---
title: "Broker negligence claims: how they are argued and insured"
description: "Most claims against insurance brokers start with a client’s declined claim. The four questions a court asks, and what your own PI does at each stage."
url: "https://www.hammondpi.com/insights/insurance-brokers-declined-claim-negligence/"
updated: "2026-11-20T06:10:05.670Z"
---

[Home](https://www.hammondpi.com/index.md) / [Insights](https://www.hammondpi.com/insights.md) / When the client’s insurer says no: how a claim against a broker is argued

Insights for insurance brokers

# When the client’s insurer says no: how a claim against a broker is argued

Most claims against brokers begin the same way. A client’s insurer declines, reduces or avoids, and the client looks for someone else to pay. The argument then follows four questions, and your own PI policy has something to say at each one.

How it startsFour questionsThe client’s settlementYour own PIThe fileFirst steps

Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.

## How a client’s declined claim becomes a claim against you

A broker is rarely sued over advice in the abstract. The claim starts when a client’s insurer declines a loss, avoids the policy, applies average or relies on a condition. The client’s solicitors then work backwards through your file for the cover you did not arrange, the term you did not explain, the requirement you did not pass on or the claim you did not notify.

So these claims arrive late and look backwards. The placement may be years old and the handler may have left. The first document that matters is not a letter of claim. It is the insurer’s letter to your client, which usually reaches you first.

## The four questions every broker claim turns on

Each question is a separate argument, and a claim can fail at any of them.

The four questions in a negligence claim against an insurance broker

Question

How it is argued

What the courts have said

Did you fall short?

The client says you did not arrange, explain, pass on or notify something a competent broker would have.

A broker should explain the duty of disclosure and check the client understands it. Standard written warnings alone may not be enough ([Jones v Environcom \[2010\] EWHC 759 (Comm)](https://caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ewhc/comm/2010/759)).

Was the insurer entitled to say no?

A client that has neither sued nor settled with its insurer must show the insurer’s defence was good.

An arguable defence is not enough. The point is decided as a matter of law or on the balance of probabilities ([Dalamd v Butterworth Spengler \[2018\] EWHC 2558 (Comm)](https://caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ewhc/comm/2018/2558)).

What would have happened without the error?

Would the client have acted differently? Would an insurer have covered the loss?

Where a broker is said to have failed to arrange liability cover, the court asks what the insurer would have done. Whether the client was really liable to the third party is one factor, not a knockout point ([Norman Hay v Marsh \[2025\] EWCA Civ 58](https://caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ewca/civ/2025/58)).

Did the client contribute?

The client chose the figure, guessed at growth or ignored advice.

Damages for a claim cut by average were reduced by 20%, because the client used an arbitrary growth figure in place of a forecast ([Infinity Reliance v Heath Crawford \[2023\] EWHC 3022 (Comm)](https://caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ewhc/comm/2023/3022)).

In Jones the claim against the broker still failed on causation. That is where many broker claims are decided, and why they are costly to fight: each side usually needs an underwriting expert.

## Why the client’s deal with its insurer matters to you

Many clients accept a reduced payment from their insurer and claim the gap from the broker. Where that settlement was reasonable, brokers who had not passed on an insurer’s risk requirement were held liable for the shortfall ([Ground Gilbey v Jardine Lloyd Thompson \[2011\] EWHC 124 (Comm)](https://caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ewhc/comm/2011/124)).

So what your client does with its insurer shapes your own exposure, and that is a trap. Advising the client to accept an offer, or to reject it and fight, is fresh advice you may have to answer for. Pressing the client’s insurer to reconsider can be sensible mitigation, but only on a footing your PI insurers have agreed.

Arguing that the client lost nothing needs care too. In April 2025 a broker that admitted failing to advise its client to notify two of the three insurers that could respond argued the client had suffered no loss. The argument failed ([Watford Community Housing Trust v Arthur J Gallagher \[2025\] EWHC 743 (Comm)](https://caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ewhc/comm/2025/743)).

## What your own PI policy does at each stage

-   **Notification.** A client’s declined or reduced claim is usually a circumstance under your own policy, before any complaint arrives. Wordings ask for notice as soon as reasonably possible, whatever your view on liability.
-   **No admissions.** Defending your advice in writing, or offering to make up the shortfall, can breach the policy’s conditions.
-   **Defence costs.** Check whether costs are paid in addition to the limit or inside it. A causation fight with experts can use much of a limit that includes costs.
-   **Ombudsman awards.** Smaller clients can complain instead of suing ([FCA Handbook, DISP 2.7.3R](https://handbook.fca.org.uk/handbook/disp2/disp2s7)). The FCA requires your PI to cover Ombudsman awards, which can reach £455,000 for complaints referred on or after 1 April 2026 about acts on or after 1 April 2019 ([Financial Ombudsman Service, compensation limits](https://www.financial-ombudsman.org.uk/businesses/resolving-complaint/understanding-compensation)).
-   **Aggregation.** If the same guidance note went to many clients, one limit may have to serve every claim, while an excess may apply to each.

## The file that wins or loses the claim

Broker claims are decided on what the file shows was said, to whom, and when. Four records carry most of the weight.

-   **Disclosure.** Proof that someone explained the duty of fair presentation to the person who signed, and checked they understood it. The duty itself is set out in [Fair presentation explained](https://www.hammondpi.com/insights/fair-presentation.md).
-   **Sums insured.** A broker was not liable for underinsurance where it had explained the insurer’s meaning of gross profit and the indemnity period, and the client supplied the figures ([Eurokey Recycling v Giles Insurance Brokers \[2014\] EWHC 2989 (Comm)](https://caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ewhc/comm/2014/2989)). Keep that explanation.
-   **Insurer requirements.** Every survey condition, warranty and endorsement passed to the client in writing, with its consequence spelled out.
-   **Claims.** A log of when each client claim arrived, when it reached the insurer, and which policies were considered.

## What to do when the insurer’s letter arrives

1.  Send us the insurer’s letter to your client the day you see it. We notify your PI insurers as a circumstance or a claim.
2.  Say nothing to the client about liability until insurers have agreed the response.
3.  Secure the file: emails, call notes, renewal reports and the presentation as it went to the insurer.
4.  Check whether any other policy of the client’s could respond, and that it has been notified, late or not.
5.  Ask whether the same error could reach other clients. If it could, we notify the wider problem so that later claims attach to this policy year.
6.  Agree with your PI insurers whether, and how, your firm supports the client’s challenge to its own insurer.

## Has a client’s insurer just said no?

Send us the letter before you reply to the client, and we will help you notify your own insurers in time and on the right footing.

[Speak to a PI specialist](https://www.hammondpi.com/contact.md)[PI for insurance brokers](https://www.hammondpi.com/who-we-cover/insurance-brokers.md)

Related: [PI for insurance brokers](https://www.hammondpi.com/who-we-cover/insurance-brokers.md) · [Claims support](https://www.hammondpi.com/claims-support.md) · [Fair presentation explained](https://www.hammondpi.com/insights/fair-presentation.md)
