We would like to set optional cookies to understand how the site is used. Essential cookies keep forms working. Cookie policy.

Home / Insights / Third party reliance on ground reports: who can sue, and what your PI does

Insights for geotechnical and tunnelling engineers

Third party reliance on ground reports: who can sue, and what your PI does

Most claims against ground engineers come from the client. The one that defines the profession comes from someone else: a buyer, funder or contractor who was handed your report and acted on it. Whether they can sue at all is the first question, and often the last.

Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.

How a report reaches people you never met

A ground report is written for one client and read by many. It goes into a sales pack, a planning application, a tender or a funder’s due diligence file. Years later someone who never paid you a fee finds the ground is not what they expected.

The leading example is BDW Trading v Integral Geotechnique (Wales). A council selling a former residential centre commissioned a geotechnical report, issued in May 2012. A national housebuilder received it and bought the site for £4.5 million. After demolition, asbestos containing materials were found in the ground, and removal was estimated at about £860,000. The housebuilder had no contract with the consultant, so it sued in negligence (National Archives, [2018] EWHC 1915 (TCC)).

Three arguments decide a claim like this, in order: duty, breach and loss.

Duty: did you owe the stranger anything?

The consultant knew the report would be shown to prospective purchasers. Its covering letter said the report could be assigned to the purchaser and on to two further parties. The report itself said it was prepared for the council’s use and should not be passed on without consent. The consultant’s terms excluded third party rights and capped liability at £300,000.

The housebuilder never took an assignment. The judge found this was an oversight within a reasonably sophisticated business, and that the consultant would probably have agreed to one if asked. He held that the statements about assignment meant one thing to a reasonable reader: no legal reliance without an assignment or a similar document. No duty was owed. He added that even if a duty had existed, it would not fairly have extended beyond the £300,000 limit in the consultant’s own terms.

The argument was won on paper written before anyone fell out.

Breach and loss: was the report wrong, and what did it cost?

The judge decided the remaining issues in case he was wrong on duty. On breach, he read the report as a whole and against the purpose it was written for. He accepted that parts of it should have named asbestos in made ground as a possible contaminant. But the report also recommended sampling on a 25 metre grid during site clearance, the trial pits had found no sign of contamination, and a consultant need not put hypothetical risks above the results of the investigation. Read as a whole, the report was not negligent.

On loss, the claim was valued as a lost chance to negotiate a lower price: 75% of about £1.33 million. Nothing was awarded, because the claim was dismissed.

The three arguments in a reliance claim and the documents that decide them
ArgumentWhat decides itWhat to keep
DutyYour terms, the report’s wording on use and assignment, covering letters, and any assignment, warranty or reliance letterThe signed appointment and every document that passed the report to someone else
BreachThe report read as a whole, against its purpose, scope and stated limitsThe brief, the agreed scope, what the client declined, and your recommendations for further work
LossWhat the claimant would have done with different advice, and any cap or net contribution clauseYour terms as issued, with the dates the report and each later document were sent

What a PI policy does with each part

The answer depends on the wording, but four points usually matter.

  • Defence costs. A duty defence is legal work, and BDW went to a full trial. Most wordings pay defence costs in addition to the main limit. Where the claim concerns asbestos or pollution, a smaller limit may apply, in the aggregate and with costs inside it (AGS, asbestos cover under PI).
  • The clause the claim falls under. AGS notes that PI policies usually treat asbestos separately from pollution and contamination, and that some exclude asbestos claims altogether.
  • Documents you signed. Many wordings cover a warranty, assignment or reliance letter only where it gives no greater or longer lasting benefit than your appointment. An uncapped reliance letter can fall outside that condition.
  • What you do after the letter. Policies usually bar admissions and new agreements without insurers’ consent. A reliance letter signed to calm a buyer, after the problem is known, can create the very duty the buyer lacked.

Terms to have ready before anyone asks

AGS advises members to keep a standard assignment agreement ready, and to consider the price of the extra risk each time one is requested (AGS, warranties, reliance and limiting liability). The terms it suggests include:

  • No further assignment of the report.
  • No proceedings more than six years after the date of the report, not the date of the assignment.
  • Performance judged by the standards and the appointment in place when the report was written.
  • No liability for changes to the site after the report.
  • A financial cap, and an exclusion of consequential loss.
  • The new party takes the report subject to every defence and set off you have against your client.

AGS also suggests resisting requests to put the new party’s name on the report, limiting warranties to closely defined parties, and capping how many you will give. Send us each document before you sign it. Contract reviews

If a stranger’s solicitor writes to you

Treat the letter as a claim, even though the writer is not your client. We would notify insurers at once with the letter, the appointment, the report and everything that went out with it. We would ask you to send nothing beyond an acknowledgement agreed with insurers, and to sign nothing new.

Then we would check which clause the claim falls under, what limit applies and whether costs reduce it. A request for an assignment or reliance letter that arrives after a problem has surfaced deserves the same care. It may be a circumstance to notify. Claims support

Asked for a reliance letter or an assignment?

Send it to us before you sign, and we will check it against your policy’s conditions for warranties and tell you what we would change.

Speak to a PI specialistPI for geotechnical and tunnelling engineers

Related: PI for geotechnical and tunnelling engineers · Contract reviews · Claims support