Home / Insights / Liability caps in planning appointments: what holds, and what your PI needs
Insights for town planners
Liability caps in planning appointments: what holds, and what your PI needs
A planning fee of a few thousand pounds can sit behind a claim for a lost site sale. A liability cap is the term that closes that gap. Whether it holds depends on who the client is, how it was agreed and what else you sign.
Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.
Why planners need a cap more than most
Most consultants’ fees bear some relation to the value of the project. A planner’s often do not. A few thousand pounds buys an application, an appraisal or an appeal, and the landowner, buyer or funder then makes a decision worth far more on the strength of it.
The reported case of Elvanite Full Circle v AMEC Earth and Environmental shows the gap. The consultant’s lump sum fee for preparing and submitting a planning application was £13,225. The client claimed the profit it said it had lost on a sale of the site, starting from a sale figure of £1.35 million (read the judgment). The claim failed, but only after a High Court trial.
The terms in Elvanite, and what the judge said
The consultant’s standard terms held three protections, and the client’s director had signed an order confirmation accepting them. Mr Justice Coulson held that the claim failed on the facts, then gave his view of each term.
| Term | What it said | The judge’s view |
|---|---|---|
| Cap | Liability limited to the fees actually paid or £50,000, whichever was less | Reasonable. It would have limited liability to £13,987.20 |
| Consequential loss | No responsibility for consequential, incidental or indirect damages | Reasonable. The lost profit on the sale was indirect loss and would have been excluded |
| Time limit | Claims treated as given up unless filed within one year of substantial completion | Reasonable. It did not require court proceedings within the year, but it did require a detailed claim, and that came too late |
He found the terms reasonable because the two companies were in broadly equal bargaining positions, the client received no inducement to agree, it knew of the terms, and clauses of this kind are common. He distinguished an earlier case in which a cap at the level of the fee was unreasonable, because the same contract required the consultant to carry £10 million of professional indemnity insurance.
This is one judgment on one set of facts between two commercial parties. It does not promise that another cap will hold.
The test your cap has to pass
Business clients. A term limiting liability for negligence must satisfy the requirement of reasonableness (Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977, section 2). The court asks whether the term was fair and reasonable to include, given what the parties knew when the contract was made. Where the term limits liability to a stated sum, the Act points to two things in particular: the resources you could expect to have to meet the liability, and how far you could cover yourself by insurance. It is for you to show the term is reasonable (section 11).
That is why a cap set far below the insurance you carry, or the insurance the same contract tells you to carry, may be harder to defend than one set with your limit of indemnity in mind.
Consumer clients. A householder is a consumer. Under the Consumer Rights Act 2015, a term is not binding on a consumer to the extent that it excludes your liability for reasonable care and skill, or restricts it so that the consumer could not recover the price paid. A higher cap may still be tested under the Act’s rules on unfair terms (section 57). Terms written for developers should not go to homeowners unchanged.
Incorporation. A cap helps only if it is part of the contract. RTPI members must give written terms of engagement before work starts (RTPI Code). Have them signed, and keep them.
Where the cap leaks
A cap in your appointment protects you against your client. Planning advice travels further than that.
- Reliance letters and collateral warranties. Each is a new promise to a new party. Unless it repeats the cap, the purpose and the period, the buyer or funder may hold an uncapped right against you.
- The forwarded report. Your cap sits in a contract the reader never signed. State on the face of every appraisal who may rely on it, for what purpose and up to what amount.
- Client drafted appointments. These often replace your terms entirely, and add promises on programme or outcome.
- Subconsultants. If your ecologist or transport consultant caps liability at the fee while you answer to the client for far more, the gap between the two sits with you.
What your PI needs from your terms
Insurers have no quarrel with a cap that protects you. Their concern is with the terms that run the other way.
- Liability assumed by contract. Liability you accept beyond the ordinary legal duty is commonly excluded: guarantees, fitness for purpose, penalties and liquidated damages. A promise of permission by a date is that kind of term.
- Rights of recovery. Many wordings exclude loss where you have agreed to restrict your right to recover from someone else. Accepting a subconsultant’s cap at fee level can do exactly that.
- Warranties and reliance letters. These are usually covered only if they are no wider and no longer than the duty owed to the original client.
- Disclosure. Your standard terms, and how often clients replace them, are part of what insurers need to know. Fair presentation explained
Before you sign
- Issue written terms, with the cap, before any work starts. Have the client sign them.
- Keep a separate version for consumer clients.
- Send us any client drafted appointment, reliance letter or warranty before you agree it. We flag the insurance points. Contract reviews
- Appoint subconsultants on terms that match your own, or have the client appoint them direct.
- Keep signed terms for as long as a claim could be brought. The long stop for negligence claims is fifteen years (Limitation Act 1980, section 14B).
Asked to sign a reliance letter or an uncapped appointment?
Send it to us first, and we will flag the insurance points before you commit.
Related: PI for town planners · Contract reviews · Freelancers and subconsultants