Home / Insights / Who requires an actuarial firm to hold PI, and how much?
Insights for actuaries and pension consultants
Who requires an actuarial firm to hold PI, and how much?
No single rule sets a PI minimum for every actuarial firm. The IFoA sets a duty for its members and figures for the firms it licenses, and the FCA sets figures for the firms it authorises. Here is what each asks for, and where firms get caught.
Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.
Three sources, and more than one can apply
Which rule applies depends on who you are and what you do, not on the size of your firm.
| Source | Who it binds | What it sets |
|---|---|---|
| IFoA, APS X5 | IFoA members who are principals in a firm doing actuarial work for external clients | A duty to have appropriate arrangements in place. No figure. |
| IFoA, DPB Handbook | Firms the IFoA licenses to carry on a limited range of regulated activities | A minimum sum insured, maximum excesses, retroactive cover and run off. |
| FCA Handbook | Firms the FCA authorises, such as insurance intermediaries and personal investment firms | Minimum limits that depend on the firm’s permissions. |
A firm can fall under more than one, and a promise in your appointment terms to hold a stated level of cover is a contract term in its own right.
APS X5: a duty on the individual, with no figure
APS X5 has applied since 20 November 2020 (IFoA, APS X5). It binds a member who is a “Principal”, meaning a member who is responsible for, or has material input into, deciding how the firm compensates clients for professional shortcomings. That member must consider the loss external clients could reasonably foreseeably suffer, direct or indirect, through negligence or breach of duty in the actuarial work, and ensure that “Appropriate Arrangements” are in place.
The arrangements are not prescribed. The standard gives four examples: the scope and extent of PII, the contract terms with the client, the employer’s resources and the member’s own resources. Its second paragraph is the one to act on. The member must be in a position to justify the arrangements if reasonably called upon to do so, and a failure to comply may result in a finding of misconduct.
In practice we would keep a short note at each renewal: your largest schemes and transactions, the caps in your terms and the clients outside them, the limit chosen and why. That note is your justification.
The DPB licence: figures for each relevant person
Firms licensed by the IFoA as a Designated Professional Body must meet the PII rules in its Handbook, in force from 15 September 2020 (IFoA DPB Handbook, paragraphs 6.18 to 6.30). The figures turn on the number of “relevant persons”: principals on the IFoA’s roll as Fellows, Associates, Affiliates or Students, and officers and employees who are Fellows, Associates or Affiliates.
- Sum insured. At least the lower of £5,000,000 or £250,000 for each relevant person, per claim and in aggregate.
- Aggregate excess. No more than the lower of 15% of the sum insured or £37,500 for each relevant person.
- Excess per claim. No more than the lower of 5% of the sum insured or £12,500 for each relevant person.
- Retroactive cover. Work carried out in the previous five years, other than matters known at inception.
- Run off. At least two years after the licence ends, the firm stops practising, or a merger or reorganisation.
- Insurance distribution. In addition, at least €1,250,000 for a single claim and €1,850,000 in aggregate.
An illustration: a firm with six relevant persons has a minimum of £1,500,000. On that sum insured, the aggregate excess may not exceed £225,000 and an excess per claim may not exceed £75,000. The Handbook is clear that these are floors. Where a firm advises clients with significant assets, such as a large pension scheme, it says a sum insured far above the minimum will “almost invariably” be appropriate.
FCA authorised firms: figures by permission
If your firm is FCA authorised, the limits come from the FCA Handbook.
- Insurance intermediaries (MIPRU 3.2). €1,300,380 for a single claim. In aggregate, the higher of €1,924,560 or 10% of annual income, up to £30 million. The excess may be no more than the higher of £2,500 or 1.5% of annual income, or the higher of £5,000 or 3% where the firm holds client money or assets.
- Personal investment firms (IPRU-INV 13.1). Relevant income up to £3,000,000: at least £500,000 for a single claim and £500,000 in aggregate. Above that: at least £650,000 for a single claim and £1,000,000 in aggregate, with higher aggregate limits once relevant income passes £10,000,000.
The IFoA Handbook’s euro figures are lower than the FCA’s current ones. We give each as its own source states it.
Where firms get caught
- Headcount. The IFoA figures move with the number of relevant persons. Recruiting or promoting members can raise the minimum during the policy year.
- Excess. An excess agreed at renewal can pass the Handbook’s cap without anyone checking it against the rule.
- Retroactive date. A change of insurer can reset it. The rule asks for five years. Your real exposure is usually longer.
- Mergers. The Handbook requires two years of run off after a merger or reorganisation. Decide whose policy answers for the predecessor’s work before completion.
- Business description. A compliant limit is of little use if the regulated work is excluded or was never described to insurers.
- Complaints. The Handbook reminds licensed firms to have regard to their PII terms when a complaint is made, because it may need notifying as a claim or a circumstance.
Setting the limit above the minimum
Every figure above was written for regulated activities, not for the size of the schemes you advise. APS X5 asks a different question: what loss could your clients foreseeably suffer? We would answer it by testing the limit against your largest scheme and transaction, the caps in your terms and how many clients sit outside them, who else may rely on your reports, and whether the limit is any one claim or in aggregate.
The rules for each body are set out side by side on our page for actuaries and pension consultants.
Not sure which rule applies to you?
Send us your schedule and a note of your IFoA licence or FCA permissions, and we will check the cover against each rule.
Speak to a PI specialistPI for actuaries and pension consultants
Related: PI for actuaries and pension consultants · Renewal · Run off cover