Home / Insights / R&D tax claims: who did what, and fee refund demands
Insights for accountants
R&D tax claims: who did what, and fee refund demands
When HMRC rejects an R&D claim, the adviser often faces two demands at once: give the fee back, and pay for the loss. Your PI treats them very differently, and the roles you took on decide how strong your position is.
Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.
Why R&D claims turn into disputes
R&D relief claims are often sold on a contingent fee, so the client pays only if relief is obtained. When HMRC opens an enquiry and rejects the claim, the client has paid for a result it did not get, and may face repayment, interest and the cost of the enquiry. The adviser is the obvious target.
A rejected claim does not, by itself, show negligence. ICAEW’s guidance on R&D services stresses competence, appropriate specialist help and supporting evidence, and covers firms that contribute to claims directly or indirectly (ICAEW R&D guidance). The question is what you agreed to do and whether you did it properly.
Who did what: the roles in an R&D claim
“We outsource R&D” is not an answer an insurer can work with. Responsibility is usually split across several roles, and each raises a different PI question.
| Role | What it involves | The PI question |
|---|---|---|
| Eligibility assessment | Deciding whether the client’s projects qualify as R&D for tax purposes | Did you make this judgement, or did a specialist? Is it inside your policy’s definition of your business? |
| Project narrative | Describing the advance sought and the uncertainty overcome | Who wrote it, who checked it, and what evidence it relied on |
| Qualifying expenditure | Identifying and calculating staff, subcontractor and consumable costs | Arithmetic and categorisation errors are classic negligence claims |
| Review and submission | Signing off the claim and filing it with the return | Who approved it, and did the client confirm the facts? |
| Enquiry handling | Responding to HMRC questions after submission | Was this inside your engagement and fee, or extra work? |
If you only introduce clients to an R&D specialist and receive a fee for it, you can still be drawn in. Tell insurers about introductions as well as claims you prepare yourself.
One letter, three different demands
A letter of claim after a rejected R&D claim usually mixes three things. Separating them is the first job.
| Demand | How PI usually treats it |
|---|---|
| Return of the fee | Many accountants wordings exclude a straightforward return of fees, or give only a limited benefit. Check yours. |
| The client’s loss | The core of PI cover: penalties, interest, the cost of putting things right, or a better position the client says it would have had with correct advice. |
| Costs of the HMRC enquiry | Claimed as part of the client’s loss. Whether they are recoverable depends on whether your error caused them. |
Remember the tax always due point. If the relief was never available, repaying it to HMRC is not, on its own, a loss you caused. The argument is about what the client would have done differently, and the penalties, interest and costs that followed.
When the letter arrives: the strategy
- Do not repay, reply or admit anything before speaking to us. Agreeing to refund fees without insurers’ consent can prejudice cover for the rest of the claim.
- Notify insurers as a claim, not a fee dispute, setting out the negligence allegation and the enquiry costs alongside the fee demand.
- Gather the engagement letter, who assessed eligibility, the review and sign off record, the client’s confirmation of the facts and its approval of the claim before submission.
- Ask insurers to instruct solicitors to answer the letter of claim, so the defence is funded even if the fee element is not covered.
- If the practice wants to settle the fee element commercially, agree it with insurers in writing first, on terms such as instalments with no admission of liability.
Engagement terms that help
- Define your role precisely: assessment, narrative, figures, review, submission, enquiry support.
- Record that the client confirms the technical facts and approves the claim before it is submitted.
- Say whether the fee is contingent and what happens to it if HMRC later reduces or rejects the claim.
- Name any specialist involved and who contracts with the client.
How we present R&D work to insurers
Insurers price R&D work on the detail: the share of fees, the roles you take on, the fee basis, your review process and any history of enquiries. A clear description usually earns better terms than a vague one. Fair presentation explained
Facing a fee refund demand?
Send us the letter before you reply. We will help you separate the demands and notify insurers properly.
Speak to an accountancy PI specialistPI for accountants and tax advisers
Related: PI for accountants · Claims support · Fair presentation