Home / Insights / Performance specifications: where your design stops and the contractor’s starts
Insights for building services engineers
Performance specifications: where your design stops and the contractor’s starts
Most building services claims start the same way. A system does not do what the building needs, and your performance specification meets a specialist’s design in the middle. Where your design stopped decides who answers, and how your PI responds.
Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.
Why the gap between two designs produces claims
On many projects you design to a stage, write a performance specification, and a specialist contractor completes the design under a contractor’s design portion. You calculate the loads and set the criteria. The specialist selects the plant, sizes the emitters and writes the controls.
When the classrooms will not reach temperature, the ventilation is too loud or the chiller trips in July, each half blames the other. The contractor says your loads, flow temperatures or criteria were wrong. You say the selection, installation or commissioning was. The owner does not mind which, and claims against whoever it has an appointment or a warranty with. Under design and build that is often the contractor, claiming against you after novation for its own cost of putting the work right.
The four questions these claims come down to
However the letter is worded, four questions decide these claims. Each is answered by a different document.
| Question | What decides it | What you will need |
|---|---|---|
| What did you agree to design? | Your appointment, the scope of services and any design responsibility matrix. Where they are silent, the gap is argued from what people did. | The signed appointment and every schedule to it, including documents it refers to. |
| Was your part done with reasonable skill and care? | Expert evidence on your loads, design criteria and stated assumptions, judged at the time you issued them. | Calculations, the inputs you were given and by whom, and the specification as issued. |
| What did reviewing the contractor’s design commit you to? | The words of the appointment. “Comment”, “review”, “approve” and “check” can be different duties. | Each comment you made, with its date and status, and what you were sent to comment on. |
| Did your error cause the loss? | Whether the system would have worked had your part been right, and what others changed afterwards. | Commissioning records, control system logs and the as installed drawings. |
What the courts have looked at
Three judgments show how judges have approached these questions. Each turned on its own contract and facts.
- Commenting is not authorship. In Lendlease v Aecom the mechanical and electrical consultant on a hospital oncology centre was appointed on terms that included matrices allocating design, coordination and installation design activities. The judge held that a duty of reasonable care and skill applied to the consultant’s comments on other parties’ drawings, judged in the context that someone else had produced them. By commenting, the consultant did not take on an author’s responsibility. The claim was held to be out of time ([2023] EWHC 2620 (TCC)).
- Relying on a specialist can be reasonable. In Cooperative Group v John Allen Associates the judge said professionals do not shed their duties just by obtaining a specialist’s design, but can discharge them by relying on it where that was reasonable. The factors included whether the specialist was an appropriate one, whether anything should have prompted a warning to the client, and whether the client had its own remedy against the specialist ([2010] EWHC 2300 (TCC)).
- Breach is not enough. In 199 Knightsbridge v WSP the engineers should have investigated pressure surge when booster pumps restarted. The claim still failed, because the owner could not prove the precautions would have prevented the flood ([2014] EWHC 43 (TCC)).
What the policy does with each part of the claim
One letter of claim usually contains several different things.
- The allegation that your design was negligent. This is what PI is for. Check whether your wording responds to civil liability or, more narrowly, to negligence only.
- A performance figure you promised. If the appointment says the system “will achieve” a result, the claim may be put as breach of that promise. Many wordings exclude duties more onerous than reasonable skill and care, except where you would have been liable anyway.
- The specialist’s part of the design. If the specialist was your sub-consultant, the client looks to you. Cover usually follows, but it can be reduced where you have agreed terms that limit your right to recover. Freelancers and sub-consultants
- Remedial work you organise yourself. Costs you run up without insurers’ consent are usually not covered, and directing the repair can make you responsible for it.
- The contractor’s delay costs. Liquidated damages passed down to you are usually excluded as such. Loss that flows from a negligent design may be treated differently.
The clause guide explains each of these terms.
What to settle before the project starts
- Put a design responsibility matrix in the appointment, system by system and stage by stage, and make sure the contractor’s documents use the same one.
- Define your review duty. Say what you will look at, for what purpose, and what your comment status codes mean.
- State your design criteria and assumptions in the specification: external conditions, occupancy, hours of use and the loads you were given by others.
- Agree whether you witness, manage or certify commissioning, and what your signature on a certificate means.
- Keep the file. Your comments, and the versions you commented on, are the evidence of where your design stopped.
- Send us any bespoke appointment before you sign. Contract reviews
When the contractor’s letter arrives
The instinct is to reply that the design was the contractor’s, or to go to site and help fix it. Both can harm you. An informal defence can read as an admission, and unapproved help can be treated as accepting responsibility.
Send us the letter first. We would notify insurers, as a claim if blame has been put in writing or as a circumstance if not, and ask for a building services expert to be instructed early. We would also ask insurers to agree in writing what practical help you may give the client in the meantime. Make no agreement that waives or caps your rights against the specialist or the contractor. Claims support
Blamed for a system that does not perform?
Send us the letter and your appointment before you reply, and we will help you notify insurers properly.
Related: PI for building services engineers · Claims support · Freelancers and sub-consultants