Home / Insights / Liability caps and net contribution: will your appointment terms hold?
Insights for project managers
Liability caps and net contribution: will your appointment terms hold?
A project manager’s fee is a fraction of the project it manages, so the cap in the appointment matters more than almost any other term. Two court decisions show when a cap or a net contribution clause holds, and when it does not.
Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.
Why these two clauses decide the size of the claim
A project manager rarely causes a loss alone. The contractor is late, a designer’s information is rejected, a sub-contractor fails, and the client says you should have seen it coming. In law, each party liable for the same damage can be made to pay all of it, and is left to recover a contribution from the others (Civil Liability (Contribution) Act 1978, section 1). That right is worth little against an insolvent contractor.
Two terms change the position. A cap limits the total you can be asked for. A net contribution clause limits you to your own share. Both work only if they are properly written, properly agreed and, where the law requires it, reasonable.
When a cap has to be reasonable
Where a client deals on your written standard terms of business, a term that excludes or restricts your liability for breach of contract works only so far as it is reasonable (Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977, section 3). Section 3 does not apply to consumer contracts, which have their own rules.
Three points in the Act matter to a project manager (section 11):
- The term is judged as at the date of the contract, on what the parties knew or ought to have known then. It is not judged with hindsight.
- Where liability is limited to a set sum, the court looks in particular at the resources you could expect to have to meet the liability, and how far it was open to you to insure.
- It is for the party relying on the term to show it is reasonable. That is you.
Terms that were truly negotiated for one project may be outside the test. Most consultancies trade on standard terms, and should assume it applies.
The cap that failed at Ampleforth
In Ampleforth Abbey Trust v Turner & Townsend Project Management the appointment limited the project manager’s liability to the fees paid or £1 million, whichever was less. The fees paid were £111,321. Another clause of the same appointment required the project manager to hold professional indemnity cover of £10 million ([2012] EWHC 2137 (TCC)).
The judge held the cap unreasonable. The central reason was the mismatch between the two clauses: to uphold the cap would have made by far the greater part of the promised insurance illusory. The judge accepted that the contract was freely made and the clause plainly worded, but those points did not outweigh the mismatch. The Trust had never signed the terms, and the project manager had not pointed out that they were new.
The lesson is about drafting. A cap is read beside the rest of the appointment, and above all beside the insurance clause.
Net contribution: paying your share and no more
In West v Ian Finlay & Associates an architect’s appointment with two homeowners limited its liability to the amount reasonable for it to pay, in relation to the contractual responsibilities of the other consultants, contractors and specialists the clients appointed. The main contractor was wound up. The Court of Appeal held that the clause was clear, that it did cover the main contractor, and that it was neither unfair under the consumer regulations then in force nor unreasonable under the 1977 Act ([2014] EWCA Civ 316).
The effect was to move the risk of the contractor’s insolvency from the architect to the clients. The court noted that the clause’s effect had not been drawn to the clients’ attention, which counted against the architect, though not enough to change the result.
For a project manager this clause may be worth more than the cap, because your breach nearly always sits beside someone else’s.
Where your terms and your policy meet
| In your terms | What to check |
|---|---|
| A cap | The cap and the limit of indemnity are different things. If the cap fails, the claim is measured by the loss. When a claim comes, insurers need the full potential figure, not the capped one. |
| No cap, or the client’s own terms | The policy limit is not a cap. Loss above it stays with the consultancy. Tell us what share of your work is done on clients’ terms. |
| Caps you accepted from sub-consultants | Many wordings exclude or limit cover where an agreement you made has restricted your right to recover from someone else. |
| Warranties and third party rights | Usually covered only where they give no greater and no longer lasting benefit than the appointment. Each should repeat the cap and the net contribution clause. |
| Indemnities and guarantees | Promises beyond reasonable skill and care may fall within the contractual liability exclusion, whatever the cap says. |
Six points for a cap with a better chance of holding
- Set the cap beside the insurance you promise. A cap at fee level next to a multi million pound insurance clause invites the Ampleforth argument.
- Put the cap in the proposal and the covering letter, not only in the terms, and say that it is there.
- Get the terms signed, and keep the signed copy.
- Add a net contribution clause, and name the contractor as well as the other consultants.
- Repeat both clauses in every warranty and third party rights schedule.
- Read your sub-consultants’ caps before you accept them, and send us any that are lower than your own. Freelancers and sub-consultants
Not sure your cap would hold?
Send us your standard terms and we will read the cap, the net contribution clause and the insurance clause against your policy.
Related: PI for project managers · Contract reviews · The clause guide