Home / Insights / An upheld Ombudsman complaint: what your PI pays, part by part
Insights for financial advisers
An upheld Ombudsman complaint: what your PI pays, part by part
Most claims against advisers never reach a court. They arrive as a complaint, run to an eight week deadline and end with an Ombudsman’s decision. Each part of that decision meets a different part of your PI wording.
Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.
How a complaint becomes an Ombudsman case
A client, or a claims management company acting for one, complains that your advice was unsuitable. You have eight weeks from receiving the complaint to send a final response. Once that has gone, or the eight weeks have passed, the Financial Ombudsman Service can consider it (FCA Handbook, DISP 2.8.1R). The Ombudsman can look back six years from the advice or, if later, three years from when the client ought reasonably to have known of cause to complain (DISP 2.8.2R).
For your PI the clock starts earlier. A complaint alleging financial loss is usually notifiable on the day it arrives. A final response that upholds the complaint is an admission and an offer, and most wordings bar both without insurers’ written consent.
How the Ombudsman decides: fair and reasonable
A court asks whether you were negligent or broke a rule. The Ombudsman decides by reference to what is, in the ombudsman’s opinion, fair and reasonable in all the circumstances of the case (FSMA 2000, section 228). The Court of Appeal has held that the Ombudsman takes the law into account and may depart from it if he explains why (Heather Moor & Edgecomb v Financial Ombudsman Service).
Since 1 October 2026 the rule behind that judgement has said that the Ombudsman will take into account the law and regulations, regulators’ rules, guidance and standards, codes of practice and, where appropriate, good industry practice as each stood at the time of the act or omission complained of (Financial Ombudsman Service, policy statement, August 2026). So your advice is measured against the standards of the year you gave it, and the defence is the record you made then.
How redress is worked out
The Ombudsman aims to put the client as near as possible in the position they would be in had the advice been suitable. It usually sets a formula based on a benchmark (Financial Ombudsman Service, compensation for investment complaints):
- for a client who did not want to risk capital, the average rate on one year fixed rate bonds published by the Bank of England;
- for a client prepared to take some risk, usually the FTSE UK Private Investors Income Total Return Index;
- for a cautious client between the two, half of each.
Interest is added for the time the client was out of pocket. For complaints referred since 1 January 2026 the rate is a time weighted average of the Bank of England base rate plus one percentage point. Before that it was 8% simple a year. An illiquid or suspended investment is usually valued at nil, with ownership passing to the firm on settlement where possible. The Ombudsman can also award for distress or inconvenience, in bands that run from under £100 to more than £5,000 for the most extreme cases (Financial Ombudsman Service, distress or inconvenience).
The award limit, and what binds you
A money award cannot exceed the limit: £455,000 for complaints referred on or after 1 April 2026 about acts or omissions on or after 1 April 2019, and £205,000 for earlier acts (Financial Ombudsman Service, compensation). If the ombudsman considers that fair compensation needs more, he may recommend that you pay the balance (FSMA 2000, section 229). The Ombudsman says a business does not have to accept that recommendation.
If the client accepts the determination, it is binding on you both and final (section 228). A client who accepts an award is generally barred from suing you in court for more on the same cause of action (Clark v In Focus Asset Management).
What the policy does with each part
An upheld complaint is rarely one figure. Split it before you read the wording.
| Part of the decision | How PI wordings usually treat it |
|---|---|
| Redress for investment or pension loss | The core of the cover. The FCA requires a personal investment firm’s policy to cover Ombudsman awards. Check that any limit on this cover keeps pace with the award limit. |
| Interest | Usually follows the redress it is added to, but wordings differ on whether it counts towards the limit of indemnity. |
| Refund of your advice fees | Many wordings exclude the return of fees, so this part may be yours. |
| Distress or inconvenience | May be paid as part of the award or left out as non financial loss. It depends on how the wording defines an award and a loss. |
| A direction to take steps | For example to take over a failed investment. Some wordings cover the cost of steps you are directed to take. Others cover money awards only. |
| A recommendation above the limit | Not binding on you. A voluntary payment may not be treated as an insured loss, so agree it with insurers first. |
| Your cost of handling the complaint | Staff time is usually yours. Legal costs usually need insurers’ consent before you incur them. |
Then apply the excess. Where one piece of advice was repeated across many clients, each complaint may carry its own.
What to do when a complaint arrives
- Log it and send it to us the same day, with the client file.
- We help you notify insurers, and check earlier policy years for a block notification that may already hold this client.
- Test jurisdiction with the claims handler: the six year and three year limits, and whether the complaint is against the right firm.
- Agree the final response with insurers inside the eight weeks. Do not uphold, offer or refund on your own.
- If the Ombudsman issues a provisional decision, use the time allowed to respond on suitability and on how the loss is calculated.
- Before you pay an award, we confirm with insurers which parts are insured and which are yours.
Has a complaint just arrived?
Send it to us before you reply, and we will help you notify insurers and keep the eight week deadline and your policy conditions in step.
Related: PI for financial advisers · Claims support · The clause guide