We would like to set optional cookies to understand how the site is used. Essential cookies keep forms working. Cookie policy.

Home / Insights / “Settlement shall not exceed 25mm”: design targets, guarantees and your PI

Insights for geotechnical and tunnelling engineers

“Settlement shall not exceed 25mm”: design targets, guarantees and your PI

Ground engineers are asked to promise numbers: settlement, bearing capacity, design life. A number written as a target is a matter of skill and care. The same number written as a promise is a guarantee, and most PI policies treat the two very differently.

Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.

Skill and care, or a result

A consultant’s ordinary duty is to use reasonable skill and care. If the design was one a competent ground engineer could properly have produced, there is usually no liability, even if the ground then behaves badly. PI insurance is built around that duty.

A strict obligation is different. If you promise that settlement shall not exceed 25mm, that a wall will not deflect beyond a stated figure, or that a foundation will last a stated number of years, you may be liable when the number is missed, however carefully you worked. Ground is variable and only ever sampled, so this is a discipline where an absolute promise is hard to keep.

The wording is rarely labelled “guarantee”. It arrives as “shall ensure”, “shall not exceed”, “fit for the purpose” or “comply in all respects with the Employer’s Requirements”.

One appointment can contain both

In Costain v Charles Haswell & Partners a contractor engaged a consulting engineer to design foundations for buildings at a water treatment works. The employer’s specification limited total settlement to 25mm and differential settlement to 10mm. The consultancy agreement had one clause requiring reasonable skill and care, and another requiring the design to comply in all respects with the requirements of the contract (National Archives, [2009] EWHC 3140 (TCC)).

The judge held that the second clause imposed strict liability and was not cut down by the first. On the facts it applied only to the design finally built into the permanent works. The abandoned preloading scheme was judged on skill and care, and found negligent. The engineer had never signed the agreement. It had done the work and been paid, and the court held it was bound.

Two lessons follow. A skill and care clause does not neutralise a strict clause elsewhere in the same document. And terms you never signed can still bind you if you work to them.

Following the standard does not answer a guarantee

In MT Højgaard v E.ON a contractor designed offshore wind turbine foundations to an international standard that was later found to contain an error, overstating the capacity of the grouted connections by a factor of about ten. The technical requirements also said the design of the foundations must ensure a lifetime of 20 years. The connections began to fail soon after completion, and the remedial works were agreed at €26.25 million (National Archives, [2017] UKSC 59).

The Supreme Court held the contractor liable. Where a contract requires both compliance with a standard and the achievement of a result, the courts are generally inclined to give full effect to the result, and the more demanding requirement prevails.

An appointment that asks you to design to a named code and also to meet a settlement limit may be read in the same way.

How PI wordings usually treat each promise

Most PI wordings exclude liability you assume under a contract, to the extent it goes beyond the liability you would have had without that term. The effect is to divide a claim by the words that created it. Wordings differ, so the table shows the usual position only.

Contract wording and how PI policies usually treat it
Words in the appointmentUsual treatment under PI
“Reasonable skill and care”The core of the cover.
“Shall not exceed”, “shall ensure”, “guarantees”Usually covered only so far as you would have been liable in negligence anyway. The strict part may be uninsured.
“Fit for the purpose”, “comply in all respects”Usually treated in the same way as a guarantee.
Liquidated damages and penaltiesUsually excluded, except to the extent the same loss would have been recoverable as damages for negligence.
“Indemnify against all losses”An indemnity can be wider than damages for negligence. It may fall outside cover.

Our clause guide sets out how to read an exclusion of this kind. The clause guide

When the slab settles: how the claim divides

Take an illustration. You design ground improvement for a warehouse slab under an appointment that says settlement shall not exceed 25mm. Monitoring shows 60mm. The contractor claims the cost of piling, the delay and the liquidated damages it is paying.

If the design was negligent, insurers would usually fund the defence and meet the loss that the negligence caused. That loss may be less than the claim. In Costain the court found that with the right advice the contractor would have tendered for piled foundations from the start, and assessed the loss on that footing.

If the design was competent and the ground simply behaved at the edge of what could be predicted, there is no negligence. The strict promise still stands, and the policy may not respond to it at all. The careful firm is the one a guarantee exposes most.

Either way, we would notify insurers when monitoring first passes the predicted figures, not when the claim letter arrives. Some wordings also need notice of an adjudication within days. Claims support

What to change before you sign

  1. Search the appointment and every document it brings in, including the specification and the main contract, for “shall”, “ensure”, “guarantee”, “fit for purpose” and “comply in all respects”.
  2. Ask for performance figures to be design criteria that you will use reasonable skill and care to meet.
  3. Ask for the skill and care clause to say that it governs every other obligation in the appointment.
  4. Take out liability for liquidated damages under the main contract, and agree a cap.
  5. Do not start work on terms you have not agreed. Record in writing what you are working to.
  6. Send us the draft first. We read it against your wording and tell you what is likely to sit outside cover. Contract reviews

Asked to promise a settlement figure?

Send us the appointment before you sign, and we will mark the words that turn a design target into a guarantee.

Speak to a PI specialistPI for geotechnical and tunnelling engineers

Related: PI for geotechnical and tunnelling engineers · Contract reviews · The clause guide