We would like to set optional cookies to understand how the site is used. Essential cookies keep forms working. Cookie policy.

Home / Insights / Sole trader or limited company

Insights

Sole trader or limited company: what it means for your professional liability

How you trade decides who a claim is made against, what is at risk if it succeeds, and what your PI needs to cover. Here is what a limited company protects, where that protection stops, and why closing a company does not make a claim go away.

General information, not legal, tax or accounting advice. Your accountant or solicitor can advise on your own circumstances.

In short

As a sole trader or in a partnership, you are the business. A successful claim against the business is a claim against you, and your personal assets, including your home and savings, can be used to pay it.

A limited company or LLP is a separate legal person. Claims are normally made against the company, and what the company owns is what is at risk. Your personal assets are usually protected.

The protection has limits. Individuals can still be sued personally in some situations, and closing the company does not end its liabilities.

PI matters either way. How you trade changes who needs to be insured and how the cover is set up, and it can change the premium.

How the main ways of trading compare
Sole traderPartnershipLimited companyLLP
Who a claim is made againstYouThe partnersThe companyThe LLP
Personal assets at riskYesYes, each partner can be liable for the whole debtUsually not, with the exceptions belowUsually not, with the exceptions below
Public filingNone at Companies HouseNone at Companies HouseAccounts and a confirmation statement each yearAccounts and a confirmation statement each year
If the business closesLiability stays with youLiability stays with the partnersThe company can be restored and claims can reach its insurerThe LLP can be restored and claims can reach its insurer

Trading as yourself: sole traders and partnerships

A sole trader and their business are legally the same person. Contracts are in your name, and so is any liability. If a client's claim succeeds and it is more than your PI pays, or your PI does not respond, the balance is your personal debt. Your savings, your share of your home and other assets can be used to meet it, and an unpaid judgment can lead to bankruptcy.

In an ordinary partnership the position is wider. Each partner can be liable for the whole of the firm's debts, including a claim caused by another partner's work.

Liability also outlives the business. Stopping work, retiring or selling the practice does not end your responsibility for work you have already done. A claim can arrive years later, which is why run-off cover matters (see Professional indemnity explained).

How a limited company or LLP helps

A limited company is a separate legal person from the people who own and run it. It enters into the contracts, it owes the duties under them, and a claim is normally brought against it. If the company cannot pay, shareholders generally lose what they put in, not their personal assets. An LLP works in a similar way for its members.

That gives a real layer of protection between a professional mistake and your family's finances. It also makes the position clearer for clients and insurers: the company is the party providing the service, and the company holds the PI policy.

Where the protection stops

A company does not make the people in it untouchable. The main exceptions are:

  • Personal responsibility for advice. A director is not normally liable for the company's negligent advice. The House of Lords confirmed this in Williams v Natural Life Health Foods (1998), but said a director can be liable if they personally take on responsibility to the client and the client relies on them personally.
  • Employees and individual professionals. In Merrett v Babb (2001) a surveyor employed by a firm was held personally liable for a mortgage valuation. His employer had become bankrupt and the firm's PI had been cancelled without run-off, so the claimant pursued him instead. It shows what can happen when the business's insurance is not there.
  • Documents you sign in your own name. Personal guarantees, and appointments, warranties or letters of reliance given by you rather than the company, can make you personally liable. Make sure contracts, reports and letters are issued in the company's full name with its company number.
  • How the company is run. Directors have legal duties. Carrying on trading when the company cannot pay its debts, or acting dishonestly, can lead to personal liability and disqualification.
  • Your professional body. Regulators such as ARB and RICS regulate individuals as well as firms, and their PI rules apply however you trade.

Myth: "I can close the company and the claim goes away"

You can close a company, but that does not end its liabilities, and there are routes back to it.

  • The company can be restored. A dissolved company can be put back on the register. A former director or member can apply to Companies House within six years. Anyone with an interest, including someone with a potential claim against the company, can apply to the court, normally within six years of dissolution and at any time for a personal injury claim. Once restored, the company can be sued as if it had never been dissolved.
  • The claimant can go straight to the insurer. Since 1 August 2016, the Third Parties (Rights against Insurers) Act 2010 has let a claimant bring proceedings directly against the insurer of a dissolved or insolvent company, without restoring it first.
  • The question is whether there is cover to claim on. PI is written on a claims made basis: the policy that responds is the one in force when the claim is made, not when the work was done. Close the company and stop the PI, and a later claim may find no policy at all. That is when claimants look for someone else to pursue, as in Merrett v Babb.
  • Known problems must be dealt with first. If you are aware of a complaint or circumstance that could become a claim, notify it to your insurer before the policy ends. Closing a company to avoid a known claim can be challenged and can lead to director disqualification.

The safer way to close a practice is to arrange run-off cover for the years in which claims can still be made, and to check your professional body's requirements on how long that should be.

How it changes your PI

The way you trade changes how your PI is set up, and it can change what it costs. Insurers look at:

  • Who is insured. A company policy should cover the company, its directors and its employees for their work for the company. Check that former directors, employees and consultants are included.
  • Your previous business. When a sole trader or partnership becomes a company, work done before the change still carries liability. Either the new company's policy covers the previous business (often called predecessors in business), or the old business needs its own run-off. Do not assume it happens automatically.
  • The size and shape of the business. Turnover, the work you do, your claims history and the people involved are all priced, and insurers rate a company, a partnership and a sole trader differently.

Changing how you trade part way through a policy year should be disclosed to your insurer. Tell us before you incorporate and we will make sure the cover follows the change.

The trade-off: paperwork and cost

A company brings more administration than trading as yourself:

  • Annual accounts and a confirmation statement filed at Companies House, on time, with penalties for late filing.
  • A corporation tax return, and usually an accountant's fees.
  • Directors' legal duties, and details of the company and its directors on the public register.
  • Identity verification for directors with Companies House, and keeping the company's records up to date.

For many professional firms the protection of personal assets is worth that extra work. Your accountant can set out the tax side, which often changes the comparison too.

Checklist

  1. Issue every contract, report and invoice in the company's full name with its company number.
  2. Avoid personal guarantees and personal warranties. If a client asks for one, talk to us first.
  3. Check your PI covers the company, its directors, employees and any previous business.
  4. Tell us before you incorporate, merge, take on a practice or close down.
  5. Notify any complaint or circumstance to your insurer straight away, and always before a policy ends.
  6. Plan run-off before closing a practice or retiring.

Not sure what applies to you?

Tell us how you trade now and what you are planning. We will check that your PI follows it.

Get a quoteTalk to us

Related: Professional indemnity explained · Construction PI claims and limitation · All insights