---
title: "Planning appeals from April 2026: what it means for PI"
description: "For applications from 1 April 2026, most refusals are appealed with no statement of case and no new evidence. What that means for planners’ risk and PI."
url: "https://www.hammondpi.com/insights/town-planners-appeals-april-2026/"
updated: "2026-11-20T06:10:05.602Z"
---

[Home](https://www.hammondpi.com/index.md) / [Insights](https://www.hammondpi.com/insights.md) / Planning appeals after 1 April 2026: the application is now the appeal

Insights for town planners

# Planning appeals after 1 April 2026: the application is now the appeal

For applications made on or after 1 April 2026, a refusal is appealed with no statement of case and no new evidence. The Inspector decides on what the authority saw. For planning consultants, the risk has moved from the appeal to the day of submission.

What changedThe exceptionsWhere claims startCosts and AIYour coverControls

Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.

## What changed on 1 April 2026

The Planning Inspectorate’s procedural guide for applications dated on or after 1 April 2026 puts appeals against a refusal under section 78 on what it calls the Part 1 written representations procedure ([Planning Inspectorate guide](https://www.gov.uk/guidance/planning-appeals-procedural-guide-for-appeals-relating-to-applications-dated-on-or-after-1-april-2026)).

-   There is no opportunity for the appellant or the authority to submit a statement of case.
-   The Inspector considers the application as the authority determined it, the decision notice, any committee minutes and officer’s report, the appeal form and the authority’s questionnaire.
-   The appellant cannot submit evidence the authority has not already considered.
-   Interested people cannot comment at the appeal stage. What they said on the application is still read.

Appeals against non-determination and listed building consent appeals follow a separate Part 2 procedure. The Inspectorate chooses the procedure, and can move a case to Part 2, a hearing or an inquiry. The time limits for appealing still apply, and a late appeal is not accepted.

## The narrow exceptions, and the real remedy

The guide allows new material only in limited cases. They include a material and relevant change in development plan or national planning policy, a relevant court judgment, and some matters to do with planning obligations. The decision whether to admit it is the Inspectorate’s alone.

Policy does change during the life of an application. The current National Planning Policy Framework was published on 17 August 2026 and applied to decisions from that day ([NPPF, Annex A](https://www.gov.uk/guidance/national-planning-policy-framework-annex-a-implementation)). Whether a change helps a particular appeal is a planning judgement. It is not a way to mend an incomplete application.

For everything else the guide points one way. If an amendment or new evidence would overcome the reasons for refusal, the applicant should make a new application. Evidence sent with the appeal instead will be disregarded. For the client that means a second application, more time and, sometimes, a different policy position when it is decided.

## Where the claims will start

Under the old habits a weak application could be strengthened at appeal. Those habits now produce a different result.

Old application habits, what happens under the Part 1 procedure and the complaint that follows

Old habit

What happens now

What the client says afterwards

“We will deal with highways at appeal”

The transport note cannot be added

It would have paid for the report had you said the appeal depended on it

A short planning statement, with the full case saved for the appeal

There is no statement of case to put it in

The refusal stood on a case you never made

A consultee objection left unanswered before the decision

The Inspector reads the objection and finds no reply

You knew about the objection and did not deal with it

Submitting early to meet the client’s programme

The gaps in the application become the gaps in the appeal

Nobody warned it in writing what submitting early could cost

These are illustrations. In each, the dispute is about what you advised before submission, and whether you can prove it.

## Costs awards and AI declarations

Parties normally meet their own appeal expenses. A party that behaves unreasonably, and causes another party unnecessary expense, risks an award of costs. A client ordered to pay one may look to its adviser.

The Inspectorate also expects anyone who uses AI to draft or substantially rewrite text, to summarise or analyse, or to create or alter images in appeal material to declare it. The declaration should give the checks made and take responsibility for accuracy. Each expert needs their own, and improper use may be treated as unreasonable behaviour ([Planning Inspectorate, AI in casework evidence](https://www.gov.uk/guidance/use-of-artificial-intelligence-in-casework-evidence)).

Under Part 1 the application documents are what the Inspector reads. A policy reference that does not exist, or a summary that misstates a consultee, cannot be corrected in a later statement. The checking has to happen when the documents are written.

## What it means for your cover

Your PI covers your professional work whichever procedure applies, subject to its terms. What changes is when an error becomes fixed, and whether it can be put right.

-   **Notification.** A refusal that you think flowed from a gap in your own submission can be a circumstance before the client complains. Tell us when you see it.
-   **Rescue costs.** The rescue is now a revised application. Some wordings pay agreed mitigation costs and others do not, and consent before you spend is the usual condition.
-   **Fees.** A client asked to pay for a second application may refuse, or ask for the first fee back. Many wordings exclude the return of fees, so the fee argument and the negligence allegation need separating early.
-   **Scope.** The file should show who decided the application was ready, and what the client was told.
-   **Presentation.** Insurers may ask how you have adapted. A clear account of your submission controls is part of presenting the risk. [Fair presentation explained](https://www.hammondpi.com/insights/fair-presentation.md)

## Controls worth having in place

1.  A readiness check by a senior planner before every submission, against the validation list and the likely reasons for refusal.
2.  A tracker for consultee responses, with a reply on the file before the decision wherever one is needed.
3.  A written warning, kept on file, whenever the client chooses to submit without a report you recommended.
4.  A conversation with the client about asking the authority for more time when an objection arrives late.
5.  The appeal period diaried by two people on the day the decision arrives.
6.  A record of any AI use in drafting, and of who checked the output.

Tell us about these at renewal, and we will put them in front of insurers. [How renewal works](https://www.hammondpi.com/renewal.md)

## Changed how you prepare applications?

Tell us what you do now, and we will make sure insurers see the controls behind your work.

[Speak to a PI specialist](https://www.hammondpi.com/contact.md)[PI for town planners](https://www.hammondpi.com/who-we-cover/town-planners.md)

Related: [PI for town planners](https://www.hammondpi.com/who-we-cover/town-planners.md) · [Fair presentation](https://www.hammondpi.com/insights/fair-presentation.md) · [Renewal](https://www.hammondpi.com/renewal.md)
