We would like to set optional cookies to understand how the site is used. Essential cookies keep forms working. Cookie policy.

Home / Insights / Letters of intent: the claim that defines project managers’ PI

Insights for project managers

Letters of intent: the claim that defines project managers’ PI

Starting on a letter of intent is routine. Finishing on one is how project managers get sued. One High Court case shows how the claim is built, how it is valued, and where a PI policy answers and where it may not.

Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.

Why letters of intent turn into claims

A letter of intent lets the contractor start while the contract is still being agreed. It holds the start date. It also removes the pressure to sign. Each month the works advance, the contractor has less reason to accept terms it dislikes, and the client’s protections stay in a draft: liquidated damages, the bond, the warranties, the agreed split of design responsibility.

The project manager usually issues the letter, tracks its expiry and reports to the client. So when the building is late and the client finds it has no contract to enforce, one question lands on one desk: who told us this was safe?

What happened at Ampleforth

In Ampleforth Abbey Trust v Turner & Townsend Project Management the project was a three storey residential block at a school, with an intended contract price of £4,951,365. The draft building contract provided for liquidated damages of £50,000 a week. Work began under a letter of intent in November 2003 and carried on under eight of them, the last dated September 2004. The first letter said neither side would be bound by the intended contract until it was executed. When the Trust and the contractor later settled their dispute, the contractor was paid the full price and no liquidated damages were deducted ([2012] EWHC 2137 (TCC)).

The Trust then claimed against its project manager. The judge treated an executed contract as fundamental, and said the project manager had treated it as “a dispensable luxury”. A reasonably competent project manager would have advised, by the end of March 2004 at the latest, that letters of intent were no longer appropriate. Nor could the project manager rely on its own reading of the letters’ legal effect while saying it was no legal adviser. It should have told the Trust to take legal advice.

How the claim is argued, stage by stage

  1. Breach. Did you identify what was holding up signature, work urgently to resolve it, tell the client it needed a contract and bring pressure to bear? At Ampleforth the judge found a lack of focus on exactly those points.
  2. The client. Would the client have acted on proper advice? The claimant must show this on the balance of probabilities. The judge found the Trust probably would have.
  3. The contractor. Would the contractor have signed? Here the claimant need only show a real or substantial chance. The judge put it at two thirds.
  4. Value. What was a signed contract worth? The judge valued the benefit at £340,000 and awarded two thirds of it, £226,667.

So the Trust did not have to prove the contractor would have signed, and the project manager did not pay the whole loss. In a claim of this kind most of the argument is about the last two stages: what the contractor was really prepared to accept, and when. The project manager’s own claim for unpaid fees succeeded in part, for £37,167.

What the policy does with each part

A claim like this arrives as one letter. A PI wording reads it as several separate things.

Parts of a letter of intent claim and how PI wordings usually treat them
Part of the claimHow PI wordings usually treat it
The client’s lost contractual protectionAn allegation of negligence in your professional services. This is the core of civil liability cover, subject to the policy’s terms, limit and excess.
A promise in your appointment to deliver a signed contract by a dateA duty stricter than reasonable skill and care may fall within the contractual liability exclusion. Wordings usually cover what the law would have implied, not the extra.
Your view of the letter’s legal effectCover follows the professional business you declared. If you draft or advise on letters of intent, say so when the risk is presented.
Your unpaid feesRecovering fees is usually outside the policy. A counterclaim answering your invoice is a claim, and should be notified before you pursue the fee.
Defence costsUsually paid in addition to the limit, with insurers’ consent to the solicitors and the steps taken.
What you knew before the claimAn expired letter on a late project can be a circumstance. Most wordings want notice as soon as reasonably possible, and late notice can put cover at risk.

Any cap in your appointment is a separate argument, and one for panel solicitors. In the same case a cap at the level of the fees failed.

A letter of intent procedure insurers recognise

  • Written advice before the first letter: what protection the client gives up while the contract is unsigned, and a recommendation to take legal advice on the letter’s effect.
  • An expiry date, a value limit and a defined scope in every letter.
  • One named person who diarises each expiry. No work carries on under an expired letter without the client’s written instruction.
  • A list of every point holding up signature, with an owner and a date, reported to the client each month.
  • A set point at which you advise in writing that further letters are not appropriate, and what the alternatives are.
  • A record of the client’s decision if it chooses to carry on against your advice.

If a project is already running on letters

Tell us now, not at renewal. We would look at the appointment, the letters and your reports with you, and help you decide whether there is a circumstance to notify. If the client has already complained, send nothing in reply until insurers have seen it: no apology, no offer on fees, no argument about the cap. How we support a claim

At renewal, unsigned contracts and expired letters belong in the presentation, with what you are doing about each. A clear account of a live problem is far better than a silence that is discovered later. Fair presentation explained

Works running on a letter of intent?

Send us the letter and your appointment, and we will tell you what to record, what to notify and when.

Speak to a PI specialistPI for project managers

Related: PI for project managers · Claims support · Contract reviews