We would like to set optional cookies to understand how the site is used. Essential cookies keep forms working. Cookie policy.

Home / Who we cover / Actuaries and pension consultants

Actuaries and pension consultants

Professional indemnity for actuaries and pension consultants

PI for actuarial and pensions firms, read clause by clause by specialist brokers. We know how scheme actuary, consulting, administration and employee benefits work each give rise to claims, what the IFoA and the FCA require, and where general wordings fall short.

Speak to a PI specialistSend us your renewal for reviewGet a quote

  • Since 1990Specialist PI brokers
  • 30+ insurersPlus specialist agencies and Lloyd’s
  • 4.9 out of 5From 228 Google reviews
  • FCA authorisedFRN 302911, independently owned

Your map

The actuaries and pension consultants map: from your work to the policy and beyond

Your firm’s work on one side, the policy on the other. Select a point to see what it connects to, then follow the link to the part of this page that explains it.

Still 3D render (motion off)

The map, area by area

Each heading below is one area of the map, and the number shows how many points it holds. Open a heading and tap any point: it lights up on the map with everything it connects to, and a short note explains why.

Practice and business risks 12

Your terms and framework agreements 7

Engagements and contracts 6

Legislation 2

Policy documents and schedule 11

Main policy wording 7

Exclusions and restrictions 1

Succession, closure and earlier work 4

Other insurance and final assessment 7

Our experience

Why actuaries and pension consultants come to a specialist

Two firms with the same fees can carry very different exposure. A scheme actuary appointment, a valuation relied on in a company sale, a bulk annuity project, pensioner payroll for 30,000 members and a group life placing all sit behind similar invoices. Small fees support decisions worth many millions, and errors can stay hidden for years.

Hammond PI has specialised in professional indemnity since 1990. We read the wording itself: how it defines your professional business, treats regulated advice and trustee roles, groups related claims, applies the excess to many claimants and deals with ombudsman awards. Then we present your firm to more than 30 insurers, specialist agencies and Lloyd’s, so they underwrite the work you actually do.

When a problem arises we stay involved. We help you notify it properly, put the matter to insurers, gather what they need and follow it through with the claims handler.

  1. The workValuations, funding advice, transactions, administration, investment and benefits consulting, in their real proportions
  2. What can go wrongWrong assumptions or data, benefit errors repeated across members, missing documents, reliance by others
  3. What the policy must answerBusiness definition, regulated work, aggregation, excess per claimant, ombudsman awards, past work and caps
  4. How we present itA clear submission, questions answered and wordings compared across insurers

Who requires PI

Check who requires your PI, and what they ask for

No single rule sets a minimum for every actuarial or pensions firm. It depends on your IFoA membership, any Designated Professional Body licence and any FCA permissions.

PI requirements: Who requires PI
WhoMinimum coverExcessAfter you stopOther conditions
Institute and Faculty of Actuaries, APS X5No figure is set. A member who is a principal in a firm doing actuarial work for external clients must consider the loss those clients could foreseeably suffer, make sure “appropriate arrangements” for compensation are in place, and be able to justify them.Not specifiedNot specifiedThe arrangements are not prescribed. The standard gives the scope and extent of PII, the contract terms with the client, the employer’s resources and the member’s own resources as examples. A breach may be treated as misconduct.
IFoA Designated Professional Body licenceAt least the lower of £5,000,000 or £250,000 for each relevant person in the firm (broadly, principals and staff who are IFoA members). Firms licensed for insurance distribution must also hold at least €1,250,000 for a single claim and €1,850,000 in aggregate. Basis: each claim and in aggregate.Aggregate excess no more than the lower of 15% of the sum insured or £37,500 per relevant person. Excess per claim no more than the lower of 5% of the sum insured or £12,500 per relevant person.At least two years after the licence ends, the firm stops practising, or a merger or reorganisationRetroactive cover for work in the previous five years. The Handbook strongly recommends far more than the minimum where clients have significant assets, such as a large pension scheme.
FCA, insurance intermediaries (MIPRU 3.2)€1,300,380 for a single claim. In aggregate, the higher of €1,924,560 or 10% of annual income, up to a maximum of £30 million. Basis: single claim and aggregate.No more than the higher of £2,500 or 1.5% of annual income. Where the firm holds client money or other client assets, the higher of £5,000 or 3% of annual income.Not specified in the rules we readApplies to FCA authorised insurance intermediaries. A policy in another currency must be at least equivalent to the euro limits when it is placed and at each renewal. Which FCA sourcebook applies depends on the firm’s permissions.
FCA, personal investment firms (IPRU-INV 13.1)Relevant income up to £3,000,000: at least £500,000 for a single claim and £500,000 in aggregate. Above £3,000,000: at least £650,000 for a single claim and £1,000,000 in aggregate. Firms that are also insurance intermediaries: at least €1,300,380 for a single claim and €1,924,560 in aggregate. Basis: single claim and aggregate.Not specified in the rules we readNot specified in the rules we readHigher aggregate limits apply once relevant income passes £10,000,000, starting at £2,000,000. FCA guidance says cover should extend to the firm’s appointed representatives, employees and agents.

Sources: IFoA members (APS X5 version 1.0, effective 20 November 2020), IFoA licensed firms (DPB Handbook in force from 15 September 2020), FCA insurance distribution (MIPRU 3.2.7R (dated 1 August 2021), as shown on 19 November 2026), FCA investment firms (IPRU-INV 13.1.10R and 13.1.13R (dated 1 January 2022), as shown on 19 November 2026). Firms answering to more than one must meet each set of rules.

A minimum is not a recommendation. Many firms need more, and cover for each and every claim can protect better than an aggregate limit.

Why the minimum is rarely the right limit

These figures were written for regulated activities, not for the size of the schemes you advise. One valuation, factor or data error can move liabilities by millions, and an administration fault can repeat across thousands of members. Set the limit against your largest scheme and transaction, the caps in your terms and who else may rely on the work. Then check whether related claims share one limit.

Claim scenarios

When a claim arrives: how we would handle it

Situations actuaries and pension consultants face, the risk hidden in each, and the strategy we would follow from the first letter. Choose a scenario.

Trustees ask for a retrospective section 37 confirmation of a 2004 amendment

The situationYour firm has been scheme actuary since 2001. Preparing for buy-out, the trustees’ lawyers cannot find the actuary’s written confirmation for a 2004 deed that reduced future accrual. They ask the current scheme actuary for a confirmation under section 102 of the Pension Schemes Act 2026, quickly, because the insurer is waiting.

The riskTwo exposures in one request. The missing 2004 confirmation is old work by your own firm, and a fresh opinion is new work with its own liability. Signing under deadline pressure on thin evidence, or quietly doing the work without charge, can look like an admission and leaves the old problem unnotified.

Our strategy

  1. Notify insurers now of the missing 2004 confirmation as a circumstance, naming the scheme, the deed and the possible cost if the amendment cannot be validated.
  2. Check the retroactive date reaches 2004 and which entity held the appointment then. A merger or change of insurer since may have moved either.
  3. Take the new instruction in writing, as the Act requires, limited to the statutory question and to the alterations the trustees list, on your current terms and cap.
  4. Follow the FRC’s guidance for this work: record the information relied on, the assumptions made and why the conclusion is reasonable. If the evidence is insufficient, say so.
  5. Agree with insurers what is said to the trustees about the 2004 file before anything is conceded about fees or fault.

What we aim forThe old gap held by the current policy, the new opinion given on a documented and proportionate basis, and no admission made under transaction pressure.

The lessonA request to confirm an old amendment is also notice of a possible problem with old work.

A pension increase rule is coded wrongly and 2,400 pensioners are overpaid

The situationYour administration team loaded the wrong increase rule for one benefit tranche when three schemes moved onto your platform in 2019. An audit finds 2,400 pensioners overpaid for six years. The trustees want the records rebuilt at your cost and the overpayments made good.

The riskSome general wordings apply the excess to each claimant, and each scheme’s trustees may claim separately. Fixing everything quietly at your own cost can breach the admissions condition, and rectification work is not automatically an insured loss. Notifying one scheme leaves the other two exposed.

Our strategy

  1. Read the aggregation and excess wording together. One originating cause should mean one claim and one excess, but only if the words say so.
  2. Notify the coding error as one circumstance, naming all three schemes, the tranche, the period and an estimate, including members who have not yet been told.
  3. Ask insurers to agree the correction plan and its cost before work starts, where the wording allows mitigation costs with consent.
  4. Leave recovery of overpayments to the trustees and their lawyers. Members may have defences, so the balance that cannot be recouped becomes the real measure of the claim.
  5. Check the limit against the total across all three schemes, because a single claim has a single limit.

What we aim forOne claim, one excess, a correction plan insurers have agreed to, and every affected scheme protected by the same notification.

The lessonAdministration errors repeat. The aggregation and excess words decide how the policy counts them.

After a buy-in, the insurer’s data cleanse produces a £3 million true-up

The situationYour firm administered the scheme and also advised the trustees on a £180 million buy-in. The insurer’s data cleanse after the transaction finds spouses’ pensions understated in the data and the benefit specification. It issues a £3 million premium adjustment. The trustees ask who signed off the data.

The riskTwo roles, two sets of terms and perhaps two legal entities. The project terms may contain data warranties or indemnities wider than ordinary negligence, which a PI policy can exclude. Waiting for a formal letter of claim risks late notification of something you already know about.

Our strategy

  1. Notify on the true-up notice, not the later letter of claim, describing both the administration role and the advisory role.
  2. Pull both engagement terms and compare caps, exclusions and any warranty about data accuracy. Tell insurers at once about any term that goes beyond reasonable skill and care.
  3. Establish what the trustees were told about data quality and residual risk before signing, and who chose not to cleanse first.
  4. Separate benefits that were always due from loss caused by the error. A premium for liabilities that were always owed may not be loss at all.
  5. Check each entity is a named insured, and whether the two roles count as one claim under the aggregation wording.

What we aim forThe claim defended on what the trustees knew and what they have really lost, with cover intact for both roles.

The lessonOn a bulk annuity project, send us the terms before you sign. Warranties are where cover is lost.

A member retires on an overstated quotation and complains to the Pensions Ombudsman

The situationYour team issued a retirement quotation that double counted a period of service. The member resigned in reliance on it. The pension has now been corrected downwards and the member has taken the complaint through the scheme’s dispute procedure to the Pensions Ombudsman, naming the trustees and your firm.

The riskTreating it as a service complaint rather than a claim. The Ombudsman’s determinations are binding, and some wordings give ombudsman awards a separate, lower limit for the whole year. A goodwill payment offered without insurers’ consent can prejudice cover for the larger loss of income claim.

Our strategy

  1. Notify at the first dispute stage letter. A complaint about your work that cannot be resolved at once is usually a notifiable circumstance.
  2. Check how the policy treats ombudsman awards: whether there is a sub-limit, whether it is aggregate, and whether the cost of responding is covered.
  3. Agree any offer with insurers first. The Ombudsman’s published scale for distress runs from £500 to £2,000, more in exceptional cases, separate from financial loss.
  4. Prepare the response with insurers’ lawyers: what the quotation said, its caveats, and whether the member would have retired anyway.
  5. Check the administration agreement for any indemnity to the trustees, who are also respondents and may look to you for their costs.

What we aim forThe complaint answered once, on evidence, with insurers’ consent to any payment and the trustees’ position dealt with at the same time.

The lessonA member’s complaint is a circumstance from the first letter, not from the Ombudsman’s decision.

A buyer says it relied on your valuation of the target’s pension deficit

The situationYou prepared a funding valuation for the trustees of a company’s scheme. Eighteen months later the company is sold. The buyer’s solicitors say the deficit was understated by £4 million, that the valuation was in the data room and that the buyer priced the deal on it.

The riskReplying to the buyer to explain the figures, or ignoring the letter because the buyer was never a client. Either can damage the strongest point you have. Your liability cap sits in the contract with the trustees and does not bind a stranger to it.

Our strategy

  1. Notify insurers and make no reply or admission.
  2. Gather the engagement terms, the report’s statements on purpose and reliance, any release or reliance letter, and every contact your team had with the company or the buyer.
  3. Have insurers’ solicitors take the duty point first: did you know the buyer would rely on this report for this deal, and did you assume responsibility to it?
  4. Only then examine the assumptions and data against the Technical Actuarial Standards in force when the report was signed.

What we aim forThe claim challenged on duty at the outset, before anyone argues about discount rates and mortality.

The lessonRequests to release a report to a buyer, lender or sponsor should come to us before you agree.

A peer review finds an error in a valuation you have already signed

The situationThree months before renewal, a review of a signed valuation finds the wrong pensionable salary definition was used. Technical provisions are understated and the agreed contributions are too low. The trustees do not know. Another insurer has offered terms for next year.

The riskA real tension. The Actuaries’ Code expects you to be open with the trustees, the policy says make no admission without consent, and you may also have a duty to report to the Pensions Regulator. Disclosing only on the new insurer’s proposal form can leave the matter between two policies.

Our strategy

  1. Notify the current insurer first, as a circumstance, with the scheme, the valuation date, the error and a first estimate of the contribution shortfall.
  2. Agree with insurers, the same week, what the trustees are told. Telling a client the facts is not the same as admitting liability, and insurers understand professional duties.
  3. Consider with your lawyers whether section 70 of the Pensions Act 2004 requires a report, and tell insurers before it is made.
  4. Disclose the matter to the new insurer as well, so the new policy cannot be challenged for non disclosure.
  5. Offer to rerun the figures only on terms agreed with insurers, so correction is treated as mitigation rather than a concession.

What we aim forThe current policy holds the circumstance, the trustees are told promptly and accurately, and the move to a new insurer is clean.

The lessonTell your insurer first, then your client, and agree the words in between.

A group life policy is not renewed and an employee dies uninsured

The situationYour employee benefits team arranges an employer’s group life cover. At renewal the insurer’s terms went to the wrong contact and cover lapsed. An employee dies six weeks later. The employer faces a lump sum of £600,000 that its scheme rules promise, with no insurer to pay it.

The riskAssuming the firm’s PI covers everything the firm does. A policy written for actuarial or consulting work may exclude arranging or advising on insurance and investments altogether. Regulated work has to be described to insurers and written into the business definition, with limits that meet the FCA or IFoA rule.

Our strategy

  1. Check the business definition and any financial advice or insurance exclusion before anything else. That decides whether this policy responds at all.
  2. Notify at once, on the employer’s first call, with the placing file and the renewal correspondence.
  3. Ask the life insurer, with insurers’ agreement, whether it will reinstate cover or consider the claim. A recovery there may remove most of the loss.
  4. Make no promise to the employer or the family about payment. That is an admission and needs insurers’ consent.
  5. At the next renewal, show regulated income separately and confirm the limits meet the rule that applies to your permissions.

What we aim forThe claim accepted as arising from insured business, the loss reduced through the life insurer if possible, and no admission made.

The lessonIf you arrange insurance or advise on investments, the policy has to say so.

Illustrative scenarios. How any real claim is handled depends on the facts, the policy wording and insurers’ agreement.

Four things actuaries and pension consultants should know about PI

The date of the work and the date of the claim are different

A claim today may concern a valuation signed or a benefit calculated several years ago. PI is written on a claims made basis: the policy in force when the claim is made responds, provided the work falls after the retroactive date and nothing was already notified under an earlier policy.

Claims made cover: the policy in force when the claim is made is the one that responds.

A valid notification of circumstances can connect a later claim to an earlier policy. That is why continuity matters when you change insurers or stop a particular service. How claims made cover works

A liability cap in your terms does not cap your exposure

Most actuarial and administration appointments limit liability, often to a multiple of fees or a fixed sum. Three things sit outside that comfort. A term limiting liability for negligence works only so far as it is reasonable (Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977, section 2). The cap binds the client who signed, not a member, sponsor or buyer who claims separately. And older appointments may carry a different cap, or none. The IFoA expects principals to be able to justify their arrangements, counting contract terms and PII together (IFoA, APS X5). We look at your limit of indemnity against the uncapped position as well as the capped one.

The scheme actuary is a person, not the firm

Trustees must appoint an individual as the scheme’s actuary (Pensions Act 1995, section 47), and scheme actuary is one of the roles in the IFoA’s practising certificates scheme (IFoA, practising certificates). Certificates, statutory reports and the duty to report breaches to the Pensions Regulator attach to that individual. Your policy therefore needs to cover individuals for personal appointments, past and present partners and employees, and the work they signed. When a scheme actuary changes firm, the question of which firm’s policy answers for which valuation should be settled then, not when a claim arrives.

How your limit of indemnity works

Two unrelated covered claims of £750,000 each come to £1.5 million. Under a £1 million limit in the aggregate, the policy pays up to £1 million for the year in total. Under a £1 million limit for each and every claim, each claim has its own £1 million, subject to the policy’s aggregation wording and other terms.

The same two claims under an aggregate limit and an each and every claim limit.

Then check whether defence costs are paid in addition to the limit or use it up, and when the excess applies.

Inside the wording

Twelve clauses that decide actuaries and pension consultants’ claims

Two policies with the same limit can answer the same claim very differently. These are the clauses we read first, what each means for an actuary or pension consultant and what we check.

Professional business and personal appointments

What it doesCover applies to the business described in the schedule and proposal, and may extend to personal appointments that arise from it.

For an actuary or pension consultantA firm described as “actuarial consultants” that also administers schemes, runs pensioner payroll or places group risk needs each activity written in. Scheme actuary appointments are held personally.

What we checkThe definition against every income line, and that individual appointments are expressly included.

Financial advice and insurance exclusion

What it doesGeneral professions wordings can exclude any claim from providing or arranging investment, financial or insurance advice.

For an actuary or pension consultantInvestment consulting, selecting a bulk annuity insurer and arranging group life or income protection can all fall inside such an exclusion unless it is removed or the activity is scheduled.

What we checkWhether the exclusion is present, and that regulated work under your IFoA licence or FCA permissions is expressly covered.

Trustee and officer exclusion

What it doesClaims against you as a trustee, or as a director or officer of a pension fund or company, are commonly excluded.

For an actuary or pension consultantProfessional trustee and sole trustee work, and staff who sit on a client’s trustee board, may need express cover. So may your own staff scheme.

What we checkWhether trustee appointments held in the course of business are written back in, and for whom.

Aggregation

What it doesClaims arising from one originating cause or source are treated as one claim, with one limit.

For an actuary or pension consultantA wrong factor, system setting or template can affect thousands of members across several schemes. Aggregated, that is one excess but also one limit for all of it.

What we checkThe exact words, read with whether the limit is aggregate or any one claim, and tested against your largest client.

Excess

What it doesThe amount you bear before insurers pay. Some wordings apply it to each claimant where a claim is brought by more than one.

For an actuary or pension consultantFor an administrator, an excess applied to each member could exceed the loss itself. Defence costs may or may not carry an excess.

What we checkWhether the excess is per claim or per claimant, any annual cap, and how it applies to systemic errors.

Ombudsman awards

What it doesCover for binding awards by a recognised ombudsman, sometimes subject to a separate limit for the whole policy year.

For an actuary or pension consultantThe Pensions Ombudsman can direct steps to put a member right, and several upheld complaints in a year can exhaust a small aggregate sub-limit.

What we checkThat the Pensions Ombudsman is within the clause, the sub-limit, and cover for the cost of responding.

Notification and circumstances

What it doesYou must notify claims, intended claims and circumstances promptly, with full particulars. Matters known before inception are excluded.

For an actuary or pension consultantA dispute procedure complaint, an error found on peer review, a buy-in true-up notice and a request for a section 37 confirmation can each be a circumstance.

What we checkThe definition of circumstance, the time allowed after expiry, and what insurers may do if notice is late.

Admissions and consent

What it doesYou must not admit liability, make an offer or incur defence costs without insurers’ written consent.

For an actuary or pension consultantYour professional code expects openness with trustees, and you may have a statutory duty to report a breach. Handled in the wrong order, candour can be argued to be an admission.

What we checkHow the condition is worded, and how insurers treat telling a client the facts or making a statutory report.

Contractual liability

What it doesLiability you take on by contract beyond the ordinary duty of skill and care is commonly excluded, including warranties, guarantees and liquidated sums.

For an actuary or pension consultantAdministration agreements with service credits and indemnities, and bulk annuity project terms with data warranties, can create liabilities the policy was never meant to cover.

What we checkAny contractual liability extension, and your standard terms and largest contracts against it.

Rights of recovery

What it doesInsurers take over your rights against others. Cover can be lost where you have agreed to restrict those rights.

For an actuary or pension consultantSoftware houses, printers, tracing agents and payroll bureaux often cap their liability to you at a low figure. Signing that cap can prejudice your own cover.

What we checkSupplier contracts for caps and waivers, and whether insurers have agreed to them.

Cyber and data exclusion

What it doesMany PI wordings exclude loss caused by a cyber act, a system failure or a breach of data protection law.

For an actuary or pension consultantAn administrator holds identity, bank and health data for every member. A claim by trustees after a breach may fall outside PI entirely.

What we checkHow far the exclusion goes, what liability cover remains, and how it meets your cyber policy.

Retroactive date and takeovers

What it doesWork before the retroactive date is excluded. Some wordings also exclude work done after a merger or takeover unless insurers agree.

For an actuary or pension consultantActuarial claims surface years after the valuation. Firms in this sector merge often, and the work of predecessor practices needs a home.

What we checkThat the retroactive date reaches your earliest appointment and that every predecessor entity is named.

The clause guide: how each part of a PI policy works

Law and duties

Statutory roles, standards and who can rely on your work

Statutory roles and standards

  • The scheme actuary. Trustees must appoint an individual, not a firm, as the scheme’s actuary (Pensions Act 1995, section 47). The appointment is personal even though the firm contracts for the fee, so the individual is exposed alongside the firm.
  • Reporting breaches. Professional advisers, and anyone involved in administering or advising a scheme, must report to the Pensions Regulator, as soon as reasonably practicable, a breach of the law likely to be of material significance. Failure without reasonable excuse can attract a civil penalty (Pensions Act 2004, section 70).
  • Technical standards. The FRC’s TAS 100 (version 2.0, from 1 July 2023) applies to all technical actuarial work. TAS 300 (version 2.1, for work completed from 1 November 2025) covers pensions work, including scheme funding, factors and bulk transfers. Work is usually judged against the version then in force.
  • Professional standards. IFoA members are bound by the Actuaries’ Code (revised from 25 September 2025), whose principles include competence and care, speaking up and communication, and by standards such as APS P1 for pensions work and APS X5 on compensation for professional shortcomings (IFoA standards).

Reliance, caps and complaints

  • Who can rely on your work. In Precis v Mercer, actuaries who valued a scheme for their client were held to owe no duty to the company’s buyer, which relied on the report, because they had not assumed responsibility to it. Direct dealings or a reliance letter can change that.
  • Liability caps. A term limiting liability for negligence is effective only so far as it satisfies the requirement of reasonableness (Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977, section 2). It also binds only the party who agreed to it.
  • The Pensions Ombudsman. The Ombudsman’s jurisdiction can extend to those concerned with a scheme’s administration, and determinations are final, binding and enforceable through the county court (Pension Schemes Act 1993, section 146 and section 151). Distress awards usually run from £500 to £2,000 (Ombudsman’s factsheet).
  • What trustees now expect. The Pensions Regulator’s General Code has been in force since 28 March 2024. Its modules cover managing advisers and service providers, record keeping, data monitoring and cyber controls, so trustees test their administrators and advisers against it.

Court decisions behind these points

[2005] EWCA Civ 114

Precis (521) v William M Mercer

Actuaries who valued a scheme for their client owed no duty of care to the company’s buyer, which relied on the report without their involvement.

Read the judgment

[2014] EWCA Civ 996

Mercer v Ballinger

Trustees alleged negligent valuations in 1996, 1999 and 2001 led to contributions that were too low. The appeal turned on limitation and adding later valuations.

Read the judgment

[2016] EWHC 214 (Ch)

Capita ATL Pension Trustees v Sedgwick Financial Services

A claim over scheme changes made without a valid deed, for services from 1993 to 2005. One defendant obtained summary judgment on limitation.

Read the judgment

[2018] EWHC 2839 (Ch)

Lloyds Banking Group Pensions Trustees v Lloyds Bank

The first GMP equalisation judgment: whether and how trustees must adjust benefits so that men and women receive equal benefits.

Read the judgment

[2020] EWHC 3135 (Ch)

Lloyds Banking Group Pensions Trustees v Lloyds Bank (transfers)

For transfers from 1990 to 1997, trustees remain liable where the cash equivalent left out GMP equalisation, and can be ordered to top up.

Read the judgment

[2024] EWCA Civ 843

Virgin Media v NTL Pension Trustees II

A rule alteration to a contracted-out scheme made without the actuary’s written confirmation was void, for future service rights as well as past.

Read the judgment

These decisions explain where a professional’s duty lies. They do not decide whether a particular policy responds.

Specialist work

The work that changes your cover

A short label on a proposal form hides the questions that matter. These are the areas where we ask most, starting with two current issues: retrospective section 37 confirmations and bulk annuity transactions.

Section 37 confirmations: are you being asked to validate old amendments?

In Virgin Media v NTL Pension Trustees the Court of Appeal confirmed that certain rule alterations to contracted-out salary-related schemes were void without the actuary’s written confirmation ([2024] EWCA Civ 843). The Pension Schemes Act 2026, which received Royal Assent on 29 April 2026, now lets trustees ask the current scheme actuary to confirm in writing that it is reasonable to conclude the alteration would not have prevented the scheme from meeting the statutory standard (section 102). The actuary may act on the information available, if sufficient, and may use assumptions. There is no deadline (the Pensions Regulator’s guidance), and the FRC has published guidance for actuaries on a proportionate approach.

For PI purposes we ask how many confirmations you expect to give, for which schemes, on what terms and with what cap, and how the evidence and reasoning are recorded. We also ask whether your firm, or a practice you have acquired, was the scheme actuary when the original alteration was made. A missing confirmation from that time may be a circumstance to notify now.

Bulk annuity transactions: what is your role, and what have you promised?

A buy-in or buy-out turns years of administration data and benefit interpretation into a single price. Errors that sat unnoticed in the records surface in the insurer’s data cleanse and come back as a premium adjustment, often after the trustees thought the matter closed.

  • Your role. Administrator supplying the data, actuary valuing the liabilities, adviser running the insurer selection, or all three.
  • The benefit specification. Who wrote it, who checked it against the rules and deeds, and who signed it off.
  • Data. What cleansing was done before the transaction, what the trustees were told about the gaps, and whether residual risk cover was discussed.
  • Your terms. Any warranty about data, any indemnity, and whether your usual cap applies to project work.
  • Size. The largest transaction in the year against your limit of indemnity. The fee is small beside the premium.

The FRC’s TAS 300 has its own section on bulk transfers. Advising on a particular insurer’s policy may also be regulated work, which is covered further down this list.

GMP equalisation and conversion

Since the first Lloyds Banking Group judgment in 2018, schemes have been recalculating benefits to remove the unequal effect of guaranteed minimum pensions ([2018] EWHC 2839 (Ch)). A second judgment held that trustees remain liable for certain past transfers out where the cash equivalent left out the equalisation increase ([2020] EWHC 3135 (Ch)). The work combines legal interpretation, actuarial method and bulk recalculation of individual records, sometimes from data decades old. We ask which method each scheme chose, who advised on it, who ran the calculations, how they were checked, and whether the same template was used across clients. That last answer matters for aggregation.

Scheme funding advice under the new regime

Valuations with effective dates on and after 22 September 2024 fall under the Pensions Regulator’s new defined benefit funding code, in force since 12 November 2024 (TPR, funding defined benefits). The code deals with the funding and investment strategy and the statement of strategy that now accompany the valuation, and TAS 300 version 2.1 uses the same date. The Pension Schemes Act 2026 also contains new powers to pay surplus to employers (Part 1, Chapter 2). Advice on prudence, covenant and long term targets, and in time on releasing surplus, carries far larger numbers than the fee suggests. We ask about your largest schemes by liabilities, your review process and how advice to trustees is kept separate from advice to sponsors.

Transfer values, factors and member options

Trustees decide the basis for cash equivalent transfer values, but must take advice from their actuary on the assumptions. They may reduce transfer values for underfunding only after an insufficiency report from the actuary (TPR, transfer values). TAS 300 also covers advice on commutation and other factors, including how often they are reviewed. Claims come from both ends: an out of date factor applied to hundreds of members, or a single quotation calculated wrongly on which a member acted. We ask how factors are reviewed, how the administration system applies them, what checks a transfer payment passes through, including pension scam checks, and how many transfers you process a year.

Pensions administration: records, payroll and dashboards

Administration is high volume work, and most errors are small until they repeat. We ask how many schemes and members you administer, the annual value of pensioner payroll, which platform you use and whether you own it, how new schemes are loaded and checked, and how you log and correct errors. The statutory deadline for schemes in scope to connect to pensions dashboards was 31 October 2026 (DWP guidance), which puts member data, and its accuracy, in front of members directly. Insurers will want to know how matching and data quality are handled, and what your administration agreements say about service levels, indemnities and caps.

Investment consulting, group risk and other regulated work

The IFoA describes three routes by which an actuarial firm can carry on regulated activities: a Designated Professional Body licence, for a limited range of work incidental to its professional services; FCA authorisation, or acting as an appointed representative; or FCA authorisation as an authorised professional firm with an IFoA licence (IFoA DPB Handbook). Each has its own PII rule, shown in the checker above. A DPB firm may not generally advise individuals on a particular investment, and must tell clients it is not FCA authorised. We ask which regulated activities you carry on, for whom, under which route, and what share of income they produce. Then we check that the policy’s business definition includes them and that no financial advice or insurance exclusion takes them back out.

Professional trusteeship and personal appointments

Sitting as a professional trustee, or acting as sole corporate trustee, is a different risk from advising trustees: the decisions are yours. General PI wordings often exclude claims against the insured as trustee of a pension fund, so the work needs express cover, and the scheme’s own trustee liability insurance and indemnities should be read alongside it. The same care applies where a partner or employee joins a client’s trustee board, acts as secretary to trustees, or gives expert evidence in legal proceedings. Tell us about every appointment held by an individual because of their position in the firm.

Work for sponsors, transactions and reliance letters

Advice to employers on accounting figures, benefit changes and scheme liabilities in a sale or purchase supports decisions far larger than the fee. Reports written for trustees also find their way into data rooms. In Precis v Mercer the buyer’s claim failed because the actuaries had not assumed responsibility to it ([2005] EWCA Civ 114), but a reliance letter, a release agreement or direct dealings with the buyer can create the duty the court did not find. We ask what corporate work you do, the size of the transactions, whether you ever act for both trustees and sponsor, and what you sign when a third party asks to see your work.

Your presentation

A proposal should explain the work behind the numbers

An unexplained label can make a modest exposure look broader than it is, while a vague one can hide an important responsibility. Here is how we turn brief answers into a picture insurers can underwrite properly.

Brief proposal answers and what we send instead
What insurers often seeWhat we send instead
“Actuarial and pensions consultancy.”Fees split across scheme actuary work, corporate advice, transactions, administration, investment consulting and employee benefits, with the largest client in each.
“We administer about 40 schemes.”Member numbers, annual payroll value, the platform, how new schemes are loaded, the checking process and the error log.
“Liability is capped in our terms.”Cap levels by type of work, clients on older or uncapped terms, and any reliance letters or warranties given.
“No regulated activities.”Whether you hold an IFoA licence or FCA permissions, what regulated work you do under them and the income from it.
“Some de-risking work.”Each bulk annuity project, its size, your role, who prepared the benefit specification and the terms you signed.
“No claims.”Ombudsman and dispute procedure complaints, errors corrected at your own cost, and matters raised with insurers, with their status.

Illustrations of common answers, not statements about particular clients.

How we handle your renewal

  1. You send what you haveSchedule, wording, endorsements, last proposal and your renewal date.
  2. We find what needs explainingScheme sizes, administration volumes, transaction work, liability caps, regulated activities and predecessor firms.
  3. We approach suited insurersFrom more than 30 insurers, specialist agencies and Lloyd’s, chosen for the work you do.
  4. We compare the wordingsCover, clauses, excess and limits side by side, with the differences explained.

Firm changes

When your firm changes, the insurance needs reviewing

Merging or acquiring a practice

Decide before completion whose policy answers for the acquired firm’s past valuations and records. Name predecessor entities, carry their retroactive dates across and tell insurers before the deal, not after.

A scheme actuary leaves

Appointments are personal. Agree which firm’s policy covers the valuations already signed, and make sure the leaver stays covered as a former partner or employee.

Taking on a scheme

A new administration client brings inherited data and practices. Record what you checked on transfer and what you were told, and agree who is responsible for historic errors.

Starting regulated work

An IFoA licence or FCA permission brings its own PII rule. Tell us before you start, so the business definition and limits change on the same day.

Changing insurer

Notify the outgoing insurer of everything you already know about, disclose it to the new one, and keep the retroactive date unchanged.

Closing or retiring

Claims over valuations and benefit errors can arrive many years later. IFoA licensed firms must keep run off for at least two years, which is a floor, not a plan.

Run off cover explained

How long should run off last for an actuarial or pensions firm?

Longer than any minimum suggests. The IFoA requires its licensed firms to keep cover for at least two years after they stop (DPB Handbook). But in Mercer v Ballinger trustees sued over valuations signed in 1996, 1999 and 2001, and in Capita ATL v Sedgwick the court was dealing in 2016 with services that began in 1993. Errors in valuations, deeds and member records tend to surface at the next major event: a buy-out, a merger or a new administrator. We would plan run off around how long your work can stay undiscovered. Run off cover explained

Alongside your PI

Cyber and crime cover to consider alongside your PI

PI answers claims about your professional work. It is not built to restore a locked administration platform or replace money paid to a fraudster. Firms that hold member data for whole schemes and operate pension payments are obvious targets, so we recommend considering cyber and crime cover alongside PI.

Which policy responds?

Tap a situation for the explanation. A general guide only: the answer always depends on the actual wordings.

SituationPICyberCrime
Ransomware locks your administration platform days before the pensioner payrollNot built for itBuilt for itNot built for it

Incident response, forensic and legal help, system restoration and your own lost income are cyber covers. If pensions are paid late and trustees claim, that liability may come back to PI, depending on any cyber exclusion in it.

Member records for several client schemes are copied and publishedMay respondBuilt for itNot built for it

Cyber cover is built for the breach response, notification and regulatory defence. Trustees’ claims for their own costs may fall to PI or to cyber, depending on the wordings and on any data exclusion in the PI policy.

A fraudster impersonates a member and redirects a pension or transfer paymentMay respondMay respondMay respond

The member or the trustees may claim that your checks were negligent, which is a PI question. Whether cyber or crime cover responds depends on how the instruction arrived and whose money moved. The three policies have to be read together.

An employee diverts payments from a scheme bank account you operateMay respondNot built for itBuilt for it

Crime cover is built for employee dishonesty, including money you hold or control for others if the wording says so. PI dishonesty clauses deal with your liability to the trustees and never protect the dishonest person.

A fake email from a “trustee chair” instructs an urgent paymentMay respondMay respondBuilt for it

Social engineering cover usually sits in crime policies, and in some cyber policies, often with a lower limit and a call back condition. The trustees’ claim against you for paying away scheme money is a PI matter.

Built for itMay respondNot built for it

Cyber cover explained: response, recovery and liability
  • Incident response. Forensic investigators, lawyers and notification support from the first call.
  • Restoration and interruption. Rebuilding systems and data, and income lost while you cannot work.
  • Liability and regulators. Claims over personal data and the cost of regulatory investigations.

The ICO’s £14 million penalty against Capita in October 2025 followed a 2023 attack affecting 6.6 million people and 325 organisations that provide pension schemes (ICO). The Pensions Regulator’s General Code now includes a cyber controls module, so trustees ask their administrators detailed questions. Many PI wordings exclude cyber events and data protection breaches, so the two policies need reading side by side.

Crime cover explained: dishonesty, impersonation and whose money
  • Employee dishonesty. Theft by your own staff, including from accounts you operate for trustees.
  • Third party crime. Fraudulent transfers by outsiders who gain access to banking.
  • Social engineering. Staff tricked into making a payment, often with a lower limit and conditions about verifying changed bank details.
  • Whose money. Policies differ on scheme money in trustee accounts that you can instruct. This is the first thing to check.

Crime cover pays your own loss. A claim by trustees that you were negligent in letting it happen remains a PI question. Other covers we arrange

The other covers we arrange

Proposal form

Prefer to fill in a form?

Ask us for the appropriate proposal form, or send us your details when you request a quote.

Beyond the policy

Claims support and contract reviews

If you receive a complaint or become aware of something that could lead to a claim, email [email protected], or call 0333 222 4257 if it is urgent or sensitive. We report the matter, follow up with the insurer and explain updates. If a deadline is near, follow the notification instructions in your policy immediately. Do not admit liability before speaking to us.

Before you sign, send us the trustee engagement terms, administration agreement, bulk annuity project terms, reliance letter or liability cap you have been asked to accept, with a short note of the work and the scheme’s size. Highlight the wording that concerns you. We can flag insurance points to discuss with you and, where needed, your insurer. Your solicitor can advise on the legal effect. A review cannot guarantee cover for a claim.

Claims support  ·  Contract reviews

Review your cover

Let a specialist read your PI cover

Send us your current schedules, wordings, endorsements and renewal information. Tell us about your scheme actuary appointments, administration, transaction and regulated work, and anything that needs explaining. We will tell you where the cover fits your firm, where it does not, and what we would change.

Speak to a PI specialistSend us your renewalGet a quote

  • Your schedule, policy wording and endorsements
  • Renewal date and your last proposal form
  • Fee split by type of work, and your largest schemes
  • Standard terms and liability caps, with any exceptions
  • Any IFoA licence or FCA permissions, and the work done under them
  • Complaints, errors and matters notified, with their status