Home / Insights / Geotechnical PI requirements: who sets them, and where the contract outruns the policy
Insights for geotechnical and tunnelling engineers
Geotechnical PI requirements: who sets them, and where the contract outruns the policy
No regulator sets a PI limit for ground engineers. Your clients do, one appointment at a time. The danger is promising a basis of cover that your pollution and asbestos clauses cannot deliver.
Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.
No regulator, three sources
Geotechnical and tunnelling consultants have no regulator setting a minimum limit, an approved wording or a run off period. The requirement comes from three places.
- Your institution. The guidance to Rule 1 of the ICE Code of Professional Conduct says members should, where appropriate, obtain PI for the risks of the work, and tell clients before the project starts if it is not in place (ICE, Code of Professional Conduct). It gives no figure.
- Your trade association. The AGS membership requirements contain no PI minimum (AGS, membership requirements). AGS publishes a PI checklist for members, updated in 2022, and regular loss prevention guidance (AGS, professional indemnity insurance).
- Your contracts. Each appointment, framework and collateral warranty sets its own limit, basis and duration. This is the requirement that can be enforced against you.
A ground engineer who falls short of that promise may be in breach of contract, whether or not any report was ever wrong.
What the insurance clause usually asks for
Client drafted clauses vary, but most make the same five demands. Each needs checking against the schedule and the wording, not against the headline limit.
| Demand | What the clause usually says | What to check in the policy |
|---|---|---|
| Amount | A stated limit of indemnity | That the limit is available for this kind of work, after any sub-limit |
| Basis | Often “each and every claim” | Whether any part of your cover is in the aggregate, and whether defence costs sit inside it |
| Scope | Cover for “the services” | That the business description includes every service in the appointment, such as monitoring, verification or supervision of site work |
| Duration | Cover kept up for a stated number of years after completion | That the promise depends on cover being available on reasonable terms, since each year’s policy is a new contract |
| Evidence | A broker’s letter or certificate on request | That the letter describes the sub-limits accurately |
Where firms get caught: pollution, contamination and asbestos
AGS warned members as long ago as 2011 that the PI requirement in the NEC3 Professional Services Contract raises two potential problems, especially where the work involves contaminated land, asbestos or pollution, and that standard consultants’ policies often do not comply (AGS, Loss Prevention Alert 47).
The reason is in the policy. In November 2026 AGS reminded members that asbestos cover varies considerably between PI policies. Some exclude every asbestos related claim. Where cover is given, it is usually subject to an aggregate limit that includes costs. It may also be confined to claims arising directly from negligence, to work in the UK, the Isle of Man, the Channel Islands and the Republic of Ireland, and to claims other than injury, illness or death. AGS asks members to check whether exclusions for environmental audits or asbestos inspections could catch a ground investigation (AGS, asbestos cover under PI).
Pollution and contamination are treated separately again, often with their own aggregate limit. So a consultancy that promises a stated sum for each and every claim, without qualification, may be in breach from the day it signs, for exactly the work most likely to produce a claim.
Old promises in a changed market
The promise is tested again at every renewal. AGS reported in March 2025 that members who could once readily buy £10 million for each claim were finding cover nearer £5 million in the aggregate, and that some clients were asking for limits beyond the risk of the work (AGS, professional indemnity insurance). Appointments and warranties signed in easier years still say what they said.
Two further AGS points belong here. The level of PI you hold is not, in itself, a limit on your liability. Only an agreed cap does that. And a cap is better written to apply to all claims together than to each and every claim (AGS, limiting liability). A cap on liability for negligence must also be reasonable to stand (Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977, section 2).
Tunnel works: the project insurers’ requirements
Tunnelling adds a further source. The Code of Practice for Risk Management of Tunnel Works, published by the ITA and IMIA and now in its third edition, applies to project participants insured under the construction policy. Insurers may require compliance as a condition of covering the works, and it binds you where your contract refers to it (ITA and IMIA, code of practice). It sets no PI limit. It does expect design assumptions to be verified during construction (Tunnels & Tunnelling, updated code).
Compliance with the code does not replace your own PI. Consultants are not always insured parties under the project policy, and project insurers who have paid a loss may look to the designers to recover it. Where the design is done in joint venture, check that the joint venture is declared, because many wordings cover only your own services within it.
Before you sign, and before you renew
- Send us the insurance clause before you sign. We read it against your schedule, wording and endorsements. Contract reviews
- Ask for the basis of cover to be stated as it is really written, with pollution, contamination and asbestos shown as aggregate where they are.
- Make any promise to maintain cover depend on its being available on reasonable terms, and agree what happens if it is not.
- Keep a register of every appointment, framework and warranty, with the limit, basis and period promised in each.
- Start renewal two to three months ahead, as AGS suggests, and give us the register. Renewal
- Tell us before the expiring policy ends about any promise the new terms would not meet, so the conversation with the client happens first.
Does your policy match what you have promised?
Send us the insurance clause and your schedule, and we will tell you where the two differ before a client finds out.
Speak to a PI specialistPI for geotechnical and tunnelling engineers
Related: PI for geotechnical and tunnelling engineers · Contract reviews · Renewal