Home / Insights / The valuation claim: how trustees sue an actuary, and what PI does
Insights for actuaries and pension consultants
The valuation claim: how trustees sue an actuary, and what PI does
Valuation claims rarely arrive when the report is signed. They surface years later, when a new actuary, a buy-out or an insolvent employer exposes the gap. This is how they are argued, and what your PI does with each part.
Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.
How a valuation claim starts
A funding valuation tells trustees what the scheme’s liabilities are and supports the contributions they agree with the employer. If the liabilities were understated, the contributions were too low, and nobody notices while the employer is healthy. The error tends to come out at the next event: a new scheme actuary reworks the figures, a buy-out insurer prices the benefits from the deeds, or the employer fails and the deficit becomes real.
Mercer v Ballinger shows the pattern. Trustees alleged that valuations in 1996, 1999 and 2001 understated the liabilities, so they asked the employer for less than they should have. The employer went into liquidation in 2010, the claim form was issued in 2012, and the trustees claimed lost contributions of the order of £14 to £15 million ([2014] EWCA Civ 996).
What the error usually is
Principals often expect a claim to attack judgement: the discount rate or the mortality table. Many attack something simpler. The four errors alleged in Ballinger were all about the benefits being valued: the rate at which deferred pensions were revalued, increases on guaranteed minimum pensions in payment, an accrual rate applied to every member when it applied only to some, and no allowance for promotional pay rises.
- Benefits. The valuation did not follow the deeds and rules, or an amendment was missed.
- Data. Membership data was wrong, incomplete or unchecked, and the report did not say so.
- Assumptions. An assumption was outside what a reasonable actuary would have advised at the time, or was not explained.
- Communication. The report did not make clear its uncertainty, or what it could and could not be used for.
The work is usually judged against the standards in force when it was signed. The FRC’s TAS 100 version 2.0 has applied to technical actuarial work since 1 July 2023, and an earlier version covered work from 1 July 2017 (FRC, TAS 100).
How the claim is argued, stage by stage
| Stage | The question | What usually decides it |
|---|---|---|
| Breach | Did the work fall below the standard of a reasonably competent actuary at the time? | Expert evidence, the standards then in force and your file. |
| Causation | What would the trustees and the employer have done with the right figure? | Whether higher contributions would have been asked for, agreed and affordable. |
| Loss | What has the scheme actually lost? | The benefits were always due under the rules. The loss is usually the money that was not collected and cannot now be collected. |
| Limitation | Is the claim in time? | For negligence, six years from when the cause of action arose or, if later, three years from when the claimant had the knowledge needed to sue, with an overriding limit of 15 years from the negligent act (Limitation Act 1980, section 14A and section 14B). |
| Cap and claimant | Who is claiming, and on what terms? | A cap binds the client who agreed it, and only so far as it is reasonable (Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977, section 2). A buyer or sponsor who relied on the report raises a different argument. |
Under section 14A, knowledge includes what the claimant could reasonably have learned with expert advice. In Ballinger the Court of Appeal described each valuation as “an independent and freestanding exercise” when it refused to let claims about the 2002 valuations be added.
What the policy does with each part
PI is written on a claims made basis. The policy that responds is the one in force when the claim is made or the circumstance is notified, not the one you held when the valuation was signed. Four parts of the wording matter most.
- Retroactive date and predecessors. Cover must reach back to the oldest valuation that could be challenged, and name any practice you have merged with or acquired.
- The individual. The scheme actuary is appointed personally (Pensions Act 1995, section 47), so the policy should cover present and former partners and employees for the reports they signed.
- Defence costs. Valuation claims are fought with expert actuarial evidence and can run for years. Check whether costs are paid in addition to the limit or within it.
- Related claims. Three valuations repeating one error may be treated as one claim with one limit, or as three, depending on the aggregation words. The clause guide
When an error comes to light
- Notify insurers as soon as you are aware of a problem: a query from the new actuary, a peer review finding or a trustee’s letter. Do not wait for a letter of claim.
- Give the scheme, the valuation dates, the suspected error and a first estimate. Name every valuation that carried the same error.
- Agree with insurers what the trustees are told. Telling a client the facts is not the same as admitting liability, but the words should be agreed first.
- Consider with your lawyers whether a report to the Pensions Regulator is required (Pensions Act 2004, section 70), and tell insurers before it is made.
- Do not rerun the valuation without charge or offer a fee refund without insurers’ consent.
- Preserve the file: the data received, the checks, the benefit summary, the drafts and the advice given on contributions.
What helps before any claim
The strongest defences are built when the work is done. A report that states its purpose, who may rely on it, the data it was given and the checks made on that data is far easier to defend. So is a file showing that the benefit summary was agreed with the trustees or their lawyers, and that the contribution advice was given with the employer’s position in view.
These controls are worth describing to insurers, who want a clear account of your review process, your largest schemes and your terms. Fair presentation explained
A query on an old valuation?
Call us before you reply, and we will help you notify it properly and agree what the trustees are told.
Speak to a PI specialistPI for actuaries and pension consultants
Related: PI for actuaries and pension consultants · Claims support · Run off cover