---
title: "The injury clause in health and safety consultants’ PI"
description: "Most PI wordings exclude bodily injury, then give cover back for injury caused by negligent advice. How it reads and where consultants fall outside."
url: "https://www.hammondpi.com/insights/health-safety-consultants-injury-clause/"
updated: "2026-11-20T06:10:05.401Z"
---

[Home](https://www.hammondpi.com/index.md) / [Insights](https://www.hammondpi.com/insights.md) / Injury caused by advice: the PI clause that decides a safety consultant’s claim

Insights for health and safety consultants

# Injury caused by advice: the PI clause that decides a safety consultant’s claim

Most professions’ PI claims are about money. A health and safety consultant’s are about someone being hurt. Yet most PI wordings begin by excluding injury. Whether your policy answers depends on a few words that give the cover back.

Why it mattersThe write backAdvice or actTwo insurersLimit and capWhat to check

Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.

## A policy built for financial loss, a profession that faces injury claims

Professional indemnity is designed around advice that costs a client money. Most PI wordings therefore exclude bodily injury and property damage, and leave those to public liability and employers’ liability policies. For a consultant whose advice exists to prevent injury, that exclusion on its own would remove the main risk.

So the wording gives cover back for injury caused by professional error. That clause is often called a write back. It is short, it varies from insurer to insurer, and for this profession it is the heart of the policy. It is the first clause we read.

## How the write back reads

The usual pattern has two halves. First, no cover for death, bodily injury, illness or disease, or for loss of or damage to property. Then an exception: unless caused by negligent advice, design or specification, or by another breach of professional duty. Small differences in those words matter.

-   **What triggers it.** “Advice, design or specification” is narrower than “breach of professional duty”. A hazard missed on an audit, a training course or a document review needs to fit the words used.
-   **Illness and disease.** Noise, vibration, dust and fume work leads to disease claims, not accidents. The write back should use words wide enough for both.
-   **Your own people.** Injury to your own employees is an employers’ liability matter, not one for PI.
-   **Other exclusions still apply.** A write back for injury does not undo an asbestos, pollution or fire safety exclusion elsewhere in the wording.

## Advice or act: where the line falls

The question in each case is whether the injury came from what you advised or from what you physically did.

Injury situations and the policy that is the likely home for each

What happened

Likely home

Why

A worker is hurt following a method statement you approved

PI

The allegation is negligent advice in a document review. Many public liability policies exclude advice given for a fee.

You knock over racking during an inspection and someone is hurt

Public liability

The injury came from what you physically did on site, not from your advice.

A delegate is hurt during practical training you run

Public liability, sometimes PI

If the session was badly run or the equipment was faulty, public liability. If the allegation is that the course content was wrong, PI may respond.

Workers develop hand arm vibration syndrome after your assessment put exposure below the action value

PI

A disease claim flowing from a professional error. The write back needs to reach illness, and the aggregation wording decides how many limits and excesses apply.

Your own trainee is injured on a client’s site

Employers’ liability

Injury to your own employees belongs to employers’ liability cover.

## When two insurers look at each other

Many consultancies hold PI with one insurer and public liability with another. After an injury, each wording may point at the other: the public liability policy through its professional services exclusion, the PI policy through its injury exclusion, and both through clauses saying they stand behind any other insurance. Meanwhile the time to respond to the claim keeps running.

What we would do in that position is notify both insurers on the same day with the same facts, so neither can say notice was late. We would frame the allegation precisely, as negligent advice or as a physical act, because that is what places it. And we would ask for one insurer to lead the defence now, with any argument between the two left for later. The better time to compare the two wordings is before a claim, which is why we ask to see both. [The other covers we arrange](https://www.hammondpi.com/other-covers.md)

## Why injury changes the limit you need

A person cannot use a contract term to exclude or restrict liability for death or personal injury resulting from negligence ([Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977, section 2](https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1977/50/section/2)). The cap in your terms may protect you against a client’s financial loss. It does not cap the injury claim.

Injury claims also arrive late and from unexpected directions. Whoever compensated the injured person can seek a contribution from others liable for the same damage ([Civil Liability (Contribution) Act 1978, section 1](https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1978/47/section/1)). An injured person has three years from their date of knowledge to bring a claim ([Limitation Act 1980, section 11](https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1980/58/section/11)).

Three other clauses decide what the limit is really worth. Defence costs are often paid in addition to the limit, but reduced in proportion if the claim itself exceeds it. Some wordings apply the excess to each claimant, so one accident with several injured people could mean several excesses. And claims from one originating cause are usually treated as one claim with one limit.

## What to check in your own wording

-   The exact words of the injury exclusion and its write back, including illness and disease.
-   Your public liability policy’s professional services exclusion, read next to it.
-   The “other insurance” clause in each policy.
-   Whether added covers such as asbestos surveying have their own limit, and whether defence costs sit inside it.
-   Whether the excess applies to each claim or each claimant.
-   The limit, judged against a serious injury with both sides’ costs.

These points depend on the wording in front of you, and wordings differ. Send us both policies and we will read them together. [The clause guide](https://www.hammondpi.com/clauses.md)

## Does your PI cover injury caused by your advice?

Send us your PI and public liability wordings and we will show you where they meet and where they leave a gap.

[Speak to a PI specialist](https://www.hammondpi.com/contact.md)[PI for health and safety consultants](https://www.hammondpi.com/who-we-cover/health-and-safety-consultants.md)

Related: [PI for health and safety consultants](https://www.hammondpi.com/who-we-cover/health-and-safety-consultants.md) · [The clause guide](https://www.hammondpi.com/clauses.md) · [Public liability and other covers](https://www.hammondpi.com/other-covers.md)
