Home / Insights / Agent supplier agreements: the indemnity clause your PI may not follow
Insights for inventory clerks
Agent supplier agreements: the indemnity clause your PI may not follow
A lettings group offers you all its inventory work, with a supplier agreement attached. Somewhere in it is a promise to indemnify the group if a deposit deduction fails. That one clause can decide whether a future claim is insured.
Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.
The law asks for care. The contract may ask for a result
When an agent instructs you, the law already implies a term that you will carry out the service with reasonable care and skill (Supply of Goods and Services Act 1982, section 13). Where a landlord instructs you as a consumer, the Consumer Rights Act says the same (section 49). That is a duty about how you work. It is not a promise about what an adjudicator will decide.
A deposit claim can fail for reasons that have nothing to do with your report. The deposit schemes’ joint guidance says a landlord needs a signed tenancy agreement, a reasonable claim and evidence of the loss, and that an award must allow for fair wear and tear (Guide to Deposits, Disputes and Damages). An indemnity for any failed deduction makes you answer for all of that. PI is built on the first duty, not the second.
Six clauses to look for in a supplier agreement
| Clause | What it asks of you | The PI question |
|---|---|---|
| Indemnity for failed deductions | To pay the agent or landlord whenever a deduction fails “for any reason connected with the report”. | Many wordings exclude liability assumed under an indemnity, guarantee or warranty unless you would have been liable without it. |
| Payment on demand | To pay within a set number of days of the agent’s demand. | Wordings require you not to admit liability or settle without insurers’ consent. A payment made to meet the deadline can prejudice cover. |
| Warranty about the report | To warrant that every report will be accepted as evidence, or is “fit for purpose”. | A promise of outcome goes further than reasonable care and skill, and may meet the same exclusion. |
| Insurance clause | To hold a stated PI limit, sometimes for years after the contract ends. | Whether your limit, its basis and your plans for run off match what you are promising. |
| Subcontractors | To answer for anyone who produces a report for you, or not to subcontract without consent. | Whether self employed clerks are insured under your policy, and whether insurers keep a right of recovery against them. |
| Set off | To let the agent deduct disputed sums from your invoices. | An invoice withheld after a complaint can be a circumstance to notify. Accepting the deduction may be treated as settling without consent. |
How PI wordings usually treat a promise like this
PI covers civil liability arising from your professional business. Most wordings then take back liability that exists only because you agreed to it: a guarantee, a warranty, a penalty, or an indemnity wider than the law would impose. The usual saving words are that the exclusion does not apply to liability you would have had anyway.
In practice that can split an agent’s demand in two. Where the deduction failed because your report fell below a reasonable standard, the claim may be covered as negligence whatever the contract says. Where it failed for another reason, and you owe the money only because of the indemnity, the policy may not respond and you would be paying from your own funds. The wording decides where that line falls. The clause guide
A cap on liability, and whether it will hold
Agents’ contracts rarely offer a cap. Ask for one. Between two businesses, a term limiting liability for negligence must satisfy the requirement of reasonableness (Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977, section 2). Where a term limits liability to a stated sum, the Act directs attention to the resources you could expect to have to meet the liability and how far it was open to you to cover yourself by insurance. It is for the party relying on the term to show that it is reasonable (section 11).
Your own terms need the same care in the other direction. Against a consumer landlord, a term cannot cap liability for a failure of reasonable care and skill below the price paid (Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 57). In Regus (UK) v Epcot Solutions [2008] EWCA Civ 361 the Court of Appeal held an exclusion of loss of profits in standard terms between two businesses to be reasonable, and a separate cap on liability stood. Each clause is judged on its own facts.
What to ask for before you sign
- Send us the agreement, your terms of business and your schedule before you sign. Contract reviews
- Propose that the indemnity is limited to loss caused by your failure to use reasonable care and skill.
- Ask for payment only once liability is agreed or decided, not on demand.
- Ask for a cap, and check that it sits within your limit of indemnity.
- Match the insurance clause to the policy you hold: the limit, whether it is any one claim, and how long you must keep it.
- Where the agent will not move, we would put the clause to insurers and ask whether they will endorse the policy, so you sign knowing what is insured and what is not.
If you have already signed one
Three things follow. First, tell us. A contract that widens your liability is the kind of fact insurers may regard as material, and the duty of fair presentation covers what you know or ought to know (Insurance Act 2015, section 3). Fair presentation explained
Second, find out how many of your agents’ agreements contain the clause and what share of your work they represent. Third, when a demand arrives under it, do not pay to keep the peace. Tell us at once so that it is notified.
An illustration: an agent demands £1,900 within 14 days under its indemnity after a failed adjudication. We would notify the matter as a circumstance, ask insurers to confirm which part they treat as negligence and which as contractual, and help you answer the deadline without making an admission.
Asked to sign an agent’s supplier agreement?
Send it to us first and we will flag the indemnity, payment and insurance clauses against your wording before you commit.
Related: PI for inventory clerks · Contract reviews · The clause guide