Why a small report carries a large claim
A site investigation report is rarely read once. The client buys the land on it, the planning authority discharges conditions on it, and a lender or purchaser may rely on it later. National planning policy expects adequate site assessment information prepared by a competent person, and says responsibility for securing a safe development rests with the developer or landowner (NPPF, policy P2). When the ground proves worse than reported, that developer looks to you.
Statute sharpens the point. Under Part 2A of the Environmental Protection Act 1990, remediation falls first on whoever caused or knowingly permitted the contamination. If no such person is found, it falls on the current owner or occupier (section 78F). A client who buys on your report may be buying that liability.
The loss follows the site, not your fee: specialist soil disposal, redesign and a stalled programme. It usually surfaces late, during earthworks or at verification.
The four arguments in almost every claim
The claimant has to show that a reasonably competent consultant would have found, or warned of, what was missed. In practice the dispute settles into four arguments.
| Argument | What the claimant says | What the defence turns on |
|---|---|---|
| Scope | You should have investigated the whole site, or tested for more substances. | What the appointment and the agreed proposal asked for, and whether you advised in writing on what was left out. |
| Sampling | Too few locations, too shallow, or in the wrong places. | Whether the design followed the conceptual site model and a recognised sampling density. |
| Interpretation | The data showed a problem and the report played it down. | The assessment criteria chosen, why they suited the end use, and whether the report justified the risk evaluation. |
| Limitations | The report read as a clean bill of health. | Whether uncertainties and gaps were recorded, with their consequences, where a reader would see them. |
An expert will usually measure your work against the Environment Agency’s Land Contamination Risk Management guidance. It builds a tiered risk assessment on a conceptual site model, says the sampling densities in BS 10175 can be used, and asks you to record and identify the consequences of any uncertainties and limitations (Environment Agency, LCRM stage 1). A report that states its own limits clearly is far easier to defend.
What your appointment may already have decided
Before anyone argues about boreholes, solicitors on both sides read the appointment. In Persimmon Homes v Ove Arup the engineers’ agreement limited liability for pollution and contamination to £5 million in the aggregate, and said that liability for any claim in relation to asbestos was excluded. The developers argued that those words dealt only with causing contamination, not with failing to find it. On 25 May 2017 the Court of Appeal disagreed. It held that the exclusion reached the pleaded claims that the engineers had failed to identify asbestos (Persimmon v Arup [2017] EWCA Civ 373).
Terms like these help only if they were agreed before the work started and are reasonable. A term restricting liability for negligence, other than for death or personal injury, is valid only so far as it is reasonable (Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977, section 2).
What the policy does with each part of the claim
A missed contamination claim touches more clauses than almost any other. Wordings differ, so check each point against your own.
- The insuring clause. Most wordings cover civil liability arising from your professional business as the schedule describes it, so every stage of your work should be in that description.
- The pollution clause. Many wordings exclude pollution and contamination, then write cover back. Some write back only a sudden, identifiable incident. Contamination you failed to find is historic and gradual, so a write-back of that kind may not respond.
- The asbestos clause. Asbestos in made ground usually falls under a separate, lower sub-limit that is aggregate for the policy year.
- Defence costs. Under the main limit they are usually paid in addition. Under pollution and asbestos sub-limits they are often included, and expert evidence can use a large share.
- The retroactive date. PI is written on a claims made basis. The policy in force when the claim is made responds, and only if its retroactive date reaches back to the report.
- Contractual liability. If the appointment warranted that the land was suitable for use, the part of the claim resting on that promise, not on negligence, may be excluded.
Pollution caused by your own drilling is a different risk, and PI is not built for it. The other covers we arrange
When the contractor finds something
- Tell us the day you hear, even if nobody has blamed you. Unexpected contamination on a site you reported on can be a circumstance that must be notified.
- Make no admission, and do not offer to pay for extra testing or disposal without insurers’ consent.
- Gather the appointment, proposal and terms, the sampling plan, logs, laboratory certificates and the report with its limitations.
- Ask insurers whether an expert should inspect while the ground is open. Once the soil has gone, so has the evidence of what lay where.
- Check which sub-limit applies and whether it is aggregate.
- If a sub-contracted driller or laboratory was involved, say so at the outset, so that rights against them are protected in time.
What to settle before a claim comes
The time to find a write-back limited to sudden incidents, or an asbestos sub-limit set with another profession in mind, is at renewal and not after the letter of claim. Hammond PI has specialised in professional indemnity since 1990. We read the pollution and asbestos clauses in each insurer’s wording, then present your work by stage, from desk study to verification, with the largest site by end value and who signs reports. Insurers can then underwrite the work you actually do. Fair presentation explained
Contamination found on a site you reported on?
Call us before you reply to anyone, and we will notify insurers and tell you which clauses and sub-limits are in play.
Related: PI for environmental consultants · Claims support · The clause guide