[2017] UKSC 59
MT Højgaard v E.ON Climate and Renewables
A contractor that followed the design standard with reasonable skill and care was still liable on a 20 year service life requirement. The stricter obligation prevailed.
Home / Who we cover / Building contractors and design and construct businesses
Building contractors and design and construct businesses
Design and construct PI, read clause by clause by specialist brokers. We know where a contractor’s design liability starts, what JCT, NEC and employers’ requirements really ask of your policy, and how contractors’ wordings differ from the ones your consultants buy.
Speak to a PI specialistSend us your renewal for reviewGet a quote
Your map
Your business’s work on one side, the policy on the other. Select a point to see what it connects to, then follow the link to the part of this page that explains it.
Still 3D render (motion off)
Each heading below is one area of the map, and the number shows how many points it holds. Open a heading and tap any point: it lights up on the map with everything it connects to, and a short note explains why.
Our experience
Two contractors with the same turnover can carry very different design risk. A contractor’s designed portion on a traditional job, a full JCT design and build with novated consultants, a specialist façade or building services package and a principal designer appointment each put different promises over your signature, and different questions to your policy.
Hammond PI has specialised in professional indemnity since 1990. We read the wording itself: how each insurer defines your professional activities, where the workmanship exclusion stops and negligent design starts, and what it does with fitness for purpose, collateral warranties, fire safety and the cost of putting a defect right. Then we present your business so insurers underwrite the design risk you actually carry.
When a defect or a letter of claim arrives we stay involved. We put the matter to insurers, separate the design allegation from the workmanship, gather what they need and follow it through with the claims handler.
Who requires PI
No regulator or professional body sets a minimum for contractors. The requirement comes from the building contract, the client’s tender conditions and the funder’s terms. These are the sources we see most, with what each one actually asks for.
| Who | Minimum cover | Excess | After you stop | Other conditions |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| JCT Design and Build Contract (clauses 6.15 and 6.16) | No fixed figure. Clause 6.15 obliges the contractor to hold PI at the level the employer enters in the Contract Particulars. The 2024 edition adds space there for sub-limits and for policy exclusions, such as fire safety. Basis: as stated in the Contract Particulars. | Not specified | For the period the Contract Particulars state, so long as cover stays available at commercially reasonable rates and terms | If cover stops being available on those terms, clause 6.16 requires the contractor to tell the employer so that both can discuss how to protect their positions. Employers’ amendments often change both clauses. |
| NEC4 Engineering and Construction Contract (secondary option X15) | No fixed figure. The core clauses do not require cover for design negligence. Where secondary option X15 is chosen, clause X15.5 requires the contractor to take out PI. | Not specified | PI is the one contractor’s insurance that must continue after the defects certificate is issued | X15 sets the design duty at the skill and care normally used by professionals designing similar works. Where X15 is not used, NEC advises the client to state a PI requirement in the contract data. |
| Public contracts and frameworks (Procurement Act 2023 and the Construction Playbook) | Each contracting authority sets its own figure as a condition of participation. The condition must be proportionate to the nature, complexity and cost of the contract. Basis: set by each tender. | Not specified | Set by each contract | An authority may not require the insurance to be in place before the contract is awarded. The Construction Playbook tells authorities not to ask suppliers to take unlimited liabilities. |
Sources: JCT (DB 2024 edition), NEC4 (NEC4 ECC, as described in NEC’s own insurance guidance), Public sector (Procurement Act 2023, section 22; Construction Playbook version 1.1, September 2022). Businesses answering to more than one must meet each set of rules.
A minimum is not a recommendation. Many businesses need more, and cover for each and every claim can protect better than an aggregate limit.
A contract figure is set for one project. Your policy answers every project you have ever designed, on the terms in force when the claim is made. One cladding or fire safety claim can exceed a contract minimum on its own, an aggregate limit can be spent by a single matter, and claims over dwellings can now reach back up to 30 years. Check the basis, the sub-limits and the exclusions before you check the amount.
Claim scenarios
Situations design and build contractors face, the risk hidden in each, and the strategy we would follow from the first letter. Choose a scenario.
The situationEighteen months after practical completion, water is entering flats at the balcony thresholds of a block you built under a JCT design and build contract. The employer’s agent writes alleging defective workmanship and demands that you return and put it right at your own cost.
The riskTreating it as snagging. PI wordings for contractors usually exclude pure workmanship and respond only where negligent design or specification caused the defect. If your team opens up and rebuilds before anyone asks who designed the threshold detail, the evidence goes, and so may the cover for the cost.
Our strategy
What we aim forThe design element of the defect dealt with under the policy, repairs agreed with insurers in advance, and recovery rights against the designer and subcontractor preserved.
The lessonAsk who designed the detail before you fix it. Workmanship is excluded. Negligent design is what PI is for.
The situationMidway through a school project, your temporary works engineer notices that the transfer beams designed by your structural subconsultant are undersized. Two floors are already built on them. The employer does not know and nobody has made a claim.
The riskStrengthening the frame quietly and absorbing it as a site cost. Some contractors’ wordings will pay to rectify a design defect found before handover, but usually only if insurers are told first and agree the steps. Your own profit and mark up are normally excluded either way.
Our strategy
What we aim forThe remedial cost agreed by insurers before it is spent, the programme protected, and a recovery pursued against the subconsultant’s policy.
The lessonRectification cover works only if insurers agree first. Tell us on the day the error is found.
The situationYou designed and built a distribution warehouse on amended JCT terms. The Employer’s Requirements said the slab would carry a stated racking load for 25 years. It is cracking after three. Your engineer followed the recognised design guidance and nobody alleges carelessness.
The riskAssuming PI answers any design failure. The employer is claiming on the performance promise, not on negligence. Contractors’ wordings usually exclude liability more onerous than the ordinary duty of skill and care, including guarantees of fitness for purpose or of meeting a performance specification.
Our strategy
What we aim forInsurers engaged on the negligence element, a clear view of what is uninsured, and no surprise about which promise the claim is really made on.
The lessonPI insures reasonable skill and care. A fitness for purpose promise may go further than any policy will follow.
The situationOn a student residence, the architect novated to you by the employer detailed the cavity barriers incorrectly. The employer claims against you under the building contract. The architect’s practice went into liquidation last year.
The riskTelling the employer it is the architect’s problem. Under design and build you answer for the whole design. Your own wording may also ask whether you checked the consultant’s PI when you took the novation, and may exclude loss where your contract gave away rights of recovery.
Our strategy
What we aim forYour policy responding to the employer’s claim, with every available route to the architect’s insurers kept open.
The lessonA novated consultant’s PI is not your PI. Check it at novation and keep the evidence.
The situationA housing association’s solicitors write about a nine storey block you designed and built in 2011. They allege combustible insulation and missing cavity barriers, cite the Defective Premises Act and seek the cost of full remediation plus a waking watch.
The riskReplying that the claim is out of time. For dwellings, the Building Safety Act extended the Defective Premises Act period to 30 years for older work. Meanwhile your current policy may exclude fire safety claims or cap them in the aggregate, so where the claim attaches matters greatly.
Our strategy
What we aim forThe claim attached to the most favourable policy year available, the defence funded, and recovery routes against designers and subcontractors identified early.
The lessonOld projects are live again. Your past notifications may be worth more than your current policy.
The situationYou are a mechanical services subcontractor with design responsibility. The main contractor has withheld your final account and now serves a notice of adjudication, claiming the smoke ventilation system you designed does not meet the fire strategy and must be replaced.
The riskHanding it to your quantity surveyor as a payment dispute. The counterclaim is a design claim. Some wordings cover adjudication only if insurers are told within days of the notice, and defence costs incurred without consent are not paid. The timetable leaves no room to catch up.
Our strategy
What we aim forA funded, expert defence of the design allegation within the timetable, and the payment dispute kept from prejudicing the policy.
The lessonAdjudication moves faster than most policies allow for. Notify on the day the notice arrives.
The situationNine years after completing an office building, you receive a claim from the tenant for defective curtain walling design. It sues on a collateral warranty you signed at handover. The warranty runs for fifteen years and has no clause limiting your liability to that under the building contract.
The riskAssuming every warranty you sign is insured. Contractors’ wordings usually cover collateral warranties only where the benefit is no greater and lasts no longer than the duty owed to the original client, and not for guarantees of fitness for purpose or completion dates.
Our strategy
What we aim forCover confirmed for the part of the warranty that mirrors the building contract, and the uninsured excess identified and defended.
The lessonEvery warranty should give no greater liability, for no longer, than the building contract. Send them to us first.
Illustrative scenarios. How any real claim is handled depends on the facts, the policy wording and insurers’ agreement.
A claim today may concern a building you designed and handed over several years ago. PI is written on a claims made basis: the policy in force when the claim is made responds, provided the work falls after the retroactive date and nothing was already notified under an earlier policy.
A valid notification of circumstances can connect a later claim to an earlier policy. That is why continuity matters when you change insurers or stop a particular service. How claims made cover works
A contractor’s PI policy is not a guarantee of the building. Most design and construct wordings exclude the construction work itself and bring cover back only where the loss comes from a negligent design, specification or other professional activity listed in the policy. The first question on any defect is therefore who designed it, and whether the design or the installation failed. Many defects are both, and the policy may then answer only the design share. That is why we ask you to notify before you repair: once the work is opened up and replaced, the evidence that separates the two has gone.
The Defective Premises Act 1972 requires anyone who takes on work for the provision of a dwelling to do it in a workmanlike or professional manner, with proper materials, so the dwelling is fit for habitation. You cannot contract out of that duty (Defective Premises Act 1972). The Building Safety Act 2022 extended the time limit to 30 years for claims that had already accrued before 28 June 2022, and to 15 years for later claims (Building Safety Act 2022, section 135). PI is written on a claims made basis, so it is the policy in force when the claim arrives, with its current fire safety terms, that has to respond.
Two unrelated covered claims of £750,000 each come to £1.5 million. Under a £1 million limit in the aggregate, the policy pays up to £1 million for the year in total. Under a £1 million limit for each and every claim, each claim has its own £1 million, subject to the policy’s aggregation wording and other terms.
£1 million in the aggregate
£1 million each and every claim
Then check whether defence costs are paid in addition to the limit or use it up, and when the excess applies.
Inside the wording
Two policies with the same limit can answer the same claim very differently. These are the clauses we read first, what each means for a design and build contractor and what we check.
What it doesCovers liability for breach of professional duty in your business. The policy defines that duty as a list: design, specification, technical calculations, feasibility studies, surveying and any other activities named in the schedule.
For a design and build contractorIf design management, principal designer duties, fire engineering input or temporary works design is not within the definition or the schedule, a claim from it may fall outside cover.
What we checkThe definition and the schedule against every design activity you actually perform or manage.
What it doesExcludes liability from constructing, installing, altering or repairing, by you or your subcontractors, unless the loss was caused by a breach of professional duty.
For a design and build contractorThis is the clause that separates your PI from a consultant’s. A defect must be traced to negligent design or specification before the policy will respond.
What we checkHow the exception is worded, and whether it needs negligence or responds to any breach of professional duty.
What it doesSupervision may count as a professional activity only where the works supervised are not carried out by you, a connected company or your subcontractors.
For a design and build contractorA failure by your own site managers to spot bad work is usually treated as workmanship, not as a professional error. Inspection duties under design and build can fall into that gap.
What we checkWhether supervision and inspection of your own packages sits inside or outside the professional duty definition.
What it doesExcludes liability more onerous than the law would imply, including guarantees, penalties and liquidated damages.
For a design and build contractorAmended JCT and NEC terms often ask for fitness for purpose, performance guarantees or wide indemnities. The policy usually follows you only as far as reasonable skill and care.
What we checkThe exclusion against your usual contract amendments, and whether cover remains for liability that would exist without the onerous term.
What it doesBrings warranties and duty of care agreements back into cover, provided the benefit is no greater and lasts no longer than the duty owed to your client.
For a design and build contractorFunders, purchasers and tenants each want one. A longer period, wider losses or unlimited assignment can take a warranty outside this protection.
What we checkEach warranty for a no greater liability clause, its duration and its assignment terms, before you sign.
What it doesPays agreed costs of avoiding a claim, or reducing a loss, that the policy would otherwise cover. Insurers’ prior written consent is usually required.
For a design and build contractorThis is the route to funding the repair of a design defect before handover or before the employer claims. Your own profit and mark up are normally excluded.
What we checkWhether rectification before handover is covered, the consent needed, any sub-limit and how the costs must be recorded.
What it doesOften added by endorsement: an exclusion, or an aggregate sub-limit, for claims about combustibility, fire performance or external wall systems.
For a design and build contractorA current policy with a fire safety exclusion may not answer a claim about a block finished years ago, however good the cover was when you built it.
What we checkThe exact wording, what it catches beyond cladding, whether defence costs sit inside the sub-limit, and what was notified in earlier years.
What it doesCover for work you subcontract can depend on your having checked that the subconsultant or subcontractor holds adequate PI, and on keeping evidence of the check.
For a design and build contractorMost of your design is produced by others: novated consultants, specialist subcontractors and suppliers. Their errors are your liability to the employer.
What we checkThe condition itself, your procedure for collecting PI evidence each year, and whether limits and exclusions are checked as well as the existence of a policy.
What it doesExcludes or reduces cover where an agreement you made has restricted your rights of recovery against a third party.
For a design and build contractorLiability caps, net contribution clauses and limited warranties in consultants’ appointments and novation agreements can all restrict what is recoverable.
What we checkYour standard appointment and subcontract terms for anything that limits what insurers could recover.
What it doesCovers adjudication only if insurers are notified very quickly, sometimes within two working days of the notice, and the timetable is no more onerous than the statutory scheme.
For a design and build contractorDesign counterclaims regularly arrive inside payment adjudications. A late notice, or a bespoke contract timetable, can put cover at risk.
What we checkThe notice period, the conditions on procedure, and your internal route for getting a notice to us the same day.
What it doesClaims and circumstances must be notified as soon as reasonably possible. Claims arising from one originating cause are treated as one claim with one limit.
For a design and build contractorA detail repeated across several blocks, or one specification used on many projects, can be one claim. Whether that helps or hurts depends on the limit and the excess.
What we checkThe definition of a circumstance, the aggregation words, and whether the limit is any one claim or in the aggregate.
What it doesPollution cover is usually limited to sudden incidents caused by a professional error, within a lower aggregate limit that includes costs. Asbestos is often excluded altogether.
For a design and build contractorRefurbishment and brownfield work bring both. JCT’s Contract Particulars have long provided for a pollution and contamination sub-limit to be stated.
What we checkSub-limits and exclusions against the contract’s insurance clause, so you do not promise cover you do not hold.
Law and duties
[2017] UKSC 59
A contractor that followed the design standard with reasonable skill and care was still liable on a 20 year service life requirement. The stricter obligation prevailed.
[2025] UKSC 21
The retrospective 30 year period also supports negligence and contribution claims that depend on Defective Premises Act liability. No rule bars recovery of repair costs incurred voluntarily.
[2022] EWHC 1813 (TCC)
A design and build contractor was liable for specifying combustible external wall insulation under a 2005 contract, and for installation defects. Waking watch costs were recoverable.
[2024] EWHC 3235 (TCC)
An adjudicator could decide a Defective Premises Act claim arising from a 2002 building contract. The court enforced an award of over £14 million against the contractor.
[2024] EWHC 3569 (TCC)
A building liability order made a parent company liable for its insolvent subsidiary’s fire safety and structural defects.
[2024] UKSC 23
A collateral warranty that only repeats the contractor’s promises under the building contract is not a construction contract, so it carries no statutory right to adjudicate.
These decisions explain where a professional’s duty lies. They do not decide whether a particular policy responds.
Specialist work
A turnover split on a proposal form says little about design risk. These are the areas where we ask most, starting with the two that shape every contractor’s renewal now: fire safety and the Building Safety Act dutyholder roles.
Insurers restrict fire safety cover across construction. In the Construction Leadership Council’s 2021 survey of 1,066 firms, over 60% had some restriction on cladding or fire safety cover, one in three had a total exclusion for cladding claims and one in five a total exclusion for fire claims (Construction Industry Council, CLC survey results). Terms still differ sharply between insurers.
We ask for your project list by height, use and external wall type, what has been surveyed and what has been notified. In Martlet Homes v Mulalley a contractor was held liable in 2022 for a system installed under a 2005 contract.
A design and build contractor is usually the principal contractor, and often the principal designer too, under two separate regimes. JCT’s 2024 form names both roles for the CDM Regulations and again for the Building Regulations (JCT DB 2024, articles 6 and 7).
For PI the questions are whether the principal designer role is within your insured activities, who in the business is the designated competent individual, and whether you perform the role yourself or pass the tasks to a consultant. Delegating the tasks does not transfer the legal responsibility. Wordings usually exclude fines, and cover for defending a prosecution is usually a separate, limited extension.
On a traditionally procured job the architect designs the building and you design named parts: the piling, the frame connections, the cladding fixings or the mechanical and electrical installation. It looks like a small design role, but for that portion you carry a designer’s liability, and you usually pass the work to a specialist subcontractor.
We ask which portions you take on, who actually produces the design, what the subcontract says about the design standard and insurance, and how the interface with the architect’s design is checked. Claims often start at that interface, where each side assumed the other had designed the detail. If your proposal says you do “no design”, a contractor’s designed portion is the work that contradicts it.
Under design and build, the employer’s architect and engineers are often novated to you when the contract is awarded. From then on you answer to the employer for their design, including, depending on the wording, what they did before novation.
PI follows the professional standard: reasonable skill and care. Many employers’ amendments ask for more: that the works will be fit for purpose, will meet a performance specification, or will comply with the Employer’s Requirements whatever care was taken. In MT Højgaard v E.ON the Supreme Court held a contractor to a service life requirement although it had followed the design standard ([2017] UKSC 59).
We read tender amendments for these terms, and for wide indemnities, uncapped liability and liquidated damages linked to design. The Construction Playbook tells public authorities not to ask suppliers to take unlimited liabilities (GOV.UK, the Construction Playbook). Where a term cannot be removed, you should at least know that it sits outside the policy.
A design and build contract rarely ends with the employer. JCT provides for collateral warranties or third party rights in favour of funders, purchasers and tenants, from you and from your subcontractors (JCT DB 2024, section 7). Each one creates a direct claim on your design.
Most wordings cover warranties only if they give no greater benefit, for no longer, than the building contract. We check the standard of care, the limitation period, the losses recoverable, step in rights, the number of assignments and any promise to maintain PI at a stated level. A promise to hold a fixed limit for twelve years, whatever the market offers, is a promise about something you do not control.
Façade, roofing, mechanical and electrical, fire protection, piling, steelwork and modular specialists often design what they install, under a subcontract that passes down the main contract’s design terms in full. The main contractor may then ask for PI at the main contract level and a warranty to the employer.
We look at whether design is done in house or bought in, and who signs it off, because some wordings require design to be done or supervised by a qualified or suitably experienced person. We also separate product supply from design: a defective product is not a PI claim unless a design or specification error lies behind it.
Replacing cladding, upgrading fire stopping or converting a building into flats is design work on someone else’s building. Work completed since 28 June 2022 on any building containing a dwelling carries its own Defective Premises Act duty (Building Safety Act 2022, section 134). In the Construction Leadership Council’s 2021 survey, one in three firms said they had been unable to carry out remedial work they wanted to do (Construction Industry Council).
Insurers ask who designs the remedial scheme, who the fire engineer is, what survey information you rely on and what you sign at completion about the external wall. A fire safety exclusion that seems tolerable for new commercial work can remove cover for the very job you are tendering.
Your presentation
An unexplained label can make a modest exposure look broader than it is, while a vague one can hide an important responsibility. Here is how we turn brief answers into a picture insurers can underwrite properly.
| What insurers often see | What we send instead |
|---|---|
| “We do no design. It is all subcontracted.” | Which packages carry design, who produces it, the design terms passed down and the PI evidence you collect from each designer. |
| “Design and build: 40% of turnover.” | The projects behind the figure by sector, contract value, height and form of contract, and the design responsibility accepted on each. |
| “No cladding work.” | Residential and high rise projects over the past 15 years, external wall types, what has been surveyed and anything already notified. |
| “Standard JCT terms.” | Your usual amendments: design standard, fitness for purpose, liability caps, warranties and the PI clause you are asked to sign. |
| “Consultants carry their own PI.” | Who checks limits, exclusions and renewal dates for each consultant, how often, and where the evidence is kept. |
| “No claims, only a few defects.” | Defects notices, withheld retentions, adjudications and letters alleging design fault, with their status and what insurers were told. |
Illustrations of common answers, not statements about particular clients.
Business changes
A first higher-risk building, a new sector or a contract well above your usual size changes the risk. Tell us at tender stage, before the PI clause is agreed.
Check the role is within your insured activities and that a competent individual is designated. Tell us whether you perform it yourself or appoint a consultant.
Each contracting entity needs to be named on the policy. Building liability orders mean an associated company can be made to answer for another’s building safety liabilities.
You may inherit its completed projects. Establish its notification history, its fire safety terms and who insures its past work from the day of completion.
Notify every known defect and circumstance to the outgoing insurer first. Check the retroactive date carries across, and compare the fire safety terms line by line.
Liability under a deed lasts twelve years, and Defective Premises Act claims can run for 15 or 30. Plan run off before the company is closed.
Tell us as soon as you know. JCT’s Design and Build Contract makes the PI obligation subject to cover being available at commercially reasonable rates and, in the 2024 edition, on reasonable terms. If it is not, clause 6.16 requires you to notify the employer so that both sides can discuss how to protect their positions (Mills & Reeve, JCT DB 2024 insurance). That protection is often amended out, so read the contract you signed. We would set out for the employer what the market is offering and why, a better conversation before signing than after a breach.
Alongside your PI
PI answers claims that your design or specification was negligent. It is not built to pay for damage to the works during construction, or for injury and damage caused by site operations. We recommend contractors consider contractors’ all risks and public and products liability alongside it, because one defect can involve all three.
Tap a situation for the explanation. A general guide only: the answer always depends on the actual wordings.
Physical loss or damage to the works, site materials and plant during the contract is what contractors’ all risks insures. Under JCT the works are insured under Insurance Option A, B or C. PI is not a property policy.
PI may fund rectification of a negligent design, with insurers’ prior consent. All risks policies usually exclude the cost of correcting the defective part itself, but may pay for resulting damage to sound work, depending on the defects exclusion.
Injury to the public and damage to third party property arising from site operations is public liability. Contractors’ PI wordings usually exclude injury and damage unless they result from negligent design, specification or advice.
Injury or damage caused by negligent design is where PI and liability cover meet. Many public and products liability policies exclude design or advice given for a fee, so the design claim usually sits with PI. We would notify both.
The cost of redoing your own defective work is a business risk that none of the three policies is built to pay. That is why the split between design and workmanship matters on every defect.
Built for itMay respondNot built for it
Contractors’ all risks covers physical loss or damage to the contract works and, usually, site materials, temporary works and owned or hired plant while the project is being built.
Cover for the works usually ends around practical completion. Design liability does not.
Public liability covers your legal liability for injury to third parties and damage to their property arising from your operations. Products liability does the same for what you have supplied or installed. JCT requires the contractor to insure its liability for personal injury and property damage (JCT DB 2024, clause 6.4).
Employers’ liability is separate and compulsory for most employers, with a minimum of £5 million (GOV.UK). The other covers we arrange
Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.
Proposal form
Ask us for the appropriate proposal form, or send us your details when you request a quote.
This form is not available to download at the moment. Call 0333 222 4257 or email [email protected] and we will send it to you.
Beyond the policy
If you receive a complaint or become aware of something that could lead to a claim, email [email protected], or call 0333 222 4257 if it is urgent or sensitive. We report the matter, follow up with the insurer and explain updates. If a deadline is near, follow the notification instructions in your policy immediately. Do not admit liability before speaking to us.
Before you sign, send us the building contract or subcontract amendments, the Employer’s Requirements on design and insurance, any novation agreement, collateral warranty or third party rights schedule, and the PI clause you are asked to accept. Highlight the wording that concerns you. We can flag insurance points to discuss with you and, where needed, your insurer. Your solicitor can advise on the legal effect. A review cannot guarantee cover for a claim.
Review your cover
Send us your current schedules, wordings, endorsements and renewal information. Tell us about your design responsibility, fire safety history, dutyholder roles and any contract terms that worry you. We will tell you where the cover fits the design risk you carry, where it does not, and what we would change.