Home / Insights / When a prosecuted client blames your risk assessment: how the claim reaches you
Insights for health and safety consultants
When a prosecuted client blames your risk assessment: how the claim reaches you
A client’s prosecution after an accident rarely ends with the client. Its fine, its legal costs and the injured worker’s damages can all be pointed at the consultant who wrote the risk assessment. Each is argued differently, and your PI treats each differently.
Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.
Why the client turns to its consultant
An employer must appoint one or more competent persons to help it comply with health and safety law, and many appoint an outside consultant (Management Regulations 1999, regulation 7). The appointment does not move the duty. The regulations give the employer no defence in criminal proceedings on the ground that the fault lay with the person it appointed (regulation 21), and HSE tells employers that with a consultant, managing health and safety is still their legal duty (HSE, getting help).
So after an accident the client is prosecuted, pays, and then looks for someone to share the bill. If your name is on the risk assessment, the letter comes to you.
Three routes from the accident to you
The same accident can reach you in three ways, each on its own timetable.
| Route | Who brings it | What it rests on |
|---|---|---|
| The client’s own claim | Your client, or its insurer | Breach of contract or negligence in your assessment, audit or advice. It may include the client’s fine, its legal costs and what it paid the injured person. |
| A contribution claim | Whoever compensated the injured person | A person liable for damage can recover a contribution from anyone else liable for the same damage (Civil Liability (Contribution) Act 1978, section 1). |
| Prosecution of you | HSE or the local authority | Where a client’s offence is due to the act or default of another person, that person can be convicted whether or not the client is prosecuted (1974 Act, section 36). A self-employed consultant owes the section 3 duty where the work may pose a risk to others (section 3), and a director can be personally guilty where the company’s offence was attributable to their neglect (section 37). |
How the claim against you is argued
The client’s case is simple: we paid you to tell us what was wrong, and you did not. The assessment itself will be the main exhibit. In Goldscheider v Royal Opera House a noise risk assessment that did not address the level, type and duration of exposure, and was not reviewed as conditions changed, counted against the employer ([2019] EWCA Civ 711).
The consultant’s answer usually rests on three points.
- Scope. What the retainer covered: which sites, machines and tasks, how many visits, and what was expressly left out.
- Unheeded advice. Recommendations made in writing that the client did not act on, with their dates.
- Causation. Whether the accident came from something the assessment missed, or from the client not following it: a guard removed, a procedure ignored, a change in the process that nobody reported.
All three are argued from documents, not from memory.
What the policy does with each part of the demand
A client’s letter usually mixes several demands. Separating them is the first job.
| Part of the demand | How PI usually treats it |
|---|---|
| The injured person’s damages | The core of a consultant’s cover, provided the wording covers injury caused by negligent advice or another breach of professional duty. |
| The client’s legal costs | Claimed as a loss flowing from your advice. Expect argument over how much of the client’s defence was caused by your error and how much by its own failings. |
| The client’s fine | PI wordings exclude fines and penalties. In Safeway Stores v Twigger the Court of Appeal refused to let a company recover a penalty for its own breach from the directors and employees whose conduct caused it ([2010] EWCA Civ 1472). |
| HSE’s fee for intervention | HSE charges the dutyholder where an inspector finds a material breach, at £188 an hour (HSE, fee for intervention, HSE rates, updated 1 April 2026). How a wording treats that invoice when a client passes it on depends on its exact words. |
| Return of your fees | Usually excluded. A refund or credit note offered without insurers’ agreement can also prejudice the rest of the claim. |
| Your own prosecution | No policy pays your fine. Many wordings add an extension for the legal costs of defending a health and safety prosecution, usually to a separate, smaller limit and only with insurers’ prior consent. |
What to do in the first week
- Notify on the day you hear of the accident or the prosecution, not the day the client writes. An accident at a client’s site that involves your documents can be a circumstance under the policy.
- Send us the client’s letter, any HSE notice, the retainer and the assessment together. We put it to insurers as a civil claim and a possible prosecution at the same time.
- Do not give HSE an account or attend an interview until insurers have agreed a solicitor. Some extensions start at an interview under caution, others only once proceedings begin.
- Do not apologise in writing, issue a credit note or offer to help with costs without insurers’ agreement.
- Preserve the file: visit reports, emails, photographs, drafts and the version of the assessment that was in force on the day.
The record that defends you
Most of the defence is written before the accident. IOSH’s guidance to consultants notes that if a complaint becomes a claim, insurers are likely to prefer that the scope of your involvement was clearly documented (IOSH, consultancy good practice guide). In practice that means a retainer that says what is and is not included, a dated report after every visit, and a running list of recommendations showing which the client has closed and which it has not.
Hammond PI has specialised in professional indemnity since 1990. We read the injury and prosecution defence clauses before you need them, and we stay involved when a claim comes. How we support claims
Has a client had an accident or an HSE visit?
Tell us the day you hear of it, and we will put it to insurers before anyone asks you for an account.
Speak to a PI specialistPI for health and safety consultants
Related: PI for health and safety consultants · Claims support · The clause guide