---
title: "Will execution claims and will writers’ PI"
description: "How a claim over a wrongly signed or witnessed will is argued against a will writer, what the codes expect, and how a PI policy treats each part of it."
url: "https://www.hammondpi.com/insights/will-writers-unsupervised-signing-claims/"
updated: "2026-11-20T06:10:05.725Z"
---

[Home](https://www.hammondpi.com/index.md) / [Insights](https://www.hammondpi.com/insights.md) / Wills signed at home: how an execution claim against a will writer is argued

Insights for legal service providers

# Wills signed at home: how an execution claim against a will writer is argued

Many claims against will writers are not about what the will says. They are about how it was signed. The claim arrives when the client dies, from someone you never met, and it turns on what your file shows about one afternoon years ago.

The formalitiesThe dutyThe codesThe policyWhen it arrivesHow long

Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.

## Four formalities, and one trap for witnesses

A will is valid only if it meets section 9 of the Wills Act 1837. It must be in writing and signed by the testator, or by someone else in the testator’s presence and at their direction. It must appear that the testator intended the signature to give effect to the will. The signature must be made or acknowledged in the presence of two or more witnesses present at the same time. Each witness must then attest and sign, or acknowledge their signature, in the testator’s presence ([Wills Act 1837, section 9](https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/Will4and1Vict/7/26/section/9)).

Section 15 adds the trap. A gift to a witness, or to a witness’s spouse or civil partner, is void, although the witness can still prove the will ([section 15](https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/Will4and1Vict/7/26/section/15)). The will survives. The gift does not.

One more date matters. For wills made from 31 January 2020 to 31 January 2024, “presence” included presence by video link. Wills witnessed on screen in those four years are still in will banks, waiting to be tested.

## What the court expected of the firm in Humblestone

In _Humblestone v Martin Tolhurst Partnership_ a firm prepared a will for signature. The client dated it twice but never signed it, and the witnesses signed without him present. The will was handed in to the firm, where a member of staff, probably a secretary, said it was in order. The firm then kept it. After the client died, the main beneficiary claimed the value of what she had lost ([\[2004\] EWHC 151 (Ch)](https://caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ewhc/ch/2004/151)).

The High Court held that the firm owed a duty to check that the will appeared to be validly executed, whether or not it had been asked to. The duty arose because the firm took the will for safekeeping and, separately, because it checked the will and pronounced it in order. It was owed to the client and to his principal beneficiary.

That firm was a firm of solicitors. A will writer who offers the same service may be measured in the same way.

## What the two will writing codes add

Both main codes deal with signing, and a claimant’s solicitor will usually read yours.

What the will writing codes say about signing and records

Point

Institute of Professional Willwriters

Society of Will Writers

Supervised signing

Clients not identified as low risk should be encouraged to have signing supervised. The service must be offered at no extra cost for new documents (clause 10.1).

Clients must be given the opportunity to have signing supervised. The terms of business must say whether this is chargeable (clause 6.4).

If the client signs alone

Written advice on the consequences of incorrect attestation, with written instructions on the procedure (clause 10.3).

The code does not prescribe the instructions.

Checking the returned will

A free postal service to check that documents appear to have been attested correctly (clause 10.3.3).

A free service to check, as far as is practical, that documents appear to have been attested correctly (clause 6.4).

Keeping the file

Not less than six years after the client’s death (clause 7.3.10).

A copy of the client file must be available on demand, without time limit (clause 6.6).

Sources: [IPW Code of Practice, May 2019](https://approvedcode.tradingstandards.uk/media/xy4d4st5/ipw-code-of-practice.pdf); [SWW Code of Practice, version 2024.01](https://www.willwriters.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/SWW-Code-of-Practice-2024.01.pdf).

## How the policy treats each part of the claim

A letter of claim usually contains several demands. A PI policy may answer each differently, depending on its wording.

-   **The lost inheritance.** This is the core of the cover: civil liability arising from your professional work. The claimant was never your client, so check that the insuring clause is not limited to claims by clients.
-   **Putting the estate right.** Beneficiaries may redirect an estate by a written variation within two years of the death, and inheritance tax then applies as if the deceased had made the change ([Inheritance Tax Act 1984, section 142](https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1984/51/section/142)). A court can also rectify a will that fails to carry out the testator’s intentions because of a clerical error or a failure to understand instructions, on an application made within six months of the grant unless the court permits a later one ([Administration of Justice Act 1982, section 20](https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1982/53/section/20)). Either route may cost far less than damages. Any contribution from you needs insurers’ agreement first.
-   **Your fees.** A demand for the return of the fee is commonly excluded.
-   **The date of the work.** If the will was drafted before the retroactive date in your schedule, the policy may not respond at all.

## When the letter arrives

1.  Acknowledge the letter and say nothing more. The Institute of Professional Willwriters’ code asks members to acknowledge an allegation of negligence immediately and have it passed on for insurers to act (clause 16.2). Send it to us the same day and we will notify insurers for you.
2.  Pull the whole file: the instructions, the signing letter, any note of the returned will being checked, and the storage record.
3.  Do not explain, apologise or offer a refund. What you write to a beneficiary’s solicitor can be read later as an admission.
4.  Tell us the date of the will and every policy you have held since. We would check the retroactive date and whether the problem was notified before.
5.  Ask whether the same signing process was used for other clients in the same period. Those wills may need notifying as circumstances.

## How long the exposure lasts

Under the Limitation Act 1980 a negligence claim can be brought within six years of the cause of action accruing, or three years from the date of knowledge if later, with a long stop fifteen years after the negligent act ([section 14A](https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1980/58/section/14A), [section 14B](https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1980/58/section/14B)). How those periods apply to a particular will is a question for the solicitors insurers appoint. For your practice the lesson is simpler. The signing record has to outlive the client, and so does the cover. [Run off cover explained](https://www.hammondpi.com/insights/run-off-cover.md)

## Had a letter about an old will?

Send it to us before you reply, with the will file, and we will notify insurers and tell you what the policy needs from you.

[Speak to a PI specialist](https://www.hammondpi.com/contact.md)[PI for legal service providers](https://www.hammondpi.com/who-we-cover/legal-services-costs-consultants-and-will-writers.md)

Related: [PI for legal services and will writers](https://www.hammondpi.com/who-we-cover/legal-services-costs-consultants-and-will-writers.md) · [Claims support](https://www.hammondpi.com/claims-support.md) · [Run off cover](https://www.hammondpi.com/insights/run-off-cover.md)
