Home / Insights / Generative AI in agency work: where the law stands and what insurers ask
Insights for marketing and communications consultants
Generative AI in agency work: where the law stands and what insurers ask
AI tools now draft copy, images, voice and film for clients. The law on copyright, ownership and likeness is still moving, and the agency that publishes the output answers for it. This is the position in late 2026 and what insurers will ask.
Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.
Copyright and AI: decided, appealed and still open
The leading English case is Getty Images v Stability AI. In November 2025 the High Court dismissed the secondary copyright claim against the AI model and found limited trade mark infringement where outputs carried watermarks. The claim about training the model was withdrawn, not decided ([2025] EWHC 2863 (Ch)). In December 2025 the judge gave Getty permission to appeal on secondary infringement, saying the appeal had a real prospect of success, and refused Stability permission on the trade mark findings ([2025] EWHC 3343 (Ch)).
Parliament has not settled it either. The government’s report on copyright and AI, published on 18 March 2026, says a broad copyright exception with an opt-out is no longer its preferred way forward, and that it will not reform copyright law until it is confident the changes will meet its objectives (GOV.UK, report on copyright and AI). For an agency the practical point is narrower than the policy debate. Whatever a model was trained on, an output can still reproduce a protected work, a brand or a real person.
Who owns what the tool produces
Clients expect to own what they pay for. Under the 1988 Act the author of a computer generated work is the person who made the arrangements necessary for its creation (CDPA 1988, section 9). Whether a particular AI output qualifies, and who that person is when a tool, an agency and a client are all involved, may be disputed.
That protection may not last. The March 2026 report proposes that copyright protection for wholly computer generated works should be removed, while the government continues to monitor its use. It gives no timetable (GOV.UK, report on copyright and AI). An agency that warrants exclusive ownership of a deliverable made largely by a tool may be promising something the law does not give. Say in the contract which elements were AI generated and what the client is getting.
Likeness, voice and false endorsement
English law has no image right as such. But using a famous person’s image so that buyers think she approved the product can be passing off (Fenty v Arcadia [2015] EWCA Civ 3). In Irvine v Talksport a doctored photograph in a promotional mailing falsely suggested endorsement, and damages were a reasonable endorsement fee, raised on appeal from £2,000 to £25,000 ([2003] EWCA Civ 423).
AI makes a lookalike or soundalike easy to produce by accident. The ASA’s advice is that an AI generated celebrity endorsement that looks real enough to mislead consumers is likely to breach the CAP Code (ASA, AI and deepfakes). The government has said it will explore whether a new digital replica or personality right would be beneficial (GOV.UK, report on copyright and AI), so the rules here may tighten. Check every AI generated face and voice against real people before it is published, and record that you did.
The advertising rules do not change
The CAP Code is media neutral. The rules apply however the content was created, and the advertiser remains primarily responsible for compliance even where automated tools produced or placed the ad (ASA, June 2026). Agencies also accept an obligation to abide by the Code (CAP Code, rule 1.8).
There is no blanket duty to label AI content. CAP’s test is whether the audience is likely to be misled without a disclosure, and a label is unlikely to rescue a message that is misleading in itself, such as an AI image of a cosmetic result the product does not deliver (CAP, disclosure of AI in advertising). So the review a person gives the output is the control that matters: accuracy of claims, stereotypes, likeness, brand marks and stray watermarks.
What insurers ask about AI
| Question | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Which tools, for which deliverables? | Drafting internal ideas is a different risk from generating finished images, voice or film for publication. |
| On what licence terms? | The terms may restrict commercial use, and may give you no indemnity if an output infringes. |
| What goes in? | Client briefs, customer data and embargoed material entered into a tool raise confidentiality and data protection questions. |
| Who reviews the output? | A named person checking for copied work, likeness, marks and accuracy is the control insurers look for. |
| What do you tell clients, and what do you warrant? | A warranty of originality or exclusive ownership may go beyond what PI follows. |
| What records are kept? | Prompts, reference images and settings show whether a likeness or a copy was asked for or emerged unprompted. |
Answer these in your presentation to insurers. If an earlier proposal form said no AI was used and that has changed, say so. Fair presentation explained
How PI wordings treat AI work
Many media PI wordings do not mention AI at all. They cover civil liability arising from your professional business, and the questions are the usual ones. Is the work within the business description? Was any copyright infringement or misuse of a likeness unintentional, and can you show it? Does the client contract contain promises about ownership or originality that go further than reasonable skill and care? Conduct found to be reckless can be excluded, which is why letting a campaign run on after a complaint is dangerous.
If a complaint arrives, notify at once, agree any withdrawal with insurers and keep the prompts and review notes. AI does not move responsibility. The agency that publishes the output answers for it. We read your wording against the way you actually use these tools, and at renewal we read any question or endorsement that mentions AI before you answer or accept it.
Using AI in client work?
Tell us how, and we will check your wording and your client contracts against it before renewal.
Speak to a PI specialistPI for marketing and communications consultants
Related: PI for marketing and communications consultants · Fair presentation · Contract reviews