[2016] UKSC 6
Kennedy v Cordia (Services) LLP
A suitable and sufficient risk assessment comes first. The court judged the employer’s precautions by examining it, and accepted expert evidence from a consultant with health and safety experience.
Home / Who we cover / Health and safety consultants
Health and safety consultants
Health and safety consultants’ PI, read clause by clause by specialist brokers. We know how advice on risk assessment, CDM, fire, asbestos and occupational hygiene turns into injury claims and prosecutions, and where wordings quietly exclude that work.
Speak to a PI specialistSend us your renewal for reviewGet a quote
Your map
Your consultancy’s work on one side, the policy on the other. Select a point to see what it connects to, then follow the link to the part of this page that explains it.
Still 3D render (motion off)
Each heading below is one area of the map, and the number shows how many points it holds. Open a heading and tap any point: it lights up on the map with everything it connects to, and a short note explains why.
Our experience
Two consultancies with the same fee income can need very different cover. A retained competent person service, CDM and principal designer work, fire risk assessments, asbestos and legionella surveys, occupational hygiene monitoring, training and accident investigation each carry different liabilities, and most of the claims that follow involve someone being hurt.
Hammond PI has specialised in professional indemnity since 1990. We read the wording itself: whether injury and property damage caused by your advice are covered, how asbestos, fire safety and pollution are treated, what the policy pays towards defending a prosecution, and how it groups related claims. Then we present your consultancy so insurers underwrite the work you actually do.
When a problem arises we stay involved. We put the matter to insurers, gather what they need and follow it through with the claims handler, from the first call after an accident to the last letter.
Who requires PI
No body sets a fixed minimum limit for health and safety consultants. The consultants register and the professional bodies each expect cover that fits your work.
| Who | Minimum cover | Excess | After you stop | Other conditions |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Occupational Safety and Health Consultants Register | No set figure. Applicants declare that they hold professional indemnity insurance, or an equivalent, covering the nature of their duties, and the registration terms require evidence of it. | Not specified | Not specified | Registration also needs chartered or equivalent status with a participating body (for example Chartered Member of IOSH, Fellow of IIRSM, or Chartered Member or Chartered Fellow of the BOHS Faculty of Occupational Hygiene), continuing professional development and a commitment to sensible and proportionate advice. |
| Institution of Occupational Safety and Health | No set figure, and the current Code of Conduct contains no insurance rule. IOSH’s consultancy good practice guide describes professional indemnity insurance as essential for members who consult, and notes that it is required for the consultants register. | Not specified | The guide advises members who stop consulting or retire to consider run off cover for a period afterwards, because a claim can follow the event by some time. | The Code requires members to be competent for the duties they carry out and to make clients aware of their level of competence. The guide warns that a PI policy will often not cover contract obligations that exceed the cover. |
| International Institute of Risk and Safety Management | No set figure. The Code of Ethics says members who are self-employed should ensure that appropriate professional indemnity insurance is current and up to date. | Not specified | Not specified | Members should only advise or undertake tasks in areas where they are competent, and accept personal responsibility for all work carried out by them or under their supervision. |
| Association for Project Safety | No published figure. Members are expected to have adequate and appropriate professional indemnity insurance for themselves, their business and their employees, and to maintain a minimum level of cover. Members who provide services other than as an employee confirm each year that they hold current cover. | Not specified | The Code expects the cover maintained to include run off cover as appropriate. | Cover must be on terms and for amounts compatible with the scale and extent of the member’s professional services. The Code’s guidance treats accepting an appointment without telling the client that insurance is insufficient for its scope as an example of a breach. |
| British Occupational Hygiene Society (Faculty of Occupational Hygiene) | No set figure. Consultancies must have valid professional indemnity, public liability and, where applicable, employers’ liability insurance in place in order to offer occupational hygiene consultancy services. | Not specified | Not specified | The guide also expects reports to be reviewed and quality checked, and Faculty members and registrants to follow the BOHS Code of Ethics. |
Sources: OSHCR (eligibility criteria and registration terms, last updated November 2025), IOSH (current Code of Conduct and consultancy good practice guide, as read in November 2026), IIRSM (Code of Ethics, dated 27 September 2023), APS (Code of Professional Conduct, updated April 2024, and PI guidance page read November 2026), BOHS (Good Practice Guide for Consultants, version 3, December 2024). Consultancies answering to more than one must meet each set of rules.
A minimum is not a recommendation. Many consultancies need more, and cover for each and every claim can protect better than an aggregate limit.
None of these bodies sets a figure, so the limit is yours to judge. Judge it against the worst realistic injury at your highest hazard client, not against your fees. A serious injury claim brings both sides’ legal costs with it, a cap in your terms cannot limit liability for injury caused by negligence, and one flawed method can reach many clients under a single limit. Client contracts and frameworks often ask for more than any professional body does.
Claim scenarios
Situations health and safety consultants face, the risk hidden in each, and the strategy we would follow from the first letter. Choose a scenario.
The situationYou are the appointed competent person for a manufacturer. A worker loses fingers on a machine your risk assessment covered. HSE prosecutes the client, which writes to say it followed your advice and will hold you responsible for its fine, its legal costs and the injury claim. HSE also asks to interview you.
The riskTreating it as the client’s problem, or answering HSE and the client alone. The fine, the client’s costs and the injury claim are three different things under your policy. Cover for defending a prosecution is usually a separate, smaller limit that needs insurers’ consent before any cost is incurred.
Our strategy
What we aim forA funded defence on both the civil and criminal sides, the claim confined to what your advice actually caused, and no breach of the policy conditions.
The lessonYour client’s prosecution is your circumstance. Notify it the day you hear of it.
The situationYou reviewed a contractor’s lifting plan and method statement. A load slips and a worker is badly hurt. The contractor’s insurer pays the worker, then seeks a contribution from your consultancy, saying your review missed an obvious fault. Your consultancy holds liability policies with two different insurers.
The riskNotifying only the general liability insurer because someone was hurt. Many such policies exclude advice given for a fee, and many PI policies exclude injury unless it flows from professional negligence. Each insurer can say the claim belongs to the other while the time to respond runs.
Our strategy
What we aim forOne insurer defending from the outset, no gap between the two policies, and the contribution argued on what your review was engaged to cover.
The lessonFor a consultant, an injury claim is usually a PI claim. Check the injury wording before you need it.
The situationA senior consultant finds that your vibration exposure assessments have used the wrong tool data for three years. Fourteen clients were told exposure was below the action value. Two now have employees diagnosed with hand arm vibration syndrome, and one client’s insurer has written to you.
The riskDealing only with the client that has complained. The other twelve know nothing yet, and what you know today is excluded from next year’s policy unless it is notified now. The aggregation and excess wording decide whether this is one claim or many, and some wordings apply the excess to each claimant.
Our strategy
What we aim forEvery affected client protected by one notification, workers’ exposure reduced early, and the limit and excess position known before the claims arrive.
The lessonOne method across many clients is one notification. Make it complete, and make it now.
The situationYour refurbishment survey of a school block reported no asbestos in a ceiling void. Contractors cut into asbestos insulating board during the works. The site is closed, the client faces decontamination costs and delay, and several workers and staff may have been exposed.
The riskAssuming a health and safety PI policy covers asbestos work. Standard wordings often exclude anything connected with asbestos unless surveying is specifically added, and the added cover may be a smaller aggregate limit that includes costs. Exposure claims may also come many years after the clean up claim.
Our strategy
What we aim forThe clean up claim handled inside the asbestos limit, future exposure claims tied to the policy notified now, and no gap in later years.
The lessonAsbestos cover is added, limited and long tailed. Know your endorsement before the survey, not after.
The situationTwo years ago you assessed a block of flats for a managing agent. A fire and rescue service audit now serves an enforcement notice, saying the assessment did not properly address compartmentation or the external walls. The agent wants its remedial and interim costs back from you.
The riskLooking to the policy in force when the assessment was written. PI is claims made, so today’s policy responds, on today’s terms. If a fire safety exclusion or a lower fire safety limit was added at a recent renewal, cover for older assessments may have narrowed without anyone noticing.
Our strategy
What we aim forThe claim placed with the right policy year, defended on the assessment’s stated scope, and the rest of the portfolio notified before renewal.
The lessonFire safety terms change at renewal. Past assessments are judged against the policy you hold today.
The situationYou were CDM principal designer for a developer under its own form of appointment. It required you to ensure the design was safe and to indemnify the client against all losses. After a temporary works collapse the client’s solicitors claim under the indemnity and serve a notice of adjudication.
The riskTwo traps. PI usually covers the liability you would have had anyway for lack of skill and care, not the extra you accepted by promising to ensure a result or by giving an indemnity. And adjudication moves in days: some wordings require notice within two working days.
Our strategy
What we aim forThe negligence allegation defended within the adjudication timetable, the uninsured contractual element identified early, and recovery rights against others kept intact.
The lessonThe appointment you sign decides how much of a claim your PI can answer.
The situationYou ran a one person occupational hygiene consultancy and retired four years ago. A former client’s insurer now writes about a worker diagnosed with occupational asthma. It relies on your exposure monitoring report from nine years ago, which said the spray booth controls were adequate.
The riskAssuming the liability ended when the work or the business did. An injury claim can be brought within three years of the date the person knew of the injury, which may be long after the exposure. A PI policy that lapsed on retirement does not respond to a claim made today.
Our strategy
What we aim forA run off policy that responds, a funded defence for a retired consultant, and the old records to hand.
The lessonOccupational disease has a long tail. Run off for a consultant is planned in years, not months.
Illustrative scenarios. How any real claim is handled depends on the facts, the policy wording and insurers’ agreement.
A claim today may concern a risk assessment, survey or training course delivered several years ago. PI is written on a claims made basis: the policy in force when the claim is made responds, provided the work falls after the retroactive date and nothing was already notified under an earlier policy.
A valid notification of circumstances can connect a later claim to an earlier policy. That is why continuity matters when you change insurers or stop a particular service. How claims made cover works
An employer must appoint a competent person to help it comply, but the duty stays with the employer (Management Regulations 1999, regulation 7). The regulations give it no defence in criminal proceedings on the ground that the fault lay with the person it appointed (regulation 21). HSE tells employers the same: with a consultant, managing health and safety is still their legal duty (HSE, getting help).
Your exposure arrives by other routes: a claim by the client in contract or negligence, a contribution claim from whoever compensated an injured person (Civil Liability (Contribution) Act 1978, section 1), and prosecution in your own right.
A person cannot use a contract term or notice to exclude or restrict liability for death or personal injury resulting from negligence. For other loss, a term restricting liability for negligence must satisfy the requirement of reasonableness (Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977, section 2).
So the cap in your terms may protect you against a client’s financial loss, but it does not cap the injury claim, which is the typical serious claim for this profession. Choose your limit of indemnity on that footing, and do not let a capped contract persuade you that a low limit is enough.
Two unrelated covered claims of £750,000 each come to £1.5 million. Under a £1 million limit in the aggregate, the policy pays up to £1 million for the year in total. Under a £1 million limit for each and every claim, each claim has its own £1 million, subject to the policy’s aggregation wording and other terms.
£1 million in the aggregate
£1 million each and every claim
Then check whether defence costs are paid in addition to the limit or use it up, and when the excess applies.
Inside the wording
Two policies with the same limit can answer the same claim very differently. These are the clauses we read first, what each means for a health and safety consultant and what we check.
What it doesCovers civil liability for claims first made in the period arising from your professional business, usually defined as the business of a firm of the type named in the schedule and described in the proposal.
For a health and safety consultantIf the schedule says health and safety consultants but you also do fire risk assessments, asbestos surveys, principal designer work or training, the description needs to say so.
What we checkThe business description against every service you invoice for.
What it doesMost PI wordings exclude injury and property damage, then give cover back where they are caused by negligent advice, design, specification or another breach of professional duty.
For a health and safety consultantThis write back is the heart of the policy for a consultant. Injury from your advice should be inside it. Injury from something you physically did on site may not be.
What we checkThe exact words of the write back, and how it meets any other liability policy you hold.
What it doesAn extension paying legal costs to defend a prosecution under health and safety legislation, usually to a separate aggregate limit and only with insurers’ prior consent.
For a health and safety consultantCover can stop on a guilty plea or when counsel advises there are no reasonable prospects, apart from a plea in mitigation. Fines, and prosecution costs awarded against you, are not covered.
What we checkThe limit, whether cover starts at an interview under caution or only once proceedings begin, and when it ends.
What it doesPays agreed legal costs for representation at an inquiry or similar proceeding where the outcome may bear on a claim the policy would cover.
For a health and safety consultantAfter a death at a client’s site you may be called to an inquest long before any claim. Whether representation is funded depends on this clause and on insurers’ consent.
What we checkWhich proceedings qualify, the consent needed and whether an excess applies.
What it doesMany wordings exclude any claim connected with asbestos, including advice or warnings given or not given, with at most a narrow exception for making clients aware of their own duties.
For a health and safety consultantSurveys, sampling, air monitoring and management plans are usually outside a standard policy unless added by endorsement, often at a lower aggregate limit.
What we checkWhether your actual asbestos work is endorsed, the limit, and whether defence costs sit inside it.
What it doesExcludes claims related to seepage, pollution or contamination. Some wordings add fungi, spores and airborne biological agents.
For a health and safety consultantOccupational hygiene, COSHH assessments, indoor air quality, contaminated land and water hygiene work can all touch these words.
What we checkHow each exclusion reads against your monitoring, legionella and environmental services.
What it doesExcludes liability you take on by contract beyond what the law would impose anyway: duties stricter than reasonable skill and care, guarantees, warranties, indemnities and liquidated damages.
For a health and safety consultantClient appointments, principal designer terms, framework agreements and collateral warranties often ask you to “ensure” safety or to indemnify the client.
What we checkEvery appointment you did not draft, before you sign it.
What it doesThe policy covers the firm, its principals and employees. Self-employed people usually count only while under your direct control and supervision. Some wordings exclude claims where you have restricted your rights against a third party.
For a health and safety consultantAssociates who deliver audits or training in your name create claims against you. Insurers may then look to the associate, unless your terms with them have given that right away.
What we checkHow associates are defined, whether they carry their own PI, and any caps or waivers in your terms with them.
What it doesRequires notice as soon as reasonably possible of a claim, a threatened claim or a circumstance, which can include a shortcoming in your work that the client does not yet know about.
For a health and safety consultantAn accident at a client’s site, an HSE visit, a notice that refers to your documents or your own discovery of an error can each need notifying.
What we checkThe definition of a circumstance, the time limits, and what late notice costs you.
What it doesClaims arising from one originating cause or source are treated as one claim with one limit. Some wordings apply the excess to each claimant.
For a health and safety consultantA template, course or measurement method used for many clients could mean one limit for everything, while one accident with several injured people could mean several excesses.
What we checkBoth clauses, read together with whether the limit is aggregate or any one claim.
What it doesPaid in addition to the limit under many wordings, but reduced in proportion if the claim itself exceeds the limit. Added covers such as asbestos may include costs within their limit.
For a health and safety consultantInjury claims carry heavy costs on both sides. If a serious injury claim exceeds a modest limit, part of your own defence costs can fall back on you.
What we checkCosts in addition or inclusive, section by section.
What it doesExcludes fines, penalties and punitive sums, and claims for the return of your fees.
For a health and safety consultantA client demanding its fine back, an HSE fee for intervention invoice and a refund of your retainer are each treated differently from compensation for loss.
What we checkHow each head of a client’s claim would be treated, and what remains covered.
Law and duties
[2016] UKSC 6
A suitable and sufficient risk assessment comes first. The court judged the employer’s precautions by examining it, and accepted expert evidence from a consultant with health and safety experience.
[2019] EWCA Civ 711
A noise risk assessment that did not address the level, type and duration of exposure, and was not reviewed as conditions changed, counted against the employer.
[2019] EWCA Crim 520
Legionella outbreak. Subcontracting water treatment to a reputable specialist did not answer the dutyholder’s own failure to oversee it or to have a written scheme.
[2017] EWCA Crim 2186
Turnover sets the starting point for a health and safety fine, and a very large organisation can be taken outside the guideline’s ranges.
[2011] UKSC 13
Expert witnesses no longer have immunity from a negligence claim by the client who instructed them. Relevant to accident investigation and expert work.
[2010] EWCA Civ 1472
A competition case: a penalty imposed on a company for its own breach could not be recovered from the directors and employees whose conduct caused it.
These decisions explain where a professional’s duty lies. They do not decide whether a particular policy responds.
Specialist work
A label such as “general health and safety consultancy” leaves insurers guessing. These are the areas where we ask most, starting with two that have changed fast: fire risk assessment, and principal designer roles under two sets of regulations.
Fire risk assessment is often offered as a sideline, but insurers treat it as a separate risk. For buildings with two or more sets of domestic premises, the Fire Safety Order now covers the structure, the external walls and anything attached to them, and the doors between flats and common parts (Fire Safety Act 2021, section 1). An assessment of such a block that is silent on the external walls needs a clear reason.
The Order’s duties fall on the responsible person and on anyone else with a degree of control, and a person whose act or default causes another’s offence can be prosecuted for it (article 5, article 32). Section 156(4) of the Building Safety Act 2022 adds a duty not to appoint anyone to help with an assessment unless they are competent, though the commencement notes on legislation.gov.uk show no date yet for that subsection (section 156).
We ask what types of assessment you do, which building types and heights, who signs them off, and what your reports say about external walls. Fire safety exclusions and reduced limits are common, so we read that clause first.
Three different roles hide behind one label. Under CDM 2015 the principal designer plans, manages, monitors and coordinates health and safety in the pre-construction phase (CDM 2015, regulation 11). In England the Building Regulations 2010 now have their own principal designer, who must plan, manage and monitor the design work and take all reasonable steps so that the design, if built, would comply with building regulations, and who must be competent for that role (Building Regulations 2010, Part 2A). Government guidance says the two roles have different purposes and competence requirements, though one person can hold both if the client confirms it in writing (GOV.UK, design and building work).
CDM 2015 names no “CDM adviser”. If you advise a client or a designer who holds the statutory role, your liability comes from your contract and from negligence, so the scope in your appointment matters more than the job title.
We ask which role you hold on each project, whether you ever take the building regulations role, the project types and values, and what the appointment says. A health and safety wording may not treat building regulations compliance as your professional business unless declared.
A fixed annual fee for “competent person” support can mean a helpline and one visit a year, or it can mean you write every risk assessment and policy. The law leaves the duty with the employer (regulation 7), so a claim against you turns on scope: what you agreed to review, how often you visit, and what happens to recommendations the client ignores.
We ask how many retained clients you have, their trades, the highest hazard sites, how visits and actions are recorded, and whether your terms say plainly what is outside the service. IOSH’s guidance to consultants makes the same point: if a complaint becomes a claim, insurers are likely to prefer that the scope of your involvement was clearly documented (IOSH, consultancy good practice guide).
The duty to manage asbestos in non-domestic premises rests on the dutyholder, who must make sure a suitable and sufficient assessment is carried out of whether asbestos is or is liable to be present (Control of Asbestos Regulations 2012, regulation 4). HSE strongly recommends accredited surveying organisations, and says UKAS is the sole recognised accreditation body in Great Britain for asbestos inspection bodies (HSE, arrange an asbestos survey).
Standard health and safety wordings often exclude asbestos work beyond general advice on a client’s duties. We ask whether you survey, sample, analyse or monitor, under what accreditation, how report caveats are written and what share of fees it represents. Then we check the endorsement, its limit and whether it has been continuous, because exposure claims can arrive many years later.
Noise, vibration, dust, fume and water hygiene work is measured against numbers, so an error is easy to prove later. In Goldscheider a noise assessment that did not address the level, type and duration of exposure counted against the employer. In Faltec a dutyholder was fined after a legionella outbreak although it used a reputable water treatment specialist. A client in that position may look to its specialist next.
BOHS expects consultancies to hold PI and to have reports reviewed and quality checked (BOHS, Good Practice Guide for Consultants). We ask who does the site work, who authorises reports, how instruments are calibrated, and how pollution, contamination and biological agent exclusions read against these services. An injury claim can be brought within three years of the injured person’s date of knowledge (Limitation Act 1980, section 11), so disease claims may follow long after the survey.
Employers must give employees adequate health and safety training on recruitment and when risks change (Management Regulations 1999, regulation 13). When a trained employee is later hurt, the adequacy of the course, the assessment and the certificate can all be questioned.
We ask which courses are accredited and by whom, which are your own material, whether practical skills are assessed, whether the trainers are employees or associates, and how attendance and assessment records are kept. Some policies treat training as a separate activity that has to be declared. Practical training, such as plant or work at height, also raises the question of injury during the course itself, which is usually a public liability question and not a PI one.
Investigating a client’s accident puts your report in front of its insurers, its lawyers and possibly HSE. If you also wrote the risk assessment now under scrutiny, you have a conflict to manage and a circumstance to notify. Acting as an expert carries its own exposure: since Jones v Kaney an expert can be sued in negligence by the client who instructed them.
We ask how often you do this work, for whom, whether you are instructed by solicitors or directly, and whether the wording’s definition of professional business includes expert witness services. We also check the cover for representation at inquests and inquiries.
Many consultancies deliver work through self-employed associates and send samples to outside laboratories. The client’s claim comes to the name on the report. Policies usually cover people under your direct control and supervision, while an independent associate may need their own PI, and insurers may look to recover from them after paying a claim.
We ask how many associates you use, for which services, what checks you make on their competence and insurance, and what your terms with them say. IOSH’s guidance tells consultants who collaborate with another consultant to make sure they are competent and fully insured, and to tell the client (IOSH, consultancy good practice guide). Freelancers and sub-consultants
HSE charges a fee for intervention where an inspector finds a material breach and writes to the dutyholder (HSE, fee for intervention). The rate is £188 an hour (HSE rates, updated 1 April 2026). Fines follow the Sentencing Council guideline and start from turnover (Sentencing Council). PI wordings exclude fines and penalties. What many do offer is a limited extension for the legal costs of defending a health and safety prosecution, with insurers’ consent.
When a client claims its own fine, fees and legal costs from you as damages, each head is treated differently. In Safeway v Twigger the Court of Appeal refused to let a company pass a penalty for its own breach to the individuals responsible. We check the criminal defence extension’s limit and triggers, and we want to hear about any HSE contact, yours or a client’s, straight away.
Your presentation
An unexplained label can make a modest exposure look broader than it is, while a vague one can hide an important responsibility. Here is how we turn brief answers into a picture insurers can underwrite properly.
| What insurers often see | What we send instead |
|---|---|
| “General health and safety consultancy.” | The split between retained services, risk assessments, audits, CDM, fire, asbestos, hygiene surveys and training, with the fees for each. |
| “We do a few fire risk assessments.” | How many, which building types and heights, the type of assessment, who signs them off and what the reports say about external walls. |
| “CDM work.” | Whether you are principal designer or adviser to a client or designer, the project values, and whether you take the building regulations role. |
| “No asbestos work.” | Whether that also rules out management surveys, sampling and awareness training, and what your reports say when you suspect asbestos. |
| “We use associates.” | How many, for which services, their qualifications, whether each holds PI, and who reviews their reports before issue. |
| “No claims.” | Client accidents, HSE visits or notices involving your documents, complaints and known errors, each with its status and what insurers were told. |
Illustrations of common answers, not statements about particular clients.
Consultancy changes
Tell us before the first job, not at renewal. A new service may be outside the business description, or caught by an exclusion, until insurers agree to add it.
Holding a statutory dutyholder role is different from advising one. Send us the appointment, and say whether it covers CDM, building regulations or both.
Make sure the new company’s policy covers the work you did as a sole trader, with the same retroactive date, or keep the old policy in run off.
Check who counts as insured under the wording, whether associates need their own PI, and what your terms with them say about liability.
Notify the outgoing insurer of every known incident and error first, disclose them to the new insurer, and carry the retroactive date and any asbestos or fire cover across unchanged.
Injury and disease claims can arrive long after the work. Arrange run off before the policy lapses, and keep reports, data and calibration records where you can reach them.
No body sets a period for this profession. APS expects members to maintain run off cover as appropriate (APS), and IOSH advises members who stop consulting to consider it (IOSH guide). A fixed number of years rarely fits, because an injury claim can be brought within three years of the injured person’s date of knowledge (Limitation Act 1980, section 11), which for noise, vibration, dust or asbestos work may be much later. We look at the work you did and plan run off around it. Run off cover explained
Alongside your PI
PI answers claims about your professional advice. It is not built for an injury you cause physically on a site visit, or for every legal cost a small consultancy can face. Consultants work on other people’s premises and under the eye of regulators, so we recommend considering public liability and legal expenses cover alongside it.
Tap a situation for the explanation. A general guide only: the answer always depends on the actual wordings.
Injury or damage caused by what you physically do on site, not by your advice, is a public liability matter. Many PI wordings exclude injury unless it flows from a breach of professional duty.
Injury caused by negligent advice is what a consultant’s PI should answer. Many public liability policies exclude advice given for a fee, though some give limited cover. The two wordings need reading together, which is why we ask to see both.
Many PI wordings include a limited extension for defending a health and safety prosecution arising from professional work. Public liability and legal expenses policies can include prosecution defence for their own subject matter. None of them pays a fine.
If the injury came from how the session was run or the equipment used, public liability is the natural home. If the allegation is that the course content was wrong, PI may respond. Injury to your own employees is an employers’ liability matter.
Pursuing unpaid fees is outside PI, which also usually excludes claims for the return of fees. Commercial legal expenses cover can fund this kind of dispute, subject to its terms and to reasonable prospects of success.
Built for itMay respondNot built for it
Public liability covers your legal liability for injury to other people and damage to their property arising from your business activities: the visit, the survey, the training day. For a consultant the important part is where it joins PI.
BOHS expects occupational hygiene consultancies to hold public liability as well as PI (BOHS). If you employ anyone, employers’ liability insurance of at least £5 million is usually a legal requirement (GOV.UK, employers’ liability insurance).
Commercial legal expenses insurance pays legal costs in defined types of dispute. For a consultancy the sections that usually matter most are:
These policies pay costs, not fines, and normally need reasonable prospects of success and the insurer’s consent before costs are incurred. We read them next to the PI wording so the two neither overlap nor leave a gap. The other covers we arrange
Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.
Proposal form
Ask us for the appropriate proposal form, or send us your details when you request a quote.
This form is not available to download at the moment. Call 0333 222 4257 or email [email protected] and we will send it to you.
Beyond the policy
If you receive a complaint or become aware of something that could lead to a claim, email [email protected], or call 0333 222 4257 if it is urgent or sensitive. We report the matter, follow up with the insurer and explain updates. If a deadline is near, follow the notification instructions in your policy immediately. Do not admit liability before speaking to us.
Before you sign, send us the client’s appointment, principal designer terms, framework agreement, collateral warranty or associate agreement you have been asked to accept, with a short description of the work and any indemnity, “ensure” wording or insurance clause highlighted. We can flag insurance points to discuss with you and, where needed, your insurer. Your solicitor can advise on the legal effect. A review cannot guarantee cover for a claim.
Review your cover
Send us your current schedules, wordings, endorsements and renewal information. Tell us about fire, asbestos, CDM and training work, your associates, and any client incident or HSE contact. We will tell you where the cover fits your consultancy, where it does not, and what we would change.