Home / Insights / After Mazur: litigation tasks, unauthorised staff and what your PI needs to know
Insights for legal service providers
After Mazur: litigation tasks, unauthorised staff and what your PI needs to know
In March 2026 the Court of Appeal settled who may carry out litigation tasks under an authorised person. It did not change the position of firms that have no authorised person. Costs draftsmen and paralegal businesses need to know which side of that line they work on.
Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.
What the Court of Appeal decided
The conduct of litigation is a reserved legal activity. The Legal Services Act 2007 defines it as issuing proceedings, commencing, prosecuting and defending them, and performing ancillary functions in relation to them (Schedule 2, paragraph 4). Carrying it on without being entitled is an offence, and can also be a contempt of court (section 14).
On 31 March 2026 the Court of Appeal held in Mazur that an unauthorised person may lawfully perform any task within the conduct of litigation for and on behalf of an authorised individual, who keeps responsibility for it. The authorised individual is the person carrying on the litigation. The court rejected the distinction between supporting litigation and conducting it under supervision, and reversed the High Court’s 2025 ruling ([2026] EWCA Civ 369).
Supervision is a matter of degree. Some work needs approval before each step. For routine work, regular meetings and sampling may be enough.
Where the decision stops: the litigant in person
The court treated the cases about litigants in person as entirely distinguishable. A litigant in person cannot delegate the conduct of their own case. Baxter v Doble shows what that means. An unauthorised firm acted for a landlord who was recorded as a litigant in person. Its staff advised him, drafted the claim form and particulars, posted them to the court with the fee, drafted witness statements and an application, instructed an advocate and arranged service of a pleading ([2023] EWHC 486 (KB)).
The High Court looked at the whole picture, as a question of fact and degree and of substance over form. Giving legal advice was not conducting litigation. Nor was drafting notices before proceedings began. Taken together, though, the firm had conducted the litigation for its client. It made no difference that the firm did not sign documents, go on the court record or use its letterhead for court correspondence.
The firm avoided a finding of contempt because the statutory defence applied. On the facts in 2019, it did not know and could not reasonably have been expected to know that an offence was being committed. A firm relying on that defence today may be asked what it could reasonably have known with these judgments published.
Three working models and the question each raises
| Model | Who carries on the litigation | The insurance question |
|---|---|---|
| Costs law firm with a designated Costs Lawyer | The Costs Lawyer, for costs litigation. The CLSB has no regulatory objection to an unregulated costs firm going on the court record if every litigation task is done by, or under the direction of, a designated Costs Lawyer who keeps responsibility. | Does the policy the Costs Lawyer relies on cover the outcome of tasks delegated to unauthorised colleagues? |
| Costs draftsmen or paralegals working on a solicitor’s files | The instructing solicitor, if they in fact direct and supervise the work. | What does the outsourcing contract say about supervision, deadlines and indemnities, and does your business description cover the tasks you perform? |
| Paralegal firm acting directly for litigants in person, with no authorised person | Only the client. Nobody in the firm can take the litigation on. | Which tasks do staff perform beyond advice and drafting, and have they been described to insurers exactly? |
What the CLSB now expects of costs firms
The CLSB published guidance on delegation and supervision on 2 November 2026. It is written for Costs Lawyers and for those responsible for unregulated costs firms (CLSB, Delegation and Supervision by Costs Lawyers). Its main points:
- Delegation must be set up in advance and be clear, not rest on assumptions.
- The Costs Lawyer should be able to show that they directed the progress of each matter, with proportionate audit and quality checks.
- The client should understand in advance that a task will be delegated to someone who is not a Costs Lawyer.
- A person to whom work is delegated must not delegate it further.
- Where supervision is arranged outside an employment relationship, a written agreement is good practice, and it may need to deal with professional indemnity insurance.
- Work produced with AI needs human review, with an authorised individual keeping ultimate responsibility.
The guidance also says that the insurance policy the Costs Lawyer relies on must extend to the outcome of delegated tasks.
The questions a PI policy raises
We do not say what any judgment means for a particular policy. That depends on the wording and on what insurers were told. The questions, though, are predictable.
- Business description. Cover follows the business you described. If the proposal said “litigation support” and staff were in substance running cases, insurers may ask whether that work was ever presented to them.
- The client’s loss. A negligence claim for a struck out case or a missed deadline is the kind of claim PI exists for, subject to the wording.
- Fees. A demand for the return of fees is commonly excluded.
- Fines and penalties. Usually excluded. On indictment the offence carries up to two years’ imprisonment, a fine or both.
- Representation. Some wordings pay for representation at an inquiry linked to a covered claim. Check whether a contempt application or a regulator’s investigation is within it.
What to do before your next renewal
- List every task your staff perform on a live court matter, from drafting to filing and service.
- Against each task, name the authorised person who directs it, and how. If there is none, pause that part of the service and take legal advice on it.
- Put the delegation scheme, the supervision checks and the audit in writing.
- Read your contracts with instructing solicitors for who owns court deadlines and what you have promised. Contract reviews
- Describe the model to insurers as it really works. A full account now is better than one extracted after a claim. Fair presentation explained
Changed how your team works since Mazur?
Tell us what your staff do on live court matters and who supervises them, and we will check that your policy is described to match.
Related: PI for legal services and will writers · Contract reviews · Fair presentation