We would like to set optional cookies to understand how the site is used. Essential cookies keep forms working. Cookie policy.

Home / Insights / Binding authorities: when the insurer, not the client, claims against you

Insights for insurance brokers

Binding authorities: when the insurer, not the client, claims against you

Under a binding authority you are the insurer’s agent. Step outside it and the claim comes from the insurer, a claimant your PI wording may treat very differently from a client. For brokers, coverholders and managing general agents, a few clauses decide the outcome.

Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.

A binder changes whose agent you are

When you place a risk for a client, you act for the client. When you bind cover, issue documents or settle claims under a binding authority, you act for the insurer. The FCA’s client money rules reflect that: premium you hold is treated as received by the insurer only where a written agreement provides for it (FCA Handbook, CASS 5.2.3R). At Lloyd’s, a coverholder is sponsored by a Lloyd’s broker and a managing agent and signs a coverholder undertaking (Lloyd’s, coverholders).

One firm can hold both roles in the same transaction: adviser to the client and agent of the insurer. If you arranged the policy for the client and intend to act for the insurer on claims, the FCA expects you to consider the conflict and tell the client (FCA Handbook, ICOBS 8.3). For your PI, two roles mean two sets of duties and two possible claimants.

How binder breaches happen

Few breaches are deliberate. Most come from a system or a habit, and surface at the insurer’s audit or after a large loss. The typical routes are:

  • a risk outside the class, territory, trade or construction the authority allows;
  • a sum insured or limit above the authority, or several risks that together exceed it;
  • terms, rates or wordings the insurer did not approve;
  • a referral that should have been made and was not;
  • a claim settled above, or outside, the claims authority;
  • bordereaux that are late or misreport what was bound;
  • business written after the authority expired or before its renewal was signed.

Take a typical case. A rating system lets a handler bind a property with a construction the binder excludes. Nobody notices until it burns. The insurer pays its policyholder, then writes to recover the payment from you.

The clauses that decide a binder claim

PI wordings for intermediaries deal with delegated authority in several places. These four need reading together, against each authority you hold.

Clauses in an intermediary’s PI wording that decide a binding authority claim
ClauseWhat it can sayWhy it matters
Declared authoritiesCover for work under a binding or delegated authority applies only to authorities declared to insurers.An undeclared binder, or one added during the year, can mean no cover for the work done under it.
Claims brought by insurersSome wordings will not respond to a claim brought by an insurer unless the insurer has first obtained a court judgment against you.A sensible early settlement, or a repayment plan agreed to protect the relationship, may fall outside the cover unless your PI insurers have agreed the route.
Intentional breachWordings can exclude an intentional breach of a binder while covering a negligent one.How the error happened decides the claim: a system that allowed it, missing referral rules, one person’s mistake or a decision to carry on regardless.
Underwriting agency workWider work as an underwriting agent or managing general agent is commonly excluded, as are your own underwriting losses.A firm whose main business is underwriting for insurers generally needs a wording written for that work.

The first and third turn on facts you control. The second is easy to miss, because it works against a broker’s commercial instinct to settle quickly and keep the account.

What the binding authority agreement makes you promise

The agreement itself can widen the gap. Binding authority agreements and terms of business with insurers often contain indemnities, hold harmless clauses and limits on what you can recover from others. PI wordings usually exclude liability you take on by contract beyond what the law would impose, and claims where you have agreed to restrict your rights of recovery.

So an indemnity for “any loss arising from a breach of this agreement” may promise the insurer more than your policy will pay. Send us the agreement before you sign it. Our contract review flags the insurance points, and the clause guide explains the common terms.

Money is the other promise. PI covers your liability for loss of money you hold for others. It does not usually replace money taken from the firm itself, which is a matter for crime cover.

When the binder is the business: managing general agents

A broker with one or two binders and a managing general agent sit at different ends of the same scale. For an MGA, pricing, wording, binding and often claims are the whole business, and a PI wording written for brokers may exclude most of it.

The FCA’s product rules draw the same line. Since 9 December 2025, firms that manufacture a product together may appoint a single lead firm for the product governance work, but that lead must be an insurer or a Lloyd’s managing agent, not a managing general agent (FCA, PS25/21).

For each authority we set out the class, the income, the underwriting and claims limits, the referral rules and the date and findings of the last audit. Insurers judge delegated authority work on that detail.

If the insurer writes to recover its loss

  1. Send us the letter with the binding authority, your declaration of it at renewal and the underwriting file. We notify your PI insurers at once.
  2. Do not agree a repayment, a set off against commission or any admission.
  3. Read the clause on claims by insurers before you reply. If a judgment is a precondition of cover, your PI insurers need to agree how the claim is handled.
  4. Establish how the error happened, and whether anyone knew the risk was outside the authority.
  5. Run the bordereaux for other risks outside the binder. We notify them as circumstances before the insurer’s audit finds them.
  6. Keep trading relations going through the insurer’s delegated authority team, without admitting liability.

Signing or renewing a binding authority?

Send us the agreement first and we will check it against your PI wording before the first risk is bound.

Speak to a PI specialistPI for insurance brokers

Related: PI for insurance brokers · Contract reviews · The clause guide