We would like to set optional cookies to understand how the site is used. Essential cookies keep forms working. Cookie policy.

Home / Insights / Missed planning deadlines: appeal, challenge and enforcement dates and your PI

Insights for town planners

Missed planning deadlines: appeal, challenge and enforcement dates and your PI

Most professions can ask for more time. Planners often cannot. An appeal period, a High Court challenge window or an enforcement notice date passes, and the client’s remedy against the council becomes a claim against you.

Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.

Why a missed date is the planner’s defining claim

Planning law runs on fixed periods, and the bodies that apply them do not bend. The Planning Inspectorate says that if it does not receive an appeal and its supporting documents within the time limit, it will not accept the appeal (Planning Inspectorate guide).

The courts take the same line. In Croke v Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government, the six weeks to challenge an appeal decision ended on 23 March 2016. The claimant’s representative reached the court building at about 4.25pm that day and was told the counters had closed. The claim was filed on 29 March. The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal, describing the six weeks as a strict time limit set by Parliament (read the judgment).

When a date like that is missed on your file, the client’s argument with the council is over. Its argument with you begins.

The dates that cannot be moved

These are the main periods for England. Always check the decision notice or the notice served, because the document itself states the date that binds.

Planning deadlines in England and where each is set out
StepTime allowedSource
Appeal against a householder or minor commercial refusalTwelve weeks from the date on the decision noticePlanning Inspectorate guide
Appeal against refusal of advertisement consentEight weeksPlanning Inspectorate guide
Most other planning appealsSix monthsPlanning Inspectorate guide
Planning appeal where an enforcement notice covers the same developmentAs little as 28 daysPlanning Inspectorate guide
Appeal against an enforcement noticeBefore the date the notice takes effectSection 174
High Court challenge to an appeal decisionSix weeks beginning with the day after the decisionSection 288
Judicial review of a planning decisionSix weeks, with no extension by agreementCPR 54.5
Request to correct an error in an appeal decisionWithin the same six weeksPlanning Inspectorate guide
Appeal against a CIL surcharge or a deemed commencement date28 daysCIL regulation 117 and regulation 118

How a date gets missed

Typical routes, given as illustrations.

  • The date lives in one person’s diary, and that person is on holiday or has left.
  • The client is slow to confirm instructions or to pay, and the file waits while the period runs.
  • The period is counted from the wrong day. An appeal period runs from the date on the decision notice, not the day it reached you.
  • The appeal form is ready but a supporting document is not. The Inspectorate needs both inside the time limit.
  • Submission is left to the last afternoon, and a portal, an email address or a train fails.
  • Nobody agreed who held the date. The planner, the architect, the solicitor and the client each thought it was someone else.

How the claim is argued

A claim over a missed date usually turns on three questions.

Was the date yours? The engagement terms decide it. RTPI members must give written terms of engagement before work starts (RTPI Code), and those terms should say whether appeals, challenges, conditions and levy notices are inside the instruction.

Was there a breach? If the date was yours and it passed, this is seldom the real fight.

What did the client lose? This is the question that decides the size of the claim. The client usually claims the value of the scheme. The better measure is usually the chance that the appeal or challenge would have succeeded, tested against the officer’s report, the reasons for refusal and the policies in force. If a fresh application can still be made, the loss may shrink to delay and the cost of applying again. In Elvanite v AMEC, a client claimed the lost profit on a site sale from a planning consultant whose fee was £13,225. The judge found that the consultant’s breaches had not caused the loss (read the judgment).

What the policy does with each part

  • The discovery. Most wordings respond to a claim made, or a circumstance notified, during the policy period. Finding that a date has passed is usually a circumstance on the day you find it, whether or not the client knows.
  • The rescue. Some wordings pay the agreed cost of putting an error right before it becomes a claim, such as a resubmitted application. Others only require you to reduce the loss. Consent before you spend is the usual condition.
  • The client’s loss. This is the core of the cover: the lost chance, the delay and the wasted costs your error caused, up to the limit.
  • Your own fee. Many wordings exclude the return or reduction of fees. Waiving or refunding a fee is a commercial decision, but agree it with insurers first so that it is not read as an admission.
  • Costs awards and surcharges. Fines and penalties are commonly excluded. A costs award or levy surcharge that the client claims from you as damages may be argued either way, depending on the wording.

Each of these terms is explained in the clause guide.

The day you find it

  1. Read the notice and count again. Confirm the date has really gone, and list every other date still running on the file.
  2. Look for the routes still open: a fresh application, an appeal on other grounds, a correction request or a challenge that is still in time.
  3. Call us the same day. We help you notify insurers as a circumstance, with the engagement terms and a short chronology.
  4. Ask insurers to agree any rescue cost before you spend it.
  5. Tell the client promptly and factually, in terms agreed with insurers, without admitting liability or promising to pay.
  6. Keep the file intact: instructions, diary entries, emails and drafts as they stood.

How we support claims

Found a date that has passed?

Call us before you write to the client, and we will help you notify insurers and protect the routes that are still open.

Speak to a PI specialistPI for town planners

Related: PI for town planners · Claims support · The clause guide