We would like to set optional cookies to understand how the site is used. Essential cookies keep forms working. Cookie policy.

Home / Insights / “Will achieve”: the two words that can take a building services claim outside PI

Insights for building services engineers

“Will achieve”: the two words that can take a building services claim outside PI

Your policy is built around reasonable skill and care. Many appointments ask for more: that the system will achieve a temperature, a noise level, an energy rating or a design life. The difference can decide whether a claim is insured.

Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.

Two standards: care, and result

The law implies into a contract for services a term that the work will be carried out with reasonable care and skill (Supply of Goods and Services Act 1982, section 13). Professional indemnity insurance is built around that standard. If a system underperforms, the question is whether a competent building services engineer would have designed it as you did.

A promise of a result is different. If the appointment says the offices will hold a stated temperature, or the building will achieve a stated energy rating, missing the figure can be a breach however careful the design was.

In Trebor Bassett v ADT the Court of Appeal held that the designer of a fire suppression system had agreed to use reasonable skill and care in its design, and had not guaranteed that the system would put out every fire ([2012] EWCA Civ 1158). That was the answer on that contract. Different words can give a different one.

What one Supreme Court judgment shows about performance wording

MT Højgaard v E.ON is not a building services case, but it shows how the courts can treat performance wording. The foundations of offshore wind turbines in the Solway Firth failed shortly after completion. The contractor had followed the specified design standard, which was later found to contain an error. The technical requirements also said the design “shall ensure a lifetime of 20 years”.

The Supreme Court held the contractor liable. Where a contract requires both compliance with a standard and the achievement of a result, it said, the courts are generally inclined to give full effect to the result ([2017] UKSC 59).

Two points matter to a building services principal. Following the standard was not an answer to the performance requirement. And the words that decided the case sat in a technical schedule, not in the main conditions. Performance obligations are often found in the employer’s requirements, the specification or the scope of services.

The words to look for, and where they hide

These are the words that can turn a duty of care into a promise of a result. None is fatal in every contract, and the effect of each depends on the whole document.

Contract wording that can create a performance guarantee
WordingWhat it may doWhat we usually suggest asking for
“Will achieve”, “shall achieve”, “shall ensure”Promises the temperature, noise level, rating or energy figure itself.Reasonable skill and care to design a system capable of achieving it, on stated assumptions.
“Fit for purpose”, “fit for its intended purpose”Promises the system will work, however careful the design.Deletion, or an express statement that no fitness for purpose duty is given.
“Comply with all statutory requirements”May make a breach of the Building Regulations a breach of contract without negligence.Reasonable skill and care to design so that the work would comply.
“Guarantee”, “warrant and undertake”May be read as an express guarantee, which many wordings exclude.A warranty only that you have used, and will use, reasonable skill and care.
“Indemnify against all losses”Can reach further than damages for negligence would.An indemnity limited to loss caused by your negligence, or none.

Look beyond the conditions: the scope of services, the employer’s requirements, the novation agreement and each collateral warranty.

How PI wordings usually treat a promised result

Wordings differ, but the usual pattern has two parts. The policy excludes liability you take on by contract that is more onerous than the law would otherwise impose, including express guarantees and fitness for purpose. It then writes cover back to the extent you would have been liable anyway, without that term.

In practice that can split a claim in two. If the design was negligent, you would usually have been liable with or without the promise, so cover may respond. If the design was careful and the result was still missed, liability may exist only because of the promise, and that part may be uninsured.

The same split can affect how the claim is run. A claimant may plead the promise because it is easier to prove than negligence. How you answer in the first week can matter, so do not argue the point in correspondence before insurers have seen the clause. The clause guide

What to do before you sign

  1. Search the whole contract pack for the words in the table, including schedules, specifications and documents incorporated by reference.
  2. Find the priority clause. A careful standard of care clause is of little use if a schedule containing “shall ensure” takes precedence over it.
  3. Ask for an overriding clause: whatever else the documents say, your duty is no greater than reasonable skill and care.
  4. Keep forecasts and targets apart. Say in every energy or overheating report what it assumes about hours, occupancy, equipment and controls, and that it is a prediction.
  5. If the client will not move, tell us before you sign. We can put the clause to insurers, and you will know what, if anything, you would be carrying yourself.
  6. Do the same for warranties and novation agreements. Contract reviews

If a claim is put as a broken promise

Suppose a refurbished office misses the energy rating your appointment said the design “will achieve”, and the client claims for upgrades and lost rent.

We would notify insurers at once and send the clause in full, with the model and the forecast you actually gave. We would ask for the defence to be framed around negligence: was the forecast prepared with reasonable skill and care, and were its assumptions made clear? We would ask you for meter data and control system logs, because how the building has been run is often the real cause. And we would ask insurers to confirm in writing which parts of the claim they accept, so that any uninsured element is known early and can be dealt with on your terms. Claims support

Asked to sign “will achieve”?

Send us the clause before you commit, and we will flag the insurance points.

Speak to a PI specialistPI for building services engineers

Related: PI for building services engineers · Contract reviews · The clause guide