We would like to set optional cookies to understand how the site is used. Essential cookies keep forms working. Cookie policy.

Home / Who we cover / M&E engineers (building services)

M&E engineers (building services)

Professional indemnity for M&E engineers (building services)

Building services PI, read clause by clause by specialist brokers. We know where mechanical, electrical and public health claims start: performance specifications, coordination, commissioning, energy and overheating models, and fire safety interfaces. And we know how the wordings treat each one.

Speak to a PI specialistSend us your renewal for reviewGet a quote

  • Since 1990Specialist PI brokers
  • 30+ insurersPlus specialist agencies and Lloyd’s
  • 4.9 out of 5From 228 Google reviews
  • FCA authorisedFRN 302911, independently owned

Your map

The M&E engineers map: from your work to the policy and beyond

Your consultancy’s work on one side, the policy on the other. Select a point to see what it connects to, then follow the link to the part of this page that explains it.

Still 3D render (motion off)

The map, area by area

Each heading below is one area of the map, and the number shows how many points it holds. Open a heading and tap any point: it lights up on the map with everything it connects to, and a short note explains why.

Practice and business risks 12

Your terms and framework agreements 8

Appointments and contracts 7

Legislation 2

Policy documents and schedule 10

Main policy wording 7

Exclusions and restrictions 3

Succession, closure and earlier work 4

Other insurance and final assessment 7

Our experience

Why building services engineers come to a specialist

Two consultancies with the same fee income can carry very different risk. Detailed design or a performance specification, a residential tower or a school boiler replacement, energy and overheating modelling, smoke control, heat networks, commissioning and dutyholder roles each change who relies on you, for how long, and what your policy has to answer.

Hammond PI has specialised in professional indemnity since 1990. We read the wording itself: how each insurer defines your professional business, treats fitness for purpose and performance guarantees, restricts fire safety, groups related claims, and deals with collateral warranties, adjudication and supply or installation. Then we present your consultancy so insurers underwrite the work you actually do.

When a problem arises we stay involved. We help you decide what to notify and when, put the matter to insurers, gather the appointment, drawings and commissioning records they need, and follow it through with the claims handler.

  1. The workDesign, specification, modelling, site inspection and commissioning, by sector and stage, as you really do them
  2. What can go wrongSystems that underperform, coordination gaps, overheating, floods, fire safety defects and claims passed down by contractors
  3. What the policy must answerProfessional business, contractual liability, fire safety terms, aggregation, warranties, adjudication, past work and run off
  4. How we present itA clear submission of sectors, roles, contracts and controls, with wordings compared across insurers

Who requires PI

What your institution asks, and where the figure really comes from

No engineering institution sets a minimum limit. Each asks you to assess your liabilities and insure them properly. The figure itself comes from your appointments, warranties and client frameworks.

PI requirements: Who requires PI
WhoMinimum coverExcessAfter you stopOther conditions
Chartered Institution of Building Services EngineersNo fixed minimum. Members must assess their relevant liabilities and, if appropriate, hold professional indemnity insurance.Not specifiedNot specifiedMembers must tell their clients whether they hold PI cover, and tell them if they cease to hold it.
Institution of Engineering and TechnologyNo fixed minimum. Members must assess all relevant liability for work done by them or under their supervision and, if appropriate, hold professional indemnity insurance.Not specifiedNot specifiedNo approved insurers or minimum wording. The duty covers work done under a member’s supervision as well as their own.
Institution of Mechanical EngineersNo fixed minimum. Members are asked to maintain adequate professional indemnity insurance, through their employer or personally.Not specifiedNot specifiedNo approved insurers or minimum wording. “Adequate” is left to the member and the employer to judge.
Association for Consultancy and Engineering (member firms)No fixed minimum. Member firms shall maintain appropriate professional indemnity insurance arrangements.Not specifiedNot specifiedNo approved insurers or minimum wording stated in the code.
Engineering Council (CEng, IEng and EngTech registrants)No fixed minimum. Its guidance says each institution’s code should oblige members to assess relevant liability and, if appropriate, hold professional indemnity insurance.Not specifiedNot specifiedThe Engineering Council sets the framework. Your own institution’s code is the rule that binds you.

Sources: CIBSE (Code of Professional Conduct in force from 1 January 2025), IET (Rules of Conduct effective from 29 July 2024), IMechE (Code of Conduct as published in November 2026), ACE (Code of Business Practice, last amended December 2021), Engineering Council (Guidance for Institution Codes of Professional Conduct, revision 2017/1). Consultancies answering to more than one must meet each set of rules.

A minimum is not a recommendation. Many consultancies need more, and cover for each and every claim can protect better than an aggregate limit.

Why the minimum is rarely the right limit

There is no minimum to rely on, so the limit is a decision for you and your clients. Appointments and warranties fix a figure project by project, without sight of your whole workload. Size the limit to the largest realistic loss: stripping out and replacing services in an occupied building, moving residents out, or lost use of a hospital or data hall. Then check whether fire safety, pollution or asbestos claims carry a lower aggregate sub-limit.

Claim scenarios

When a claim arrives: how we would handle it

Situations building services engineers face, the risk hidden in each, and the strategy we would follow from the first letter. Choose a scenario.

The heating never reaches temperature and everyone points at your performance specification

The situationYou wrote a performance specification for a school’s heat pump system. The contractor’s specialist completed the design under a contractor’s design portion, and you commented on its drawings. In the first winter the classrooms will not reach temperature. The contractor says your design loads and flow temperatures were wrong.

The riskReplying that the design was the contractor’s, or going to site to help fix it. An informal defence can become an admission, and directing remedial work can make you responsible for it. The real question is where your design stopped, and few appointments say so clearly.

Our strategy

  1. Notify insurers now, as a claim if blame has been put in writing or as a circumstance if not, naming the project, the allegation and the possible cost of replacing plant in an occupied school.
  2. Collect the documents that draw the line: your appointment and scope of services, the design responsibility matrix, the specification, and every comment you made on the contractor’s drawings, with its status.
  3. Ask insurers to instruct a building services expert early to test the loads, emitter sizing and controls, so the first technical answer is right and is not improvised on site.
  4. Agree with insurers, in writing, what help you may give on site, so that seeing the client through the winter is not treated as an admission.
  5. Protect recovery against the specialist and the contractor: make no agreement that waives or caps your rights against them.

What we aim forThe boundary between your specification and the contractor’s design established from the documents, a funded defence, and practical help for the client given with insurers’ consent.

The lessonOn a performance specification, the claim turns on where your design stopped. Keep the matrix and your comments.

Flats overheat in their first summer after your model showed a pass

The situationYou produced the overheating assessment for a scheme of 90 flats using dynamic thermal modelling. In the first summer residents complain of bedrooms above 30 degrees. The developer’s solicitors say your model assumed windows open at night, which the acoustic report had ruled out on the road side.

The riskRunning the model again and sending the developer a revised report. That hands over a document conceding the first one was wrong before insurers have seen it. The second trap is scale: one assumption repeated across 90 flats, where each owner may have rights under the Defective Premises Act.

Our strategy

  1. Notify the whole scheme as one matter, listing every block and flat type that used the same assumption, including those where nobody has complained yet.
  2. Read the aggregation clause against the limit. If 90 flats are one claim, one limit must cover all of them. If they are 90 claims, 90 excesses may apply.
  3. Assemble the modelling file: the inputs, the weather data, the acoustic and planning constraints you were given, your stated assumptions and limitations, and who approved them.
  4. Have insurers’ expert review the model before anything new is issued, and agree any further modelling with insurers as a step to reduce the loss.
  5. Identify who else shaped the result: the glazing design, the acoustic limits and any later change to ventilation, so that contribution from others is preserved.

What we aim forOne coordinated notification, the limit and excess position understood on day one, and a technical response that insurers have approved before it reaches the developer.

The lessonA model is advice. Record the assumptions you were given, and do not reissue it without insurers.

Your appointment promised an energy rating and the finished building misses it

The situationYour appointment for an office refurbishment said the design “will achieve” a stated operational energy rating. After a year in use the building misses it. The tenant’s lease depended on the rating, and your client claims the cost of upgrades and lost rent.

The risk“Will achieve” is a guarantee of a result. Many wordings exclude liability under an express guarantee, or a duty more onerous than reasonable skill and care, except where you would have been liable anyway. Argue the claim as a guarantee and you may argue yourself out of cover.

Our strategy

  1. Notify at once and send insurers the appointment clause in full, with the energy model and the forecast you actually gave.
  2. Ask panel solicitors to frame the defence around negligence: was the forecast prepared with reasonable skill and care, and were its assumptions about hours, loads and controls made clear?
  3. Separate the causes. Occupancy, tenant equipment, control settings and commissioning are often outside the designer’s hands, and each needs evidence from the building’s meters and logs.
  4. Ask insurers to confirm in writing which parts of the claim they accept, so any uninsured guarantee element is known early and can be negotiated on your terms.

What we aim forCover preserved for the negligence allegation, the guarantee element identified early, and a defence built on how the building has actually been run.

The lessonSend us any appointment that says “will achieve”, “ensure” or “guarantee” before you sign it.

A contractor serves a notice of adjudication late on a Friday

The situationYou designed the building services for a design and build contractor on a hotel. The contractor blames late and uncoordinated drawings for rework and delay. It serves a notice of adjudication claiming its costs and the liquidated damages it paid the employer.

The riskTreating it as a commercial dispute and answering it yourself. The Construction Act timetable allows 28 days from referral to decision. Some wordings cover adjudication only if insurers are told within a few working days, and most exclude liquidated damages as such.

Our strategy

  1. Send us the notice the day it arrives. We notify insurers immediately and ask for panel solicitors to be instructed before the referral is served.
  2. Check the adjudication clause in your appointment against the policy condition: who appoints, the timetable, and whether it is more onerous than the statutory Scheme.
  3. Separate the heads of claim: alleged negligent design and coordination, which is what PI is for, and the liquidated damages, which insurers will look at very differently.
  4. Pull the evidence a 28 day process needs: the information release schedule, drawing issue records, requests for information with response times, and who caused each change.
  5. Raise any unpaid fees as a separate matter. Do not set them off or concede anything to settle quickly without insurers’ consent.

What we aim forA funded, properly argued response inside the timetable, and no breach of the policy’s adjudication condition.

The lessonAdjudication moves in days. The first call when a notice arrives should be to us.

A letter about missing fire dampers arrives three weeks before renewal

The situationA developer’s solicitors write about a residential block whose services you designed in 2012. Surveys have found missing fire dampers and unsealed service penetrations in the risers. Your renewal is in three weeks, and the insurer has indicated that a fire safety exclusion will apply from renewal.

The riskLeaving it for the renewal form. A claims made policy answers only what is notified during its period. If this is first reported after the exclusion applies, it may have no home. And the same team used the same riser details on other blocks.

Our strategy

  1. Notify the letter under the current policy now, in full: the project, the allegations, the survey findings and the remedial scheme being discussed.
  2. Notify as circumstances the other blocks where the same details, specification clauses or inspection regime were used, with enough detail for each to be identified.
  3. Find the 2012 file: appointment, specification, damper schedules, site inspection reports and what your duty to inspect actually was. Who installed and who signed off matters as much as the design.
  4. Disclose it all to the renewing insurer as well, so the new policy is not open to challenge, and keep the retroactive date unchanged.
  5. Do not attend a joint inspection or reply to the solicitors until insurers have appointed someone to act.

What we aim forThe claim and the related blocks attached to the policy that has no exclusion, and a renewal presented honestly with the position already protected.

The lessonNotify before the terms change. What you know about must go to the policy you have now.

A riser joint bursts after handover and eight floors of flats flood

The situationSix months after handover a joint on a boosted cold water riser fails overnight and floods eight floors. You designed the system and witnessed commissioning. The building insurer’s loss adjuster asks for your calculations and commissioning records, and the installer blames surge pressure in your design.

The riskHanding over the file with an explanation, or sending engineers to supervise the repair. Both can be read as accepting responsibility. Meanwhile the failed joint, the pump settings and the control system logs, which decide causation, may be lost in the clean up.

Our strategy

  1. Notify insurers the same day. A loss adjuster’s request after a flood is a circumstance even though nobody has claimed against you yet.
  2. Ask for the failed components to be kept and for the pump and control system data to be downloaded before anything is reset, with insurers’ expert present if possible.
  3. Reply to the loss adjuster only through insurers or their solicitors, and give documents on an agreed basis.
  4. Set out three questions separately: was the design adequate, was it installed and commissioned as designed, and would the failure have happened anyway? Each has a different answer and a different party.
  5. Keep your rights against the installer and the commissioning specialist intact, and tell us about any contract term that limits them.

What we aim forEvidence preserved, causation tested by an expert before positions harden, and the loss shared among those responsible.

The lessonAfter a flood, the evidence is in the pipework and the logs. Preserve both before you explain anything.

A freelance modeller’s error sits inside the report you issued

The situationYou subcontract energy compliance modelling to a freelance assessor. Her terms cap liability at her fee and she carries no PI. A wrong input passes your review, the building fails its as built compliance calculation, and the client claims the cost of extra plant and the delay to completion.

The riskThe client claims against you, which is expected. The trap comes next: some wordings exclude or reduce cover where you have agreed terms that restrict your right to recover from someone else. A cap you accepted without reading can become your insurer’s complaint.

Our strategy

  1. Notify the claim and tell insurers at the outset about the sub-consultant, her terms and her lack of cover. Raising it early is far better than having it found.
  2. Show from the renewal file what was disclosed about freelance and subcontracted work, and how it is reviewed before issue.
  3. Evidence your own checking: the review record, the inputs you tested and the sign off. The claim is about your report, and your review is the defence.
  4. Then change the terms for the future: liability that is uncapped or sensibly capped, evidence of PI before each instruction, and a written scope for every package.

What we aim forThe client’s claim handled as an ordinary negligence claim, with the recovery point dealt with openly and early.

The lessonRead a sub-consultant’s terms before the first instruction. A cap on them can cost you cover.

Illustrative scenarios. How any real claim is handled depends on the facts, the policy wording and insurers’ agreement.

Four things building services engineers should know about PI

The date of the work and the date of the claim are different

A claim today may concern a design issued several years ago, long after practical completion. PI is written on a claims made basis: the policy in force when the claim is made responds, provided the work falls after the retroactive date and nothing was already notified under an earlier policy.

Claims made cover: the policy in force when the claim is made is the one that responds.

A valid notification of circumstances can connect a later claim to an earlier policy. That is why continuity matters when you change insurers or stop a particular service. How claims made cover works

No engineering body sets your limit. Your contracts do.

CIBSE requires members to assess their liabilities and, if appropriate, hold PI, and to tell clients whether they hold it and if it ceases (CIBSE, Code of Professional Conduct). The Engineering Council’s guidance asks every institution’s code to require members to assess liability and insure where appropriate (Engineering Council, guidance for codes of conduct). None of them states a figure. The limit, the years you must keep it for and the exclusions you may accept are set by each appointment and warranty. A promise to maintain cover for 12 years is a promise you make. It is not one your insurer has given, so read each insurance clause against what the market will actually provide.

Reasonable skill and care is insurable. A guarantee of the result may not be.

The law implies that a service will be carried out with reasonable care and skill (Supply of Goods and Services Act 1982, section 13). PI is built around that standard. Appointments often go further: the system “shall” achieve a temperature, a rating or an energy figure, or be fit for its purpose. In MT Højgaard v E.ON the Supreme Court enforced a design life requirement even though the contractor had followed the specified standard ([2017] UKSC 59). Whether a claim under words like those is insured depends on the policy wording, so send them to us before you sign.

How your limit of indemnity works

Two unrelated covered claims of £750,000 each come to £1.5 million. Under a £1 million limit in the aggregate, the policy pays up to £1 million for the year in total. Under a £1 million limit for each and every claim, each claim has its own £1 million, subject to the policy’s aggregation wording and other terms.

The same two claims under an aggregate limit and an each and every claim limit.

Then check whether defence costs are paid in addition to the limit or use it up, and when the excess applies.

Inside the wording

Twelve clauses that decide building services engineers’ claims

Two policies with the same limit can answer the same claim very differently. These are the clauses we read first, what each means for a building services engineer and what we check.

Insuring clause and “professional business”

What it doesCovers civil liability, or on narrower wordings negligence only, arising from your professional business as the schedule and proposal describe it.

For a building services engineerPrincipal designer roles, energy assessment, commissioning management, expert reports and digital modelling are only covered if they fall inside that description.

What we checkThe business description against every service you sell, and whether the trigger is civil liability or negligence.

Contractual liability and performance guarantees

What it doesUsually excludes duties more onerous than the law would imply, and express guarantees, unless you would have been liable anyway.

For a building services engineerFitness for purpose, “ensure” obligations, guaranteed energy or temperature figures and wide indemnities can sit outside cover even when the design was careful.

What we checkThe exclusion and what it writes back, read against your standard and bespoke appointments.

Collateral warranties and third party rights

What it doesOften covered only if the warranty gives no greater or longer benefit than your appointment, and never for fitness for purpose or liquidated damages.

For a building services engineerA services design can attract warranties to funders, purchasers, tenants and a contractor after novation, each assignable and each lasting years.

What we checkThe policy’s warranty conditions against the forms you are asked to sign, including assignment and step in rights.

Fire safety and cladding terms

What it doesUsually added by endorsement. They range from a narrow external wall exclusion to an exclusion of all fire safety claims, or a lower aggregate limit.

For a building services engineerSmoke control, dampers, fire stopping of service penetrations, alarms, sprinklers and emergency lighting are everyday building services work. A wide exclusion can remove much of what you do.

What we checkThe exact words: which systems and buildings are caught, whether any cover is written back, and what your appointments require.

Aggregation

What it doesClaims arising from one originating cause or source are treated as one claim, with one limit and one excess.

For a building services engineerA riser detail, a heat interface unit selection or a modelling assumption repeated across hundreds of flats, or several schemes, could be one claim or many.

What we checkThe aggregation words, read with whether the limit is any one claim or in the aggregate.

Notification of claims and circumstances

What it doesCover depends on telling insurers promptly of claims, and of circumstances that may lead to one, within the policy period.

For a building services engineerA defects list naming your design, a client withholding fees after a complaint, a loss adjuster’s enquiry or your own discovery of an error can each be notifiable.

What we checkThe definition of a circumstance, the time limits, and what happens if notice is late.

Adjudication

What it doesSome wordings cover adjudications only if insurers are told within a few working days and the procedure is no more onerous than the statutory Scheme.

For a building services engineerA contractor client can start an adjudication at any time, and the decision is due 28 days after referral.

What we checkThe adjudication condition in the policy against the adjudication clause in your appointments.

Defence costs

What it doesLegal and expert costs of defending a claim, paid with insurers’ consent, either in addition to the limit or inside it.

For a building services engineerServices disputes are expert heavy. Thermal modelling, hydraulic analysis and testing of failed components cost a great deal before liability is even argued.

What we checkWhether costs erode the limit, how they are shared if a claim exceeds it, and whether the excess applies to costs.

Supply, installation and construction

What it doesConsultants’ wordings usually exclude claims arising from supplying goods, or from contracts to install or construct.

For a building services engineerOffering design and install, procuring controls or plant for a client, or carrying out hands on commissioning can move a job outside a consultant’s policy.

What we checkWhether you do any contracting, and whether a design and construct wording is needed for it.

Sub-consultants and rights of recovery

What it doesWork done on your behalf is usually covered, but cover can be lost or reduced where you have agreed to limit your rights against others.

For a building services engineerSpecialist modellers, fire engineers, acousticians and overseas drafting teams often trade on capped terms.

What we checkHow subcontracted work is treated, and the caps and insurance in the terms you accept from them.

Injury, damage, pollution and mould

What it doesInjury and property damage are usually covered only when caused by a professional error. Pollution and asbestos are often sub-limited in the aggregate, and some wordings exclude mould altogether.

For a building services engineerFloods, refrigerant or fuel leaks, plant room refurbishment and ventilation design linked to condensation all touch these terms.

What we checkEach sub-limit, whether it includes costs, and any mould exclusion against your residential work.

Regulatory and criminal defence costs

What it doesSome wordings pay legal costs, up to a sub-limit, to defend proceedings under building regulations or health and safety law arising from your professional work.

For a building services engineerDesigners carry duties under the dutyholder regime and CDM 2015. Fines are usually excluded.

What we checkWhich proceedings are included, the sub-limit, when cover stops, and whether directors are covered personally.

The clause guide: how each part of a PI policy works

Law and duties

The Building Safety Act, CDM and the standard you are held to

Duties the law places on designers

  • Design for compliance. Since 1 October 2023 every designer must take all reasonable steps to ensure that, if built, the work would comply with the Building Regulations, and must report compliance concerns about related design to the principal designer (Building Regulations 2010, regulation 11K).
  • The principal designer role. The principal designer must plan, manage and monitor the design work and coordinate it so the building would comply (Building Regulations 2010, regulation 11M). On services led projects such as plant replacement, clients may ask you to take it on.
  • CDM 2015. Designers must eliminate, reduce or control foreseeable risks to those who build, maintain and clean a structure, so far as reasonably practicable (CDM Regulations 2015, regulation 9). For services that means plant access, replacement routes and safe maintenance.
  • Homes, and for longer. Work for a new dwelling carries a duty that it will be fit for habitation (Defective Premises Act 1972). Claims can be brought for 15 years, or 30 where the right arose before 28 June 2022 (Building Safety Act 2022, section 135).

Performance, commissioning and information

  • Commissioning is a legal step. Fixed building services must be commissioned and a notice confirming it given to building control (Building Regulations 2010, regulation 44). Be clear whether you witnessed, managed or certified commissioning. Each carries a different responsibility.
  • Energy forecasts. For new non-domestic buildings over 1,000 square metres the owner should receive a forecast of actual energy use, including unregulated loads. Compliance outputs are not suitable as forecasts (Approved Document L, volume 2, paragraph 9.4).
  • Overheating. Part O has applied to new residential buildings in England since 15 June 2022, met by a simplified method or by dynamic thermal modelling to CIBSE TM59. The guidance says that following it does not guarantee comfort (Approved Document O).
  • Fire safety information. At completion, information on the building’s fire safety design, services and equipment must be given to the responsible person (Building Regulations 2010, regulation 38). Smoke control, dampers and alarm logic often fall to the services designer to describe.

Court decisions behind these points

[2017] UKSC 59

MT Højgaard v E.ON Climate and Renewables

A contractor that followed the specified standard was still liable, because the contract also required a 20 year design life. Performance requirements are enforced as written.

Read the judgment

[2014] EWHC 43 (TCC)

199 Knightsbridge Development v WSP UK

Engineers should have investigated pressure surge when booster pumps restarted. The claim still failed, because the owner could not prove the precautions would have prevented the flood.

Read the judgment

[2023] EWHC 2620 (TCC)

Lendlease Construction (Europe) v Aecom

A hospital services design claim failed mainly on limitation. Commenting on a contractor’s drawings called for reasonable care, not a check of every item.

Read the judgment

[2012] EWCA Civ 1158

Trebor Bassett v ADT Fire and Security

The designer of a fire suppression system owed a duty of reasonable care and skill, not a guarantee that the system would work.

Read the judgment

[2010] EWHC 2300 (TCC)

Cooperative Group v John Allen Associates

An engineer can discharge its duty by relying on a specialist’s design, but only where relying on it was reasonable in all the circumstances.

Read the judgment

[2025] UKSC 21

URS Corporation v BDW Trading

A developer could recover repair costs it chose to incur, and the 30 year limitation period reaches related negligence and contribution claims against a designer.

Read the judgment

These decisions explain where a professional’s duty lies. They do not decide whether a particular policy responds.

Specialist work

The work that changes your cover

A one line description on a proposal form hides most of what matters. These are the areas where we ask most, starting with the two that are changing building services work now: the dutyholder regime and performance modelling.

Building Safety Act roles and higher-risk buildings: what have you taken on?

Since 1 October 2023 every designer in England has statutory duties of competence and compliance, and a principal designer must be appointed to plan, manage and monitor the design work (Building Regulations 2010, Part 2A). Higher-risk buildings bring more: building control approval from the regulator, controlled changes, a golden thread of information and mandatory occurrence reporting (Higher-Risk Buildings Procedures Regulations 2023).

For insurers the questions are practical:

  • Role. Designer only, lead designer or principal designer, and who in the firm is the designated individual.
  • Buildings. How much of your work is on higher-risk buildings, and at which stage.
  • Change. How a late services change on site is recorded and approved.
  • Fire safety terms. In the Construction Leadership Council’s 2022 survey, 68% of respondents had restrictions on fire safety cover (CIC, survey results).

The High Court can also extend a company’s liability for defective homes, or for fire and structural safety risks, to associated companies (Building Safety Act 2022, section 130). That matters when a group is restructured.

Energy and overheating modelling: a compliance check, a forecast or a promise?

Three different things are often bundled into one fee line. A Part L compliance calculation shows the design meets the regulations. An energy forecast, for example using CIBSE TM54, predicts how the building will perform in use. A contractual target says that it will. Approved Document L itself warns that compliance outputs are not suitable as forecasts.

The 2026 edition of Approved Document L takes effect on 24 March 2027, and on 24 September 2027 for higher-risk building work (GOV.UK, Approved Document L). Overheating assessments under Part O raise the same issue: the result depends on assumptions about windows, shading, noise and occupancy that other people control (GOV.UK, Approved Document O).

We ask what you modelled, with which tool and whose inputs, what the report said about its limits, who relies on it, and whether any appointment turns a prediction into a guarantee. That last point can decide whether a claim is argued as negligence or as breach of a promise.

Performance specification or detailed design: where does your design stop?

On many projects you design to a stage, write a performance specification, and a specialist contractor completes the design under a contractor’s design portion. Claims arise in the gap: plant sized by one party to loads calculated by another, and builders’ work, access and coordination that nobody owned.

We ask whether your appointment has a design responsibility matrix, who coordinates the services with the structure and the architecture, and what “review” or “comment” on a contractor’s drawings commits you to. In Lendlease v Aecom the court treated a duty to comment on a contractor’s drawings as one of reasonable care, not a check of every item ([2023] EWHC 2620 (TCC)). Your appointment may say more than that.

Commissioning, witnessing and handover: what did you sign?

Commissioning is where a design is proved, and where responsibility blurs. The Building Regulations require fixed building services to be commissioned and notice given to building control (Building Regulations 2010, regulation 44). The installer usually commissions, a specialist may manage it, and the consultant witnesses.

We ask what your scope says about witnessing, how many tests you attend, what your signature on a certificate means, and whether you are retained for seasonal commissioning and the first year of operation. Systems that pass on a mild day can fail at design conditions, long after everyone has left site. A clear record of what you saw, and what you did not, is the best evidence you will have.

Smoke control, dampers and fire stopping: whose interface is it?

Building services cross every fire compartment. Ductwork needs dampers, pipes and cables need fire stopping, smoke control has to work with the fire strategy, and the alarm’s cause and effect ties it together. Each interface involves a fire engineer, an architect, a specialist installer and you.

In Lendlease v Aecom the alleged defects included missing compartmentation to a plant room, fire dampers, and fire stopping of ducts and cables ([2023] EWHC 2620 (TCC)). We ask who specifies fire stopping to service penetrations, who inspects it before ceilings close, and who designs smoke control. Then we read any fire safety endorsement against those answers, because a broad one may leave much of this work without cover.

Heat networks and low carbon heat: new rules, less margin

Heat pumps and communal systems are less forgiving than gas boilers: lower flow temperatures, larger emitters, tighter controls and more dependence on how the building is run. Ofgem now regulates heat networks in Great Britain, with regulation being introduced in phases (Ofgem, heat networks). Government is developing technical requirements and a Heat Network Technical Assurance Scheme, and points to CIBSE’s code of practice CP1 (GOV.UK, heat networks technical standards).

Heat loss from distribution pipework is an overheating issue too. Approved Document O says its simplified method is not suitable for blocks with communal heating and significant horizontal pipework (GOV.UK, Approved Document O). We ask about your experience with these systems, the standards you design to, and any efficiency or running cost figure given to a client.

Public health engineering: water, drainage and pressure

Water is where a building services error becomes a property damage claim. A failed joint on a boosted main can flood many floors before anyone reaches the valve. In 199 Knightsbridge v WSP the engineers were held in breach for not investigating pressure surge when booster pumps restarted, though the claim failed on causation ([2014] EWHC 43 (TCC)).

We ask about tall buildings and boosted systems, leak detection and isolation, hot water temperature control and hygiene in healthcare and care settings, rainwater and drainage capacity, and sprinkler or wet riser design. We also check how the wording treats property damage and pollution, and whether any mould exclusion could reach a ventilation or condensation claim.

Sub-consultants, freelancers and overseas modelling teams

Peaks in workload are often met with freelance engineers, specialist modellers and drafting teams abroad. Your client still looks to you. We ask who they are, what they do, how their work is checked before issue, whether they carry PI, and what their terms say about liability, because a cap you accept can affect your own cover. In Cooperative Group v John Allen Associates the court set out when a professional may reasonably rely on a specialist ([2010] EWHC 2300 (TCC)).

Freelancers and sub-consultants

Working for contractors: novation, warranties and adjudication

Under design and build you may start with the employer and finish with the contractor. Novation changes who can claim against you and for what, including the contractor’s own losses. Warranties then go back to the employer, funders and tenants.

We ask to see the novation agreement, the warranty forms and any net contribution clause. In West v Ian Finlay the Court of Appeal upheld a net contribution clause in a consultant’s appointment ([2014] EWCA Civ 316). In Abbey Healthcare v Simply Construct the Supreme Court held that a warranty which merely repeats the building contract promises is not a construction contract with a statutory right to adjudicate ([2024] UKSC 23). The detail of each form matters.

Your presentation

A proposal should explain the work behind the numbers

An unexplained label can make a modest exposure look broader than it is, while a vague one can hide an important responsibility. Here is how we turn brief answers into a picture insurers can underwrite properly.

Brief proposal answers and what we send instead
What insurers often seeWhat we send instead
“Building services design, 100%.”The split by discipline, sector and stage: detailed design, performance specification, modelling, site inspection and commissioning.
“No high-rise residential.”A list of residential and higher-risk building projects by height and date, with your role on each and what you designed.
“No fire safety work.”What you do on smoke control, dampers, fire stopping, alarms and sprinklers, who else is involved and how it is checked.
“We sometimes use sub-consultants.”Who they are, what they do, the share of fees, their PI and terms, and how you review their output.
“Standard appointments only.”The forms you sign, your position on fitness for purpose, caps, net contribution and warranties, and who reviews bespoke terms.
“No claims.”Complaints, defects lists naming your design, threatened adjudications and circumstances notified, with their status and what changed afterwards.

Illustrations of common answers, not statements about particular clients.

How we handle your renewal

  1. You send what you haveSchedule, wording, endorsements, last proposal and your renewal date.
  2. We find what needs explainingSector and stage split, dutyholder roles, fire safety work, modelling, contract terms, sub-consultants and past projects.
  3. We approach suited insurersFrom more than 30 insurers, specialist agencies and Lloyd’s, chosen for the work you do.
  4. We compare the wordingsCover, clauses, excess and limits side by side, with the differences explained.

Consultancy changes

When your consultancy changes, the insurance needs reviewing

Incorporating or restructuring

Make sure the old firm’s projects stay insured and the new entity’s retroactive date reaches back to them. Warranties signed by the old entity do not move by themselves.

Merger or acquisition

Some wordings exclude work done after a takeover unless insurers have agreed. Tell us before completion, and decide who insures each firm’s past projects.

A director leaving

Past directors are usually insured under the firm’s policy for the firm’s work. Check what the leaver takes with them, and any dutyholder role they held as the firm’s designated individual.

Changing insurer

Notify everything you know about to the outgoing insurer first, disclose it to the new one, and carry the retroactive date and any fire safety cover across unchanged.

Adding a new service

Principal designer roles, heat network design, fire engineering or design and install change the risk. Agree them with insurers before the first project starts.

Retirement or closure

Claims can arrive long after you stop. Warranties are often signed as deeds, and Defective Premises Act claims can be brought for 15 or 30 years. Plan run off before you close.

Run off cover explained

What if a fire safety exclusion is proposed at renewal?

Tell us as early as you can. First, anything you already know about should be notified under the current policy before its terms change. Second, we press for the narrowest words the market will give, with evidence of what you actually design and how it is checked. Third, check your contracts: many require you to tell the client if cover cannot be kept on the agreed terms, and CIBSE’s code requires members to tell clients if they cease to hold cover (CIBSE, Code of Professional Conduct).

Fair presentation explained

Alongside your PI

Liability and D&O cover to consider alongside your PI

PI answers claims about your professional work. It is not built for an accident on site that has nothing to do with your design, or for a director pursued personally. Your engineers work in plant rooms and on live sites, and the Building Safety Act has sharpened personal accountability, so we recommend considering these two covers.

Which policy responds?

Tap a situation for the explanation. A general guide only: the answer always depends on the actual wordings.

SituationPIEL and PLD&O
Your engineer is injured in a plant room while witnessing commissioningNot built for itBuilt for itNot built for it

Employers’ liability answers injury to your own staff and is compulsory for most employers. PI wordings usually exclude injury to your own employees.

On a survey your engineer knocks a sprinkler head and floods a client’s officesMay respondBuilt for itNot built for it

Public liability is built for accidental damage and injury caused by your people on someone else’s premises. PI usually covers damage only where it flows from a professional error, such as a negligent design.

A design error causes a flood in the finished buildingBuilt for itNot built for itNot built for it

This is a professional negligence claim, which is what PI is for. Public liability policies usually exclude professional advice and design.

A director is investigated personally after the company is accused of a building regulations offenceMay respondNot built for itBuilt for it

D&O is built to fund a director’s own defence. Some PI wordings give limited defence costs for building regulations or health and safety proceedings arising from professional work, usually under a sub-limit.

A shareholder or liquidator claims against the directors over how the business was runNot built for itNot built for itBuilt for it

PI wordings usually exclude claims against directors for how they managed the company. D&O exists for them.

Built for itMay respondNot built for it

Employers’ and public liability explained

Employers’ liability insurance is a legal requirement for most employers, with cover of at least £5 million (GOV.UK, employers’ liability insurance). Public liability is not compulsory, but most appointments and site rules ask for it.

  • Where the line falls. Injury or damage caused by a design or advice error belongs with PI. Injury or damage caused by what your people physically do on site belongs with public liability.
  • The gap to avoid. PI that covers injury and damage only when professional, beside public liability that excludes professional services, means the two wordings need reading together.
D&O explained

Directors’ and officers’ cover protects individuals. It does not insure the company’s professional work. Under the Building Act 1984, where a company commits an offence with a director’s consent or connivance, or through their neglect, the director commits it too (Building Safety Act 2022, section 40).

  • What it is for. Defence costs and personal liability arising from investigations, prosecutions and claims by shareholders, creditors or liquidators.
  • What it is not. A substitute for PI. Claims about design and advice stay with the PI policy.

The other covers we arrange

The other covers we arrange

Proposal form

Prefer to fill in a form?

Ask us for the appropriate proposal form, or send us your details when you request a quote.

Beyond the policy

Claims support and contract reviews

If you receive a complaint or become aware of something that could lead to a claim, email [email protected], or call 0333 222 4257 if it is urgent or sensitive. We report the matter, follow up with the insurer and explain updates. If a deadline is near, follow the notification instructions in your policy immediately. Do not admit liability before speaking to us.

Before you sign, send us the appointment, collateral warranty, novation agreement or sub-consultancy terms you have been asked to accept, with the scope of services, and highlight any fitness for purpose, performance guarantee or indemnity wording. We can flag insurance points to discuss with you and, where needed, your insurer. Your solicitor can advise on the legal effect. A review cannot guarantee cover for a claim.

Claims support  ·  Contract reviews

Review your cover

Let a specialist read your PI cover

Send us your current schedules, wordings, endorsements and renewal information. Tell us about your sectors, dutyholder roles, fire safety and modelling work, and any contract terms that concern you. We will tell you where the cover fits your consultancy, where it does not, and what we would change.

Speak to a PI specialistSend us your renewalGet a quote

  • Your schedule, policy wording and every endorsement
  • Renewal date and your last proposal form
  • Fee split by discipline, sector and project stage
  • Residential and higher-risk building projects, with your role
  • Standard appointment, warranty forms and sub-consultant terms
  • Claims, circumstances and any fire safety restrictions