We would like to set optional cookies to understand how the site is used. Essential cookies keep forms working. Cookie policy.

Home / Insights / When a landlord loses a deposit dispute and blames your report

Insights for inventory clerks

When a landlord loses a deposit dispute and blames your report

An adjudicator awards the landlord nothing. Within days the agent forwards the decision and asks what you will do about it. This is the claim that defines inventory work. Here is how it is built, how it is tested, and what your PI does with each part.

Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.

How a deposit decision becomes a claim against you

A deposit dispute is decided on paper. The three deposit schemes’ joint guidance says the adjudicator will not visit the property. The adjudicator must be persuaded, on a balance of probabilities, that the tenant broke the tenancy agreement and that the landlord lost money as a result. The deposit remains the tenant’s money until the landlord proves the claim (TDS, DPS and mydeposits, Guide to Deposits, Disputes and Damages).

The check in and check out reports are usually the documents that matter most. The guidance says that without them a claim for damage is likely to fail. It also says the decision is final and binding unless the adjudicator made an error of fact or law, and can then be challenged only in court. A landlord who has lost may have few routes left against the tenant. The report, and the business that wrote it, is the next place to look.

What the adjudicator wanted from your report

The joint guidance lists what the best inventory evidence usually has.

  • Independence. The best evidence has usually been prepared by a third party such as a professional inventory clerk. That is why your report carries weight, and why the landlord says they relied on it.
  • Dated photographs. The guidance says photographs must be good quality, must clearly show the defect, and that best practice is for them to be clearly dated. Undated or low quality images are the usual first criticism.
  • The tenant’s signature. The best reports have been signed by the tenant. Where a party did not attend, the guidance says records of invitations to attend may be useful evidence.
  • Descriptive wording. Words like “fair” and “ok” can be read in many ways and might not help. The guidance also says it is important to record when an item is brand new.
  • A prompt check out. Check out evidence should be completed as soon as possible after the tenant returns the keys. A gap invites the argument that the damage came later.

Breach, cause and loss: the three questions

A claim against you has to pass three questions.

Was the report below standard? Your duty is reasonable care and skill, owed to a consumer landlord under the Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 49 and to a business client such as an agent under the Supply of Goods and Services Act 1982, section 13. The report is judged against what you were instructed to do and what it said about its own limits.

Did the report lose the claim? The guidance calls a signed tenancy agreement essential and says a claim without one is almost certain to be rejected. It says adjudicators award only what is reasonable, and that estimates are weaker evidence than invoices. If the landlord’s case failed for one of those reasons, the report may not be the cause.

What was really lost? An award must allow for fair wear and tear and must not leave the landlord better off. The guidance gives a worked example: where replacement is justified, a £500 carpet two years into a five year life gives a reasonable charge to the tenant of £300. The same reasoning can be applied to the sum the landlord says your report cost them.

One email, four demands, and how PI usually treats each

What an agent or landlord demands after a failed deposit dispute and how PI usually treats it
What is demandedHow PI usually treats it
Your fee backClaims for the return of fees are commonly excluded. Refunding or waiving a fee may still need insurers’ consent, because it can read as an admission.
The deduction the landlord could not recoverThis is the core of PI: a civil liability claim arising from your professional work, subject to the excess and the wording.
The landlord’s or agent’s time and troubleThe schemes’ guidance says landlords generally cannot claim for time and inconvenience at adjudication. Whether any such sum can be recovered from you is for insurers’ solicitors to test.
“Put it right or lose our work”A payment made to keep a client is not what the policy is built to pay. Made without consent, it can prejudice cover for the real claim.

Behind one complaint there is often a bigger question. If the same template, clerk or software sits behind every report you issued to that agent, wordings usually treat claims from one originating cause as one claim with one limit.

What to do when the decision is forwarded to you

  1. Tell us at once, so the matter is notified to insurers as a circumstance with the adjudication decision, both reports and the agent’s email. A complaint that cannot be resolved straight away is usually notifiable.
  2. Admit nothing and offer nothing. Acknowledge receipt only.
  3. Keep everything: the original image files with their capture data, the booking record, the instruction, the terms of business sent with it, and proof of how the report reached the tenant.
  4. Ask for the landlord’s whole adjudication file: the tenancy agreement, the claim, the invoices and the tenant’s response. It shows why the claim failed.
  5. Count the other reports issued to that agent on the same template or by the same clerk, and give insurers the number so that later complaints attach to this notification.
  6. If the matter is still open at renewal, it must be disclosed to any new insurer as well. Fair presentation explained

What makes these claims rarer and easier to defend

An illustration: a clerk’s check in reports describe each item in words, date every photograph, record how and when the tenant was sent the report, and say plainly what was not inspected. That clerk gives insurers’ solicitors something to work with on all three questions.

Hammond PI has specialised in professional indemnity since 1990. We read the wording, present your reporting practice to insurers at renewal, and stay involved when a claim comes.

Has an agent forwarded a failed deposit decision?

Send it to us before you reply, and we will help you notify it properly and separate what is being demanded.

Speak to a PI specialistPI for inventory clerks

Related: PI for inventory clerks · Claims support · Fair presentation