Home / Insights / Fire safety exclusions compared
Insights | Wording review
Six fire safety exclusions, six different gaps
Most professionals compare PI on premium, limit and excess. Those are the differences you can see. The ones that decide whether a claim is paid sit in the wording, and fire safety shows it clearly: six insurers, six exclusions, each removing something different.
Last reviewed 11 November 2026 by Numan, Director, Hammond PI.
These examples illustrate wording used in the editions identified alongside each entry. Terms offered today may differ. Check the complete wording, schedule and endorsements for your quotation.
What you compare, and what decides cover
The obvious differences
Premium, limit of indemnity and excess. Easy to compare, and usually where the conversation stops.
The wording
What an exclusion covers, how widely it is triggered, how its terms are defined, whether defence costs go with it, and any separate limit or retroactive date.
Two policies can share the same limit and a similar premium and still respond very differently to the same claim. The difference may be a single phrase, such as "arising directly or indirectly" or "in any way connected with", or a definition tucked away at the back of the policy. Which wording is better is not always obvious either. It depends on your work: an exclusion that removes nothing relevant to one practice can remove the very work another practice relies on. The right policy is not simply the cheapest, or the one with the highest limit. It is the one whose wording fits the work you actually do.
The spectrum
Six anonymised summaries, four broad approaches. Some use wide fire safety language; others focus on particular materials, external wall systems or regulatory non-compliance. Their effect always depends on the complete policy and the facts of the claim.
Side by side
Insurer names removed. Our summaries paraphrase each exclusion; the full wording always governs.
| Wording | Type and breadth | What it removes | Our commentary |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wording A | Regulatory non-compliance plus one cladding material | Products, materials or systems that fail to comply with regulations on combustibility, fire resistance or fire protection; and any cladding containing aluminium composite material (ACM). | The narrowest summary here. Its first limb turns on regulatory non-compliance, so a compliant design may fall outside it, though that alone does not establish cover. The ACM limb applies whatever the compliance position. |
| Wording B | Any aspect of fire safety | Combustibility and fire performance of facades, roofs, cladding, insulation, glazing, balconies, doors, hatches, signage, flues and internal and external walls; any aspect of fire safety including warning, escape, fire spread, structural integrity and emergency access; and a catch-all for anything else. | Broad fire safety language reaching internal elements, means of escape, alarm design and habitability, so a designer with no cladding work at all could still be affected. The complete clause, definitions and any exceptions decide a particular claim. |
| Wording C | Any aspect of fire safety | Wording materially the same as B, from a different insurer. | Similar exclusion language can appear in quotes from different insurers. Two quotes can differ on price and be much the same on fire safety. |
| Wording D | External wall systems | Combustibility or fire safety of any external cladding, facade product or external wall system, including core, filler and insulation. | Focused on the external envelope. Allegations about internal doors, compartmentation or escape may fall outside it, but the wide "directly or indirectly" trigger can still catch them where they connect with the external wall system. |
| Wording E | External and internal wall elements | Combustibility or fire safety requirements of cladding, glazing, doors, insulation, cavity barriers and external or internal wall systems, including components and gaskets. | Goes inside the building: doors, cavity barriers and internal walls are named. Relevant to architects specifying door sets and to anyone designing compartmentation. |
| Wording F | One cladding type, plus a broad definition | Combustibility of ACM rainscreen cladding and "equivalent external wall systems", plus "fire safety claims", defined as any claim in any way related to the fire safety of a building. | Check where the defined term appears in the operative exclusion and what it qualifies. Do not infer that all fire claims are excluded from the definition alone. What counts as an "equivalent external wall system" leaves room for argument. |
What we noticed
- The trigger words matter as much as the subject. "Arising directly or indirectly out of" and "in any way connected with" can remove a whole claim where fire safety is only one strand of a wider allegation.
- Definitions do the real work. A heading that says "cladding" can sit over a definition that reaches every fire safety claim (Wording F).
- Defence costs can go too. An exclusion can restrict defence costs as well as the indemnity, so check how it treats costs, including where only part of a claim is fire related.
- Regulatory compliance is not always the test. Only Wording A has a non-compliance limb. Under the others, a compliant design can still be caught.
- Internal elements are not safe. Doors, cavity barriers, internal walls, signage, flues and roof voids appear in several wordings.
- The headline limit will not tell you. Fire terms can sit in the main wording or the endorsements. A £5 million limit on a certificate says nothing about how fire claims are treated.
Where fire safety cover is provided, check its own terms: any separate limit and aggregate basis, how defence costs are treated, reinstatement, the excess, any excluded costs such as waking watch, and any retroactive date that leaves earlier work uninsured.
Who is affected
Architects
Door set and glazing specification, compartmentation, means of escape and facade design all fall within the wider wordings.
Engineers
Structural fire resistance, smoke control, alarm and life safety systems, and facade support can each be caught.
Surveyors and contractors
Inspection, fire risk advice and design and build packages involving envelopes, roofs or partitions.
Many appointments now require fire safety insurance at a stated level. If your policy does not provide it, you may be accepting an insurance obligation you cannot meet. Check the exact requirement before you agree it. See when your contract promises more than your PI covers.
Why a specialist broker matters here
Fire safety is where two policies with the same limit and a similar premium can protect you very differently. We read the endorsement, not the certificate. We match it to the work you actually do, look for insurers whose wording leaves your real activities covered, and where the market allows, negotiate narrower wording or a fire safety sublimit. We check the retroactive date and costs basis, flag where an appointment asks for more than the policy gives, and record it so the decision is yours and informed.
Related guidance
This guidance is provided for general information and does not constitute legal advice or confirmation of insurance cover. Cover is subject to the terms, conditions and exclusions of the relevant policy. Contractual obligations should be considered with appropriate professional advice.