We would like to set optional cookies to understand how the site is used. Essential cookies keep forms working. Cookie policy.

Home / Who we cover / Design and construct / Specification or installation

Case study | Design and build wordings

Was it the specification or the installation?

Imagine an office refurbishment. The client asked for a meeting room where private conversations could take place. After handover, people in the adjoining office can hear every word. The firm that specified and fitted the partition is asked to put it right.

“Show me where the policy deals with our design decision if the customer also criticises the installation. Does the same protection appear in the products clause?”

The complaint. The meeting room was meant to be private, but next door can hear every word. The client can question the specification and the installation in the same complaint.

A fictional illustration. The response to an actual claim depends on the facts, the full wording, the schedule and any endorsements.

Was the wrong partition chosen? Were there gaps around the frame? The drawings, product data and a site inspection may eventually settle that question. In the meantime, the client can reasonably question both the specification and the installation in the same complaint.

That distinction matters when buying professional indemnity insurance. In a review of design and build PI wordings, Hammond looked at how different policies treated a firm that both advises on a product and installs it. Three extracts show why seeing design and specification on the schedule is only the start.

Wording A | How far does the workmanship exclusion reach?

The exclusion refers to “any defective workmanship or materials”. Its reach comes from words printed earlier in the policy. The opening words apply the exclusions to “any claim directly or indirectly due to, arising out of, contributed to by, or in any way connected to” the matters listed.

Read those phrases together. If the client alleges gaps around the frame, the insurer could argue that the complaint is connected to defective workmanship. This particular workmanship exclusion contains no express exception for negligent design. Even if the client also alleges that the specified partition could never have delivered the privacy promised, there is a question about how far the exclusion reaches into that part of the complaint.

Wording B | What does the exception preserve?

A different policy excludes construction and installation, then adds “unless it was caused by a breach of any duty owed by You in respect of which You are entitled to any indemnity from Us under Insuring Clause 1.1”. Its products exclusion contains the same qualification.

Here, the word “unless” sends the reader back to the main insuring clause. Suppose the partition was installed exactly as drawn, but the firm negligently specified a system unsuitable for the brief. The wording gives the firm an express basis for asking the insurer to consider liability arising from that professional error, even though the firm also supplied and installed the partition. If the specification was suitable and poor fitting alone caused the problem, the same exception would not, by itself, pay for replacing it.

Wording C | Does the exception appear in both places?

A third policy’s workmanship exclusion expressly refers to “liability arising from negligent design or specification of materials”, subject to requirements about who undertook the work. That looks helpful for the firm that chose the partition. But the policy also has a separate exclusion addressing installation of “goods or products sold, supplied or distributed by or on behalf of the Insured”. That clause has no equivalent design exception.

The practical question is who supplied the partition. A consultant who only recommended it and a contractor who recommended, supplied and fitted it could face the same criticism about its acoustic performance. For the contractor, there is a further clause to consider. The exception in the workmanship exclusion does not amend the separate products exclusion.

What Hammond took back to the underwriter

We favoured the wording that expressly addressed professional error in both the construction and products exclusions. We also secured amendments to reflect the professional services the business carried out. That gave the client a specific reason for our recommendation and a way to judge competing terms against its own work.

If your firm specifies something it also supplies or installs, a useful question at renewal is “Show me where the policy deals with our design decision if the customer also criticises the installation. Does the same protection appear in the products clause?”

The meeting room is a fictional illustration. The quoted phrases are extracts from separate policy wordings. The response to an actual claim depends on the facts, the full wording, the schedule and any endorsements.