We would like to set optional cookies to understand how the site is used. Essential cookies keep forms working. Cookie policy.

Home / Insights / Workmanship or design: how a contractor’s defect claim is split

Insights for design and build contractors

Workmanship or design: how a contractor’s defect claim is split

The employer’s letter says the building is defective. It does not say whether the drawing or the tradesman was at fault, and it does not need to. Your PI policy does need to know, and the answer decides what is paid.

Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.

Why the same defect gets two different answers

Under a design and build contract you answer to the employer for the whole building: the design and the construction. The employer can claim for a leaking façade without proving which of the two failed. Your insurer looks at it the other way round. A design and construct PI wording usually excludes liability arising from the construction work itself, then brings cover back where the loss was caused by a breach of professional duty, such as negligent design or specification.

So every defect claim is really two arguments. The first is with the employer, about whether the building meets the contract. The second is with your own insurer, about how much of the loss came from a professional error. A contractor can lose the first and still have to win the second.

How the employer’s side argues a defect

Claimants plead every route open to them. Martlet Homes v Mulalley shows the pattern ([2022] EWHC 1813 (TCC)). The contract was a 2005 design and build contract on an amended JCT form, for external wall insulation on five tower blocks. The owner first alleged installation breaches: fire barriers and insulation boards that were badly fixed. It then added a specification breach: that the combustible system chosen did not meet the standards of the day.

The judge held that on the installation breaches alone the owner could recover only the cost of a repair scheme. Because it also succeeded on the specification breach, it could recover the cost of replacing the system. One building, one contractor, and the two parts of the claim were measured differently.

Expect the same in a letter of claim: workmanship, design, specification, failure to inspect and breach of statutory duty, all in one document. Nobody on the other side will separate them for you.

What the policy usually does with each part

Parts of a defect claim and how a contractor’s PI wording usually treats each
Part of the claimHow wordings usually treat itWhat decides it
Negligent design or specificationThe core of the cover, whether the design was produced in house, by a novated consultant or by a specialist subcontractorWho designed the detail, and whether the design fell below reasonable skill and care
Defective installationUsually excluded as workmanship, unless a professional error caused itWhether the trade departed from a sound design, or built an unsound one correctly
Failure to inspect or supervise your own worksOften outside the definition of professional duty where the works are yours or your subcontractors’How the wording defines supervision
Opening up and investigationMay be paid as mitigation or defence costs, usually only with insurers’ prior written consentWhether consent was asked for before the cost was incurred
Losses that follow, such as alternative accommodation or a waking watchUsually follow the cause: covered so far as they flow from the design errorEvidence linking each loss to the design, not the installation
Your own profit and mark up on remedial workNormally excludedCost records kept net of both

When the defect is both

Most real defects are mixed. A cavity barrier is drawn in the wrong place and also fitted with gaps. A balcony threshold has too little upstand on the drawing and the membrane is poorly lapped on site. The policy may then answer only the share caused by the design error, and that share is settled by evidence, not by assertion.

The evidence is perishable. Once the work is opened up and replaced, what the drawing showed and what was actually built can no longer be compared. Photographs, samples, the drawing revision issued for construction, the subcontractor’s design submission and the record of who approved it are what an expert needs to apportion cause. If your team repairs first and asks later, the split may be decided on assumptions, and assumptions rarely favour the party that removed the evidence.

What to do when the defect letter arrives

  1. Notify before anyone returns to site. Describe the defect, the allegation and the possible design issue, whatever your own view on fault. How we support a claim
  2. Find out who designed the element: your own team, a novated consultant, a specialist subcontractor or a supplier. Pull the appointment or subcontract and its design clause.
  3. Ask insurers to agree the opening up, the investigation and any urgent making safe before the money is spent.
  4. Record everything found before it is replaced, ideally with an independent expert present.
  5. Put the designer and the subcontractor on written notice and ask for their PI details, without admitting anything to the employer.
  6. Keep the commercial conversation separate. Retention, the final account and the defect are different disputes, and a concession on one can be read as an admission on another.

Why your insurer cares who else is liable

If your policy pays for a design error made by someone else, insurers will want to recover from that party and its insurer. Wordings often exclude or reduce cover where an agreement you made has restricted those rights, and some make cover for subcontracted design depend on your having checked the designer’s PI. Liability caps, net contribution clauses and missing warranties all matter here, so we ask to see them at the start, not at the end.

If the designer has become insolvent, the Third Parties (Rights against Insurers) Act 2010 can transfer its rights under its own policy to the party it is liable to. Whether that policy is worth pursuing depends on its limit, its exclusions and what was notified to it. We would trace it early. The clause guide explains the clauses mentioned here.

A defect letter on your desk?

Send it to us before anyone goes back to site, and we will help you separate the design claim from the workmanship and notify insurers properly.

Speak to a PI specialistPI for design and build contractors

Related: PI for design and build contractors · Claims support · The clause guide