We would like to set optional cookies to understand how the site is used. Essential cookies keep forms working. Cookie policy.

Home / Insights / Tenancy deposit claims against letting agents: how they arise and what PI does

Insights for estate and letting agents

Tenancy deposit claims against letting agents: how they arise and what PI does

One missed deadline or one faulty template can turn a tenancy deposit into an award of up to three times its value, and then into a landlord’s claim against you. Here is how each part is argued and how PI wordings tend to treat it.

Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.

What the Housing Act requires

A tenancy deposit must be dealt with under an authorised scheme from the moment it is received. Within 30 days the scheme’s initial requirements must be met, and the prescribed information must be given to the tenant and to any “relevant person”, meaning anyone who paid the deposit on the tenant’s behalf (Housing Act 2004, section 213). The section applies despite any agreement to the contrary.

The Act also says that references to a landlord include a person acting on the landlord’s behalf in relation to the tenancy (section 212). In Draycott v Hannells Letting the High Court accepted that a letting agent who received the deposit could be ordered to pay the statutory award, although no award was made on the facts of that case (National Archives, [2010] EWHC 217 (QB)).

How the claim usually starts

Deposit claims usually begin with one of these:

  • Late protection. The deposit sits in the client account past day 30 after a staff change.
  • The wrong recipient. The tenant received the prescribed information, but the parent or employer who paid the deposit did not.
  • A faulty template. The standard pack leaves something out, and every tenancy set up with it carries the same gap.
  • An inherited tenancy. A book is bought and nobody checks what was served at the start.

The tenant, or the person who paid, can apply to the county court, and can do so after the tenancy has ended (section 214). Often the point first surfaces when the landlord wants the property back. Since 1 May 2026 a court may make a possession order only if the deposit rules have been met, except on Grounds 7A and 14. Returning the deposit in full, or with agreed deductions, lifts that bar (section 215), but it may not dispose of the tenant’s claim for the award.

The parts of a deposit claim

A solicitor’s letter usually rolls several demands into one figure. PI treats each differently.

The parts of a tenancy deposit claim and how PI wordings usually treat them
PartWho claims itHow PI wordings usually treat it
The deposit itselfThe tenantThe court can order it repaid or paid into a custodial scheme. It is the tenant’s money, so it is not usually an insured loss.
The award of one to three times the depositThe tenant, from the landlord or the agentOnce the breach is shown the court must order it, payable within 14 days. Many wordings exclude fines, penalties and non compensatory sums, so insurers may ask which this is.
The landlord’s own lossThe landlord, from the agentWhat PI is built for: a claim that your breach of duty left the landlord paying the award, the tenant’s costs or the cost of a failed possession claim.
Legal costs of respondingThe agencyDefence costs are usually covered where insurers have agreed to them first. Costs run up before notification may not be.

The answer for the same award can differ depending on whether it was ordered against you or passed on by the landlord. The clause guide explains the terms involved.

How the claim is argued

On the tenant’s claim, if the 30 day requirements were missed the court must order a sum of at least the deposit and no more than three times it (section 214). The argument is about where in that range the figure falls, and how the agency responded can matter.

On the landlord’s claim the argument is about duty and cause. Insurers will ask:

  • what the management agreement says about protecting the deposit and serving the prescribed information, and whether you were instructed on a let only or managed basis
  • who actually held the deposit, and whether the landlord took over any step
  • what was checked when the tenancy was renewed, or taken over from another agent
  • how much of the landlord’s loss flows from the deposit failure, and how much would have happened anyway

Why one error rarely stays one claim

Deposit paperwork comes from templates and diaries, so an error is seldom confined to one tenancy. The insurance question becomes how the policy treats a hundred of them.

Two clauses decide it. The aggregation clause may treat every claim from one originating cause as a single claim. That means one excess, but also one limit for the whole book. Without it, or where the excess applies to each claimant, each tenancy can carry its own excess, and a single deposit may be smaller than the excess.

The notification clause decides which policy year responds. Tenancies you have identified and notified as circumstances attach to this year’s policy, even if the tenant does not claim until later. Tenancies you knew about and left off may fall outside both this policy and the next.

What to do when the letter arrives

  1. Do not admit, offer or pay anything until you have spoken to us. Serving the prescribed information again or returning the deposit should be agreed with insurers first, so it is treated as mitigation.
  2. Send us the letter the day it arrives. We notify it to insurers as a claim, with the landlord’s likely claim alongside it.
  3. Check every tenancy set up with the same template, by the same person or in the same handover. List each one with its landlord and deposit so the whole book can be notified.
  4. Pull the file: management agreement, scheme certificate, the prescribed information as served, proof of the date, and who paid the deposit.
  5. If the tenancy came with a book you bought, check the retroactive date and the sale agreement.

We read the penalties exclusion, the aggregation clause and the notification condition before your renewal, so you know the answers in advance. How we support claims

Found a gap in your deposit paperwork?

Tell us before you correct it, and we will notify insurers for the whole book and agree the repair with them first.

Speak to a PI specialistPI for estate and letting agents

Related: PI for estate and letting agents · Claims support · The clause guide