---
title: "Unlicensed image claims and marketing agency PI"
description: "How a rights owner builds an image copyright demand against a marketing agency, how each part is argued, and what a PI policy usually does with each one."
url: "https://www.hammondpi.com/insights/marketing-agency-image-copyright-claims/"
updated: "2026-11-20T06:10:05.474Z"
---

[Home](https://www.hammondpi.com/index.md) / [Insights](https://www.hammondpi.com/insights.md) / The unlicensed image claim: how it is argued and what your PI does

Insights for marketing and communications consultants

# The unlicensed image claim: how it is argued and what your PI does

A rights owner’s letter about an image is the claim marketing agencies meet most often. It is really several demands in one, and your PI can treat each of them differently. Here is how the claim is built and where cover turns.

How it startsThe argumentEach partThe client’s demandFirst stepsBefore a claim

Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.

## How an image claim reaches the agency

The pattern rarely changes. A designer or freelancer takes a photograph from a web search, uses a stock image beyond the media or period its licence allowed, or relies on a picture the client supplied without asking where it came from. Later the photographer, or a picture library, finds it online and writes to the brand named on the page.

Copyright is infringed by a person who does a restricted act without the owner’s licence, or who authorises someone else to do it ([CDPA 1988, section 16](https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1988/48/section/16)). So the client that published the image and the agency that chose it can both be pursued. In practice the letter goes to the client, and the client forwards it to you with the intellectual property indemnity in your contract marked. A claim in tort can usually be brought for six years ([Limitation Act 1980, section 2](https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1980/58/section/2)), which is why a website built several years ago can still produce a demand today.

## How the rights owner builds the figure

The demand is normally built in layers.

-   **The licence fee.** The starting point is what a proper licence for that use would have cost. The argument is about what a willing buyer and seller would have agreed, not the figure in the letter.
-   **Additional damages.** A court may add to the award, having regard to how flagrant the infringement was and the benefit the infringer gained ([CDPA 1988, section 97](https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1988/48/section/97)).
-   **No knowledge.** A defendant who did not know, and had no reason to believe, that copyright existed in the work does not pay damages, although other remedies remain (same section). An agency that handles images every day may find that hard to show.
-   **Costs.** In the Intellectual Property Enterprise Court a claim worth up to £10,000 is a small claim, where legal costs are not normally recovered. Larger claims can attract damages of up to £500,000 and costs of up to £60,000 ([GOV.UK, Intellectual Property Enterprise Court](https://www.gov.uk/guidance/take-a-case-to-the-intellectual-property-enterprise-court)).

_Absolute Lofts v Artisan Home Improvements_ shows the layers at work. Twenty one photographs from another firm’s website appeared on a site a web designer had built for the defendant. The claimant put the cost of commissioning the photographs at about £9,000. The judge set the licence fee at £300, the price of the stock images the defendant later bought to replace them, then awarded a further £6,000 after finding the infringement flagrant ([\[2015\] EWHC 2608 (IPEC)](https://caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ewhc/ipec/2015/2608)).

## What the policy does with each part

One letter, several heads of claim. Separating them is the first job, because a PI wording can answer each one differently.

The parts of an image copyright demand and how PI usually treats each

Part of the demand

How PI usually treats it

Licence fee and damages claimed by the rights owner

The core of the cover. Civil liability wordings take in copyright infringement, but usually only where you can show it was unintentional.

Additional damages

The facts that support them, such as knowledge or indifference, are the same facts insurers look at when asking whether the infringement was unintentional.

The client’s cost of taking down and replacing the work

Can come back to you as the client’s loss. The cost of a fix you carry out yourself may be paid as mitigation, with insurers’ prior written consent.

A licence for future use

Buying rights you should have bought at the outset may be treated as your own business cost, not a loss.

Your own fee

A refund of your fees and your lost margin are commonly excluded.

These are typical positions, not a statement of any one policy. [The clause guide](https://www.hammondpi.com/clauses.md)

## When the client relies on its indemnity

The letter is addressed to the client, so agencies often wait. That is a mistake. Once the client holds you responsible, under an indemnity or simply because you chose the image, its demand may be a claim against you under your policy, or at least a circumstance to notify.

The contract matters in two ways. An indemnity can make you liable for the client’s costs whether or not you were careless, and PI usually follows your liability at law, so a promise that goes further than reasonable skill and care may not be fully covered. And some wordings will pay towards a claim made against your client only where the indemnity was agreed in writing before the claim arose. Send us the contract with the letter.

## What we would do in the first week

1.  Notify insurers on the day the client forwards the letter, as a claim against the agency and not a query about someone else’s dispute.
2.  Do not pay the fee, apologise or tell the client “leave it with us”. Any of these can be an admission made without insurers’ consent.
3.  Ask the client to take the image down and to admit nothing. Removal limits the damage. It does not concede the claim.
4.  Trace the image: who chose it, where it came from, what licence exists and what the freelancer’s terms say.
5.  Search other clients’ work for the same image or the same sourcing, and notify what you find as one matter. A series of claims from one originating cause usually shares one limit.
6.  Keep your right of recovery against the freelancer. Do not release them or agree that their liability is limited.

[How we support a claim](https://www.hammondpi.com/claims-support.md)

## The records that decide the next claim

Insurers ask every agency the same questions. Where do images, fonts, music and footage come from? Who checks each licence’s territory, media and period? Where are the records kept? An agency that can answer is better placed to defend the claim and to show that any infringement was unintentional.

The freelancer file matters as much. A freelancer keeps the copyright in what they create unless it is assigned in writing and signed ([CDPA 1988, section 90](https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1988/48/section/90)), so their terms should deal with ownership as well as sourcing. [Freelancers and sub-consultants](https://www.hammondpi.com/insights/freelancers-and-sub-consultants.md)

## Had a letter about an image?

Send it to us with the client contract before anyone replies, and we will help you notify it properly.

[Speak to a PI specialist](https://www.hammondpi.com/contact.md)[PI for marketing and communications consultants](https://www.hammondpi.com/who-we-cover/marketing-and-communications-consultants.md)

Related: [PI for marketing and communications consultants](https://www.hammondpi.com/who-we-cover/marketing-and-communications-consultants.md) · [Claims support](https://www.hammondpi.com/claims-support.md) · [Freelancers and sub-consultants](https://www.hammondpi.com/insights/freelancers-and-sub-consultants.md)
