We would like to set optional cookies to understand how the site is used. Essential cookies keep forms working. Cookie policy.

Home / Insights / Section 37 confirmations under the Pension Schemes Act 2026: the PI questions

Insights for actuaries and pension consultants

Section 37 confirmations under the Pension Schemes Act 2026: the PI questions

Since April 2026 trustees can ask their current scheme actuary to confirm old rule changes that lack a section 37 confirmation. The request looks routine. For PI purposes it raises two separate exposures, one new and one old.

Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.

What the 2026 Act lets trustees ask

From 6 April 1997 to 5 April 2016, certain rule alterations to salary-related contracted-out schemes needed the actuary’s written confirmation before they were made. In Virgin Media v NTL Pension Trustees II the Court of Appeal confirmed that an alteration made without it was void ([2024] EWCA Civ 843). Some schemes cannot find a confirmation for every deed.

The Pension Schemes Act 2026 received Royal Assent on 29 April 2026. Under section 102, trustees may ask the scheme actuary in writing to consider whether the alteration would have prevented the scheme from meeting the statutory standard. If the actuary confirms in writing that it is reasonable to conclude it would not, the alteration is treated as always having met the requirement. The actuary may act on the information available, if it is sufficient, and may use assumptions. There is no deadline (the Pensions Regulator’s guidance).

Some alterations are outside the process, including those a court has already ruled on and those the trustees have told members in writing they treat as void (section 101).

Who gives the confirmation, and to what standard

The “scheme actuary” is the individual appointed under section 47 of the Pensions Act 1995. If the scheme has none, the trustees may appoint a Fellow of the Institute and Faculty of Actuaries for the purpose (section 101). Either way a named individual gives the opinion, about a deed that may be more than 25 years old.

The FRC published guidance for actuaries on 22 May 2026. It is not mandatory. It treats the work as technical actuarial work under TAS 100 and encourages a proportionate approach: the actuary need not recreate the original actuary’s position, hold the full data from the time or be certain of the outcome. Indirect evidence can be used, such as later certificates, valuation reports, trustee minutes and legal advice. The actuary can also decline. Where it is not reasonable to reach the conclusion, the guidance expects the actuary to tell the trustees, and to say what further information might help. Its ethics section, provided by the IFoA, says the decision must be free from bias and undue pressure.

Two exposures in one request

PI exposures arising from a request for a section 102 confirmation
ExposureWhere it comes fromThe PI question
The new opinionYou confirm and the confirmation is later challenged, or you decline and a transaction stalls.Is the work on your current terms and cap, with the basis for the conclusion recorded?
The old gapYour firm, or one you have since acquired, was scheme actuary when the alteration was made, and the original confirmation cannot be found.Does the retroactive date reach that year, is the predecessor named, and has the gap been notified?
VolumeThe same method is applied to many schemes in a short period.How would related claims be grouped, and is the limit enough for them together?

The second row is the one firms miss. A request to confirm an old amendment tells you that a document your firm should have produced may be missing. That can be a circumstance to notify under your current policy, whether or not you go on to give the new confirmation.

The instruction and your terms

The Pensions Regulator’s guidance says trustees should give a formal written instruction that specifies the alterations in scope and whether the actuary may consider the combined effect of alterations made together, for example in one deed. From a PI point of view we would want the engagement to say more.

  • Scope. The statutory question only, for the alterations listed. Whether an alteration falls within the Act is a legal question, on which the FRC guidance suggests the trustees take legal advice.
  • Reliance. The Regulator expects trustees to give the employer copies of confirmations, and a buy-out insurer may ask to see them. Say who may rely on the confirmation, and on what terms.
  • Cap. Confirm that your current liability cap applies to this work. A cap is effective only so far as it is reasonable (Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977, section 2).
  • Information. List what you were given, what you asked for and what you did not receive.
  • Conflict. If your firm held the appointment when the alteration was made, record how that was considered.

How the policy may treat it

The new opinion will usually fall within an actuarial firm’s business description. The points to check lie elsewhere. A Fellow appointed only for this purpose holds a personal appointment, which the policy should expressly include. The admissions condition matters if trustees ask your firm to do the work without charge because the original confirmation is missing: agreeing can look like a concession. And if you change insurer at renewal, a gap that was known but not notified may fall between two policies.

Records count too. The Regulator tells trustees to suspend document destruction where remediation is delayed. We would do the same for the firm’s own files from the period.

What to do when the request arrives

  1. Check whether your firm, or any predecessor practice, was scheme actuary at the date of the alteration. If it was, call us before you reply.
  2. Notify insurers of any missing original confirmation as a circumstance, naming the scheme, the deed and the possible cost.
  3. Take the instruction in writing, on your current terms, limited as set out above.
  4. Follow the FRC guidance and record the information relied on, the assumptions made and why the conclusion is reasonable. If the evidence is insufficient, say so.
  5. Do not let a transaction timetable set the standard of evidence.
  6. Tell us how many confirmations you expect to give this year, so insurers hear it from you at renewal.

How we support claims

Asked for a section 37 confirmation?

Send us the request and your terms before you reply, and we will flag the insurance points on both the new opinion and the old file.

Speak to a PI specialistPI for actuaries and pension consultants

Related: PI for actuaries and pension consultants · Contract reviews · Claims support