We would like to set optional cookies to understand how the site is used. Essential cookies keep forms working. Cookie policy.

Home / Insights / Basements and underpinning: when the house next door cracks

Insights for engineers

Basements and underpinning: when the house next door cracks

Basement and underpinning schemes produce a steady flow of claims against structural engineers. Most start the same way: movement in the building next door. This is how that claim travels to you, how it is argued, and what your policy may do with each part.

Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.

How a neighbour’s damage becomes the engineer’s claim

The neighbour has no contract with you, so the claim usually reaches you in two moves. First it lands on your client. The Party Wall etc. Act 1996 applies to excavation within three metres of a neighbouring building that goes deeper than its foundations, and within six metres on a 45 degree test (Party Wall etc. Act 1996, section 6). The building owner must compensate the adjoining owner and occupier for loss or damage resulting from work done under the Act (section 7). The surveyors’ award is conclusive unless it is appealed to the county court within fourteen days (section 10).

Following the Act’s procedure does not relieve your client of liability for the damage. So your client pays, or is ordered to pay, and then looks to the people who designed and built the scheme. The claim against you comes under your appointment: an allegation that the underpinning sequence, the propping or your assessment of the neighbouring foundations fell below reasonable skill and care. A neighbour may also claim against you directly.

Design or workmanship: how the claim is argued

Almost every one of these disputes comes down to one question. Did the building move because of what was drawn, or because of how it was dug? The contractor says it followed your sequence. You say it did not. Each allegation is answered by a record, and the records are made before the damage, not after it.

Allegations in a basement or underpinning claim and the records that answer them
AllegationWhat it turns onThe record that answers it
Sequence and bay widthsWhether the pins were specified in a safe order and width for the ground and the wall aboveDrawings, sequence notes, calculations and the assumptions stated on them
Temporary proppingWho designed it, and whether your drawings said it was the contractor’s to designScope of services, drawing notes and any temporary works design brief
Ground and neighbouring foundationsWhat investigation was available, what you asked for and what you assumedTrial pit records, written requests for information and the caveats in your report
InspectionHow often you agreed to visit and what you saw when you didThe appointment, site visit notes and dated photographs
WorkmanshipWhether the contractor dug and filled the bays as specifiedMethod statements, site diaries and monitoring results

HSE expects temporary works to get the same care as permanent works, and an independent design check on complex schemes (HSE, temporary works). As a designer under CDM 2015 you must eliminate foreseeable risks where you can and pass on information about the rest (regulation 9). Where you relied on a specialist, such as a ground investigation contractor, the court in Co-operative Group v John Allen Associates accepted that an engineer can discharge its duty that way, provided the reliance was reasonable ([2010] EWHC 2300 (TCC)).

What the policy does with each part

  • Is the work insured at all? Some insurers exclude basement and underpinning work, sub-limit it or apply a higher excess, often by endorsement. Insurers will also look at how the work was described in your proposal.
  • The neighbour’s damage. PI usually covers property damage only where negligent design, advice or specification caused it. Damage caused purely by the contractor’s workmanship is not usually your liability, but you may still need a funded defence to show that.
  • The explanation your client wants. A written account of what went wrong can read as an admission. Policies usually require insurers’ consent before you admit liability or offer to pay.
  • Your other roles. IStructE’s guidance says acting as party wall surveyor and as structural adviser needs two separate appointments (IStructE, responsibilities of a member). Each role must also fall within the policy’s description of your business.
  • Your fees. Unpaid fees are not insured. If the client withholds them, speak to us before you chase. A fee claim often draws a counterclaim.

What to do in the first week

  1. Tell us the day you hear of movement, whoever seems to be at fault. Cracking next door is a circumstance, and we notify insurers before any formal claim arrives.
  2. Give the factual safety advice needed to stabilise both buildings. That protects people and limits the loss. Leave any view on cause until insurers agree.
  3. Do not write the explanation your client asks for, or reply to the neighbour’s surveyor on liability, without insurers’ consent.
  4. Ask insurers to instruct an independent engineer early, to record crack widths, monitoring results and the excavated bays before the evidence is concreted over.
  5. Secure the contractor’s method statements, photographs and site diaries, and gather your own appointment, drawings, sequence and site visit notes.

Before you take on the next basement scheme

  • Set out in the appointment who designs the sequence, the temporary works and the waterproofing, and how often you will visit.
  • Say on the drawings which elements are for the contractor or a specialist to design.
  • Record what you assumed about the ground and the neighbouring foundations, and ask in writing for the trial pits you need.
  • Recommend a schedule of condition and movement monitoring before excavation starts, and keep a note if the client declines.
  • Ask for a liability cap and a net contribution clause. The Court of Appeal upheld a net contribution clause in a consultant’s appointment in West v Ian Finlay ([2014] EWCA Civ 316).

How we present basement work to insurers

“Some basement work” tells an insurer nothing it can use. We set out the number of schemes, their depth and type, who designs the sequence and temporary works, whether waterproofing is in your scope, how often you inspect and what your appointments say about liability. A practice that can show this is easier to place, and less likely to find a restriction it did not expect when a claim arrives. Fair presentation explained

Movement next door to one of your schemes?

Call us before you write to anyone, and we will notify insurers and help you protect the evidence.

Speak to a PI specialistPI for engineers

Related: PI for engineers · Claims support · Fair presentation