We would like to set optional cookies to understand how the site is used. Essential cookies keep forms working. Cookie policy.

Home / Who we cover / Insurance brokers

Insurance brokers

Professional indemnity for insurance brokers

Brokers’ own PI, read clause by clause by specialists in professional indemnity since 1990. We know where claims against intermediaries start, what the FCA’s MIPRU rules require, and how binders, appointed representatives and client money change the wording you need.

Speak to a PI specialistSend us your renewal for reviewGet a quote

  • Since 1990Specialist PI brokers
  • 30+ insurersPlus specialist agencies and Lloyd’s
  • 4.9 out of 5From 228 Google reviews
  • FCA authorisedFRN 302911, independently owned

Our experience

Why insurance brokers come to a specialist

Two brokers with the same income can carry very different risks. Commercial property and business interruption, liability, motor fleets, schemes, personal lines sold online, wholesale placing, binding authorities, delegated claims handling and a network of appointed representatives each bring their own duties, and their own way of going wrong.

Hammond PI has specialised in professional indemnity since 1990. We are FCA authorised brokers ourselves, so we know this work from the inside. We read how each insurer defines your business, treats binders, appointed representatives, client money and claims brought by insurers, and aggregates linked claims. Then we present your firm to more than 30 insurers, specialist agencies and Lloyd’s as it really trades.

When a client’s insurer declines a claim and the client turns to you, we stay involved. We help you notify in time, put the facts to your insurers and follow the matter through with the claims handler.

  1. The workAdvising, placing, renewing, binding, handling claims and holding client money, in the proportions you really do them
  2. What can go wrongCover not arranged, terms not explained, sums insured too low, notifications missed, binders exceeded
  3. What the policy must answerBusiness definition, MIPRU limits and excess, appointed representatives, binders, Ombudsman awards, aggregation and past work
  4. How we present itIncome split, security policy, binder audits, complaints record and controls, set out clearly for insurers

Your regulator

Check the minimum the FCA requires

The FCA sets the PI minimum for insurance intermediaries in MIPRU 3.2. It is written in euros, tied to annual income, and caps your excess. We set out the rule as the Handbook showed it on 20 November 2026, with a link to the rule.

PI requirements: Your regulator
WhoMinimum coverExcessAfter you stopOther conditions
Financial Conduct Authority, MIPRU 3.2 (insurance intermediaries)For a single claim, €1,300,380. In aggregate, the higher of €1,924,560 and 10% of annual income, with the 10% figure capped at £30 million (MIPRU 3.2.7R). A policy in any other currency must be at least equivalent when it is effected and at each renewal (MIPRU 3.2.8R). Basis: both: a minimum for a single claim and a minimum in aggregate for the year.No more than the higher of £2,500 and 1.5% of annual income if you hold no client money or client assets, or the higher of £5,000 and 3% of annual income if you do (MIPRU 3.2.11R and 3.2.12R). A higher excess is allowed only if you hold the additional capital set out in the tables at MIPRU 3.2.14R.MIPRU 3.2 sets no run off period. The policy must give continuous cover for claims arising from work carried out since the firm was given permission for the activity (MIPRU 3.2.4R(5)).The insurer must be authorised for PI in the UK, or be of equivalent status in a Zone A country, the Channel Islands, Gibraltar, Bermuda or the Isle of Man. The policy must cover the firm, its employees and its appointed representatives acting within their appointment, appropriate legal defence costs and Ombudsman awards. A policy covering several firms must be sized on their combined annual income. A comparable guarantee from an authorised person with net tangible assets above £10 million can stand in place of insurance (MIPRU 3.1.1R(3)).
Financial Conduct Authority, IPRU-INV 13 (personal investment firms that also distribute insurance)MIPRU 3 does not apply to a personal investment firm that must hold PI under IPRU-INV 13.1.5R(1). If that firm is also an insurance intermediary its minimum is no lower than €1,300,380 for a single claim and €1,924,560 in the aggregate (IPRU-INV 13.1.10R). Basis: both: a single claim minimum and an aggregate minimum.Not summarised here. IPRU-INV 13.1 has its own provisions, which we check against your schedule.Not summarised here.The policy must cover claims arising from acts or omissions of the firm and of anyone acting for it, including employees, appointed representatives and other agents (IPRU-INV 13.1.9R). A policy that is not in euros must be at least equivalent when it is effected and at renewal (IPRU-INV 13.1.15R).

Sources: FCA MIPRU (Handbook as viewed 20 November 2026; MIPRU 3.2.7R last amended 1 August 2021), FCA IPRU-INV (Handbook as viewed 20 November 2026; IPRU-INV 13.1.10R dated 1 January 2022). Firms answering to more than one must meet each set of rules.

A minimum is not a recommendation. Many firms need more, and cover for each and every claim can protect better than an aggregate limit.

Why the minimum is rarely the right limit

The minimum is set for every intermediary in the market, whatever it places. One underinsured commercial property or business interruption loss can exceed it, and the aggregate minimum can be used up by a single claim, leaving nothing for the rest of the year. Your limit should follow the largest sums insured you place, the number of clients one error or one failed insurer could reach, and whether defence costs sit inside the limit.

Claim scenarios

When a claim arrives: how we would handle it

Situations insurance brokers face, the risk hidden in each, and the strategy we would follow from the first letter. Choose a scenario.

A business interruption claim is cut by average and the client blames you

The situationA manufacturing client has a serious fire. Its insurer finds the business interruption sum insured was a quarter too low and reduces the claim by average. The client’s solicitors say you never explained how insurers define gross profit or what the indemnity period meant, and claim the shortfall from your firm.

The riskWriting back to defend your advice, or offering to put it right. Either can breach the no admissions condition. The second trap is the renewal file: if the same guidance note went to every commercial client, this is not one problem, and insurers will ask who else is underinsured.

Our strategy

  1. Notify your PI insurers at once as a claim, with the client’s letter, the renewal reports for each year and the note of every conversation about sums insured.
  2. Make no admission, and send nothing to the client’s solicitors until insurers have agreed the response.
  3. Gather what the cases turn on: what you explained about gross profit and the indemnity period, who calculated the figure, and whether declaration linked cover was offered.
  4. Raise the client’s own part early. Where the client chose the figure after proper advice, or guessed at growth, contributory fault can reduce the claim.
  5. Review other clients given the same guidance and notify the wider problem as a circumstance, so that later claims attach to this policy year.

What we aim forA funded defence built on your file, the client’s own contribution properly argued, and any similar claims protected by one early notification.

The lessonExplaining the sum insured is the broker’s job. Keep the proof that you did it.

The insurer avoids for non-disclosure and the client says you never asked

The situationAfter a large theft, a client’s insurer avoids the policy because earlier losses and a director’s insolvency history were not disclosed. The client says nobody at your firm explained what a fair presentation needed, and that a new finance manager simply signed the renewal declaration you sent.

The riskRelying only on the standard warning the client signed. Courts have held that a written warning alone may not be enough if nobody checked the client understood it. The stronger ground is often causation: what the insurer would have done had it been told.

Our strategy

  1. Notify PI insurers as soon as the avoidance letter is copied to you, before any complaint arrives. A client’s declined claim is usually a circumstance under your own policy.
  2. Assemble the evidence of advice: the fair presentation explanation, who received it, the questions asked at each renewal, and what your own staff already knew about the client.
  3. Have panel solicitors test the avoidance itself. If the insurer’s proper remedy under the Insurance Act 2015 is proportionate, not avoidance, the client’s loss and your exposure both shrink.
  4. Build the counterfactual: with full disclosure, would this insurer or another have written the risk, on what terms and at what premium?
  5. Agree with insurers whether your firm should support the client’s challenge to its insurer, and on what footing, before anyone writes.

What we aim forThe avoidance tested first, your firm’s exposure limited to what full disclosure would really have changed, and no breach of your own policy conditions.

The lessonA declined client claim is your circumstance too. Notify it before the client complains.

Your handler sat on a client’s claim and the insurer declines it as late

The situationA client emails a liability claim to an account handler who is on leave. Nobody forwards it for seven weeks. The insurer declines for breach of a notification condition. The client faces a six figure injury claim uninsured and holds your firm responsible.

The riskTreating it as one error and missing two more questions. Was there another policy that should also have been notified, such as an excess layer or a second liability policy? And is the same inbox holding other clients’ unreported claims?

Our strategy

  1. Notify your PI insurers the day you find it, stating plainly what was received, when, and when it reached the client’s insurer.
  2. Notify every policy of the client’s that could respond, late or not. One recent decision concerned a broker that advised its client to notify only one of three policies.
  3. Ask insurers to agree that pressing the client’s insurer to reconsider is mitigation: was the condition a true condition precedent, and was the insurer prejudiced at all?
  4. Search the handler’s inbox and the shared mailbox for other unreported claims, and notify any you find as circumstances.
  5. Keep the client informed in wording your insurers have approved, so that reassurance does not become an admission.

What we aim forThe client’s insurer brought back to the table where the law allows, your own cover protected, and no second late notification of your own.

The lessonA broker’s late notification creates two notification problems. Deal with your own the same day.

A survey condition nobody explained gives the insurer a defence

The situationAfter a survey, a property owner’s insurer emails your firm a risk requirement: remove portable heaters from the tenanted units. The email is filed, not passed on. A fire follows. The insurer relies on the survey condition and offers 60% of the loss.

The riskAdvising the client to reject the offer and fight, or to accept it quickly. Either choice is yours to answer for later. Whether your insurers pay the shortfall may depend on whether the client’s settlement was reasonable and reached with their knowledge.

Our strategy

  1. Notify PI insurers before the client decides anything about the offer, and send the survey email, the endorsement and your file.
  2. Have the client take its own coverage advice. Under the Insurance Act 2015 a breach of a term may not help the insurer if it could not have increased the risk of this loss.
  3. Involve your insurers in the client’s negotiation with its insurer. A settlement they have followed is far easier to treat as reasonable later.
  4. Preserve the evidence on what the client would have done if told: would the heaters really have gone before the fire?

What we aim forThe best available settlement from the client’s insurer, and any shortfall claim against you measured against a settlement your insurers accept as reasonable.

The lessonEvery insurer requirement that reaches you must reach the client in writing, with its consequence explained.

Your appointed representative sold cover outside its agreement

The situationAn appointed representative you authorised for personal lines has been arranging commercial combined policies for local traders through an unrated overseas insurer. The insurer stops paying claims. Twenty customers complain to your firm as principal.

The riskAssuming it is automatically your liability and your policy’s problem. A principal answers for the business it accepted responsibility for in writing, and wordings can exclude representative activity that was undisclosed or outside the appointment. Both points need care before anything is conceded.

Our strategy

  1. Notify PI insurers of all twenty complaints together as one circumstance, with a schedule of every customer, including those yet to complain.
  2. Send insurers the appointed representative agreement and what you declared about the representative at renewal, so the scope question is addressed from the start.
  3. Answer each complaint on time, but in terms your insurers have seen. Do not concede responsibility in a holding letter.
  4. Check the excess and aggregation wording. The limit may be shared across all linked claims while an excess applies to each claimant.
  5. Tell the FCA what it would expect to know, suspend the representative’s activity, and record the oversight you carried out.

What we aim forResponsibility decided on the written scope, insurers engaged before any redress is offered, and one notification protecting the firm against every linked complaint.

The lessonDeclare every appointed representative and what it may sell. Undeclared activity can sit outside your cover.

A risk bound outside your binding authority, and the insurer wants its money back

The situationUnder a binding authority your team binds a timber framed block of flats, a construction the binder excludes. A fire destroys it. The insurer pays the claim, then writes to say it will recover the payment from your firm.

The riskNegotiating with the insurer to protect the relationship. Some PI wordings exclude claims brought by insurers unless there is a court judgment, and exclude intentional breaches of a binder. A repayment plan agreed without your PI insurers can leave you with no cover at all.

Our strategy

  1. Notify PI insurers immediately and send the binding authority, your declaration of it at renewal and the underwriting file for the risk.
  2. Read the wording on claims by insurers before replying. If a judgment is a precondition of cover, your PI insurers need to agree how the claim is handled.
  3. Establish how the error happened: a rating system that allowed it, missing referral rules or one underwriter’s mistake. An intentional breach may be excluded where a negligent one is not.
  4. Run the bordereaux for other risks outside the binder and notify them as circumstances before the insurer’s audit finds them.
  5. Keep trading relations with the insurer through its delegated authority team, without admitting liability.

What we aim forThe insurer’s recovery claim handled inside your PI policy’s conditions, other out of scope risks notified, and the binder kept if it can be.

The lessonA binder makes you the insurer’s agent. Declare each one, and audit yourself before the insurer does.

An unrated insurer you used for a scheme stops paying claims

The situationYour firm placed a taxi fleet scheme with an unrated overseas insurer. The insurer enters insolvency. Three hundred policyholders need replacement cover today, forty have open claims, and the first letters say you should never have recommended it.

The riskTreating it as an operational crisis and notifying late. PI wordings can exclude or restrict claims arising from an insurer’s insolvency, and one shared limit may be all there is for every policyholder. What clients were told about the insurer’s security decides most of these claims.

Our strategy

  1. Notify PI insurers the day the insolvency is announced, as a single circumstance covering every policyholder on the scheme.
  2. Read any insolvency exclusion and the aggregation clause first. Know whether the cover applies, and whether one limit must serve all the claims.
  3. Pull the evidence: the decision to use the insurer, the financial information reviewed, and the written warning each client received that it was unrated.
  4. Replace the clients’ cover as mitigation, agreed with insurers where the wording provides for it, and check which clients and classes the FSCS may protect.
  5. Use one approved client letter. Three hundred different reassurances from account handlers are three hundred possible admissions.

What we aim forCover confirmed or the gap known on day one, clients reinsured quickly, and a single notification protecting the firm for every claim that follows.

The lessonAn unrated insurer is a decision to record, explain to the client in writing and disclose to your PI insurers.

Illustrative scenarios. How any real claim is handled depends on the facts, the policy wording and insurers’ agreement.

Four things insurance brokers should know about PI

The date of the work and the date of the claim are different

A claim today may concern cover you placed or renewed several years ago. PI is written on a claims made basis: the policy in force when the claim is made responds, provided the work falls after the retroactive date and nothing was already notified under an earlier policy.

Claims made cover: the policy in force when the claim is made is the one that responds.

A valid notification of circumstances can connect a later claim to an earlier policy. That is why continuity matters when you change insurers or stop a particular service. How claims made cover works

The FCA minimum is set in euros, so a sterling limit can fall short

MIPRU 3.2.7R sets €1,300,380 for a single claim and, in aggregate, the higher of €1,924,560 and 10% of annual income. If your policy is in sterling you must take reasonable steps to check it is at least equivalent when the policy is effected and at each renewal (FCA Handbook, MIPRU 3.2). In June 2026 the FCA proposed replacing the euro figures with £1,110,000 and £1,650,000, leaving the 10% test and its £30 million cap unchanged (FCA, CP26/22). On 20 November 2026 the Handbook still showed the euro figures, so we check the sterling equivalent at every renewal.

An Ombudsman award is a claim on your PI, with its own ceiling

The FCA requires a broker’s PI to cover Ombudsman awards (MIPRU 3.2.4R(6)). Consumers, micro-enterprises, small businesses, charities with income under £6.5 million and trusts with net assets under £5 million can all complain (FCA Handbook, DISP 2.7.3R). For complaints referred on or after 1 April 2026 about acts or omissions on or after 1 April 2019, the Financial Ombudsman Service can award up to £455,000 (Financial Ombudsman Service, compensation limits). Wordings can tie the Ombudsman cover to that binding limit, and some list a complaint not resolved within a few working days as a circumstance to notify.

How your limit of indemnity works

Two unrelated covered claims of £750,000 each come to £1.5 million. Under a £1 million limit in the aggregate, the policy pays up to £1 million for the year in total. Under a £1 million limit for each and every claim, each claim has its own £1 million, subject to the policy’s aggregation wording and other terms.

The same two claims under an aggregate limit and an each and every claim limit.

Then check whether defence costs are paid in addition to the limit or use it up, and when the excess applies.

Inside the wording

Twelve clauses that decide insurance brokers’ claims

Two policies with the same limit can answer the same claim very differently. These are the clauses we read first, what each means for an insurance broker and what we check.

Insuring clause and “business”

What it doesCovers civil liability arising from your business as the policy defines it, often the activities normally expected of an insurance broker, agent or consultant for which you hold FCA permission.

For an insurance brokerClaims handling for policyholders, premium finance, risk management advice, scheme administration or managing general agent work may sit outside “normally expected” unless it is described and agreed.

What we checkThe definition against every activity and permission you have, and any work done without a matching permission, which wordings can exclude outright.

Limit of liability and the FCA minimum

What it doesStates the limit and whether it applies to any one claim or in aggregate. Some wordings lift it automatically to the sterling equivalent of the FCA’s euro minimum.

For an insurance brokerGeneral insurance work may carry an any one claim limit while regulated investment work under the same policy is aggregate and costs inclusive. A broker doing both can have two different limits.

What we checkEach limit against MIPRU 3.2.7R, including the 10% of annual income test, and which basis applies to which part of your income.

Aggregation and the excess

What it doesTreats claims arising from one originating cause or source as one claim with one limit. The excess may be worded differently, for example applying to each claimant.

For an insurance brokerA flawed scheme wording, a failed insurer or one template renewal letter can reach hundreds of clients. One limit may have to serve all of them, while an excess is paid for each.

What we checkThe aggregation words and the excess words side by side, and the excess against the FCA cap in MIPRU 3.2.11R or 3.2.12R.

Notification and circumstances

What it doesRequires written notice as soon as reasonably possible of a claim, an intimation of one, or a circumstance, whatever your own view on liability. Notice given too long after expiry may be shut out.

For an insurance brokerA client’s declined claim, a complaint you cannot resolve within days, a discovered error or a suspicion of staff dishonesty can each be a circumstance, long before any letter of claim.

What we checkWhat the wording lists as a circumstance, the cut off after expiry, and whether late notice bars cover or only reduces it for prejudice.

Defence costs

What it doesPays the legal costs of defending a claim, with insurers’ prior consent. They may be in addition to the limit for some business and inside it for other business.

For an insurance brokerBroker claims are often fought on causation, with underwriting experts on both sides, which is costly. If costs erode the limit, less is left for the claim itself.

What we checkIn addition or inclusive for each type of business, how costs are shared if the claim exceeds the limit, and whether the excess applies to costs.

Ombudsman awards and regulatory costs

What it doesCovers binding Ombudsman awards, often up to the Ombudsman’s own limit, and the cost of representation in a regulatory investigation, usually with a separate aggregate sub-limit.

For an insurance brokerThe FCA requires cover for Ombudsman awards. Investigation costs matter after a client money breach or an appointed representative failure. Fines and penalties are usually excluded.

What we checkThat the award cover tracks the current Ombudsman limit, the size of the investigation costs sub-limit, and which regulators’ proceedings count.

Appointed representatives

What it doesIncludes appointed representatives as insureds, usually only those declared to insurers, and can exclude activity that is undisclosed, outside the appointment or not notified to the regulator.

For an insurance brokerMIPRU requires your policy to cover representatives acting within their appointment. Disputes are usually about one acting outside it, where your responsibility and your cover may both be in question.

What we checkEvery representative named, mid-year appointments agreed before they start, and how the exclusion reads against the scope in each agreement.

Binding authorities and underwriting

What it doesCovers claims from operating a binding or delegated authority that has been declared to insurers. Wider work as an underwriting agent or managing general agent is commonly excluded, as are your own underwriting losses.

For an insurance brokerAn undeclared binder can mean no cover for the work done under it. Delegated claims authority and scheme underwriting need the same declaration.

What we checkEach binder declared with its class, limits and claims authority, the wording on intentional breach, and whether a separate wording for underwriting agencies is needed.

Claims by insurers

What it doesSome wordings will not respond to a claim brought by an insurer unless the insurer has first obtained a court judgment against you.

For an insurance brokerInsurers claim against brokers for binder breaches, misdescribed risks and unpaid premium. This clause can stop a sensible early settlement being covered unless your PI insurers agree the route.

What we checkWhether the clause is there, what it requires before insurers will pay, and that your terms of business with insurers do not promise more than the policy supports.

Dishonesty, client money and fidelity

What it doesCovers your liability to others for staff dishonesty and for loss of client money, but never the dishonest person, and not usually the firm’s own loss unless a small fidelity extension is included.

For an insurance brokerA handler who diverts premiums creates two losses: money owed to clients or insurers, and your own. Wordings can also exclude failure to account for money on your own insolvency.

What we checkWhose dishonesty is covered, any fidelity extension and its limit, and how the clause fits with any crime cover you hold.

Contracts and rights of recovery

What it doesExcludes liability you take on by contract beyond what the law would impose, and claims where you have agreed to restrict your rights of recovery against someone else.

For an insurance brokerTerms of business with insurers, wholesalers and networks often contain indemnities, hold harmless clauses and liability caps. Signing them can remove cover for the very claim they deal with.

What we checkEvery agreement with an indemnity or a cap in it, before you sign, against these two exclusions.

Retroactive date, known matters and non-disclosure

What it doesExcludes work before the retroactive date and matters you knew of before inception. Better wordings promise not to avoid for innocent non-disclosure, and adjust the terms instead.

For an insurance brokerThe FCA requires continuous cover for work since you were given permission. A change of insurer or a merger is where the retroactive date moves, or a known matter falls between two policies.

What we checkThe retroactive date against your date of permission, the innocent non-disclosure clause, and what was notified to the outgoing insurer.

The clause guide: how each part of a PI policy works

Law and duties

The duties behind a broker’s claim, and the FCA rules around them

What the law expects of the broker

  • Fair presentation. A commercial client must disclose every material circumstance it knows or ought to know, or enough to put a prudent insurer on enquiry (Insurance Act 2015, section 3). The FCA expects you to explain that duty and its consequences (ICOBS 5.1.4G).
  • Your knowledge counts. The insured is treated as knowing what is known to those responsible for its insurance, which includes its broker’s staff. Confidential information you acquired through another client relationship is excepted (Insurance Act 2015, section 4).
  • Warranties and conditions. A breached warranty suspends cover until it is remedied, and an insurer may not rely on a risk reducing term if the breach could not have increased the risk of the loss that happened (Insurance Act 2015, sections 10 and 11). Clients need them explained.
  • Proportionate remedies. Unless a breach of fair presentation was deliberate or reckless, the insurer’s remedy depends on what it would have done: avoid, apply different terms or reduce the claim in proportion (Insurance Act 2015, Schedule 1). That shapes any claim against the broker.

The FCA rules around the work

  • Best interests and the Consumer Duty. A firm must act honestly, fairly and professionally in accordance with the best interests of its customer (ICOBS 2.5.-1R), and must act to deliver good outcomes for retail customers (PRIN 2.1, Principle 12).
  • Demands and needs. Before a contract is concluded you must specify the customer’s demands and needs, and anything you propose must be consistent with them, whether or not you give advice (ICOBS 5.2).
  • Client money. Money you hold is protected by risk transfer to the insurer under a written agency agreement, by a statutory trust, or by a non-statutory trust that needs an auditor’s confirmation of your controls and, for retail customers, £50,000 of capital (CASS 5.2, CASS 5.4).
  • Appointed representatives. A principal is responsible for what its representative does in the business it accepted responsibility for (FSMA 2000, section 39). The FCA expects a review of each one at least every 12 months (FCA, principals and appointed representatives).

Court decisions behind these points

[2010] EWHC 759 (Comm)

Jones v Environcom Ltd

A broker must explain the duty of disclosure and check the client understands it. Standard written warnings alone may not be enough. The claim still failed on causation.

Read the judgment

[2011] EWHC 124 (Comm)

Ground Gilbey Ltd v Jardine Lloyd Thompson UK Ltd

Brokers who did not pass on an insurer’s risk requirement were liable for the shortfall after the client’s reasonable settlement with its insurer.

Read the judgment

[2023] EWHC 3022 (Comm)

Infinity Reliance Ltd v Heath Crawford Ltd

Misleading guidance on the business interruption sum insured left the client underinsured. The broker was liable for the loss caused by average, less 20% for the client’s own fault.

Read the judgment

[2018] EWHC 2558 (Comm)

Dalamd Ltd v Butterworth Spengler Commercial Ltd

Where the insured has not settled, the court decides on the balance of probabilities whether the insurer could have declined. An arguable defence is not enough.

Read the judgment

[2025] EWCA Civ 58

Norman Hay plc v Marsh Ltd

After a failure to arrange liability cover, the insured need not strictly prove it was liable to the third party. The court asks what the insurer would have done.

Read the judgment

[2025] EWHC 743 (Comm)

Watford Community Housing Trust v Arthur J Gallagher Insurance Brokers Ltd

The broker advised notifying only one of three policies that could respond to a data breach. Its argument that the client had suffered no loss failed.

Read the judgment

These decisions explain where a professional’s duty lies. They do not decide whether a particular policy responds.

Specialist work

The work that changes your cover

A one line description of a brokerage tells insurers very little. These are the areas where we ask most, starting with two that produce claims and regulatory attention now: underinsurance and fair value.

Sums insured and business interruption: who explained the figure?

Sums insured go out of date quickly, and when average is applied the client looks to the broker. The courts do not expect you to calculate a commercial client’s figure, but they do expect you to explain what it has to cover. In one case a broker was not liable because it had explained the insurer’s meaning of gross profit and the indemnity period, and the client supplied the figures (Eurokey Recycling v Giles Insurance Brokers [2014] EWHC 2989 (Comm)). In another the broker’s generic guidance was misleading and it had not recommended declaration linked cover, and it was liable for the reduction caused by average (Infinity Reliance v Heath Crawford [2023] EWHC 3022 (Comm)).

For your PI we look at:

  • what you send clients about buildings, contents and business interruption sums insured, and whether it matches each insurer’s definitions;
  • how indemnity periods and declaration linked options are discussed and recorded;
  • the largest sums insured you place, because they set your realistic worst claim.
Fair value, commission and the product rules: can you show your remuneration is earned?

As a distributor you must understand each product’s value assessment and make sure your own remuneration, and that of anyone else in the chain, does not stop the product giving fair value. That includes packaged add-ons and retail premium finance (FCA Handbook, PROD 4.3). A commercial customer who asks must be told your commission in cash terms, including profit shares, volume payments and premium finance income (ICOBS 4.4).

From 9 December 2025 the FCA let co-manufacturers appoint a single lead firm, which must be an insurer or Lloyd’s managing agent and not a managing general agent, and replaced the fixed 12 month product review with an interval set by risk (FCA, PS25/21).

PI insurers ask about this because a redress exercise reaches many customers at once. Wordings commonly exclude the return of fees, and can exclude improper volume or profit share arrangements, so we check both against how you are paid.

Binding authorities, coverholders and managing general agents

When you bind cover or settle claims for an insurer you act as its agent, and the agreement must say so for the money you hold (CASS 5.2). The exposure changes too: a risk bound outside the authority, a claim paid outside it or a bordereau that misreports can each bring a claim from the insurer, not the client.

We ask for each authority’s class, premium income, underwriting and claims limits, referral rules and last audit. Broker wordings usually cover only authorities that have been declared and exclude wider underwriting agency work, so a firm whose main business is underwriting for insurers generally needs a wording written for managing general agents. Lloyd’s coverholders are sponsored by a Lloyd’s broker and a managing agent and sign a coverholder undertaking (Lloyd’s, coverholders).

Appointed representatives and networks

As principal you answer for your appointed representatives in the business you accepted responsibility for, and the Court of Appeal has held that the written acceptance sets the boundary (Anderson v Sense Network [2019] EWCA Civ 1395). The FCA expects you to assess each representative before appointment, review it at least every 12 months and keep a self-assessment signed off by your governing body (FCA, principals and appointed representatives).

Your annual income for the PI minimum includes amounts due to your representatives (MIPRU 4.3.5R). We present each representative’s activities, income and oversight, because wordings can exclude a representative that was not declared or that acted outside its appointment.

Client money: risk transfer or trust?

Holding client money moves the FCA’s cap on your PI excess from the higher of £2,500 and 1.5% of annual income to the higher of £5,000 and 3% (MIPRU 3.2.11R and 3.2.12R). It also changes the claims you face. Under risk transfer, premium you receive is treated as received by the insurer, but only where a written agreement provides for it (CASS 5.2.3R). Otherwise the money is client money and must be held in a statutory or non-statutory trust (CASS 5.3).

We ask which insurers have granted risk transfer, whether any of that money is mixed with trust money, who does the client money calculation and what your last audit found. PI covers your liability for loss of client money. It does not usually replace money stolen from the firm itself.

Insurer security: unrated and overseas insurers

If an insurer fails, clients ask why it was recommended. The Financial Services Compensation Scheme does not protect every class: marine, aviation, goods in transit and credit insurance are not eligible, and many other general insurance claims are protected at 90%, not in full (FSCS, insurance).

PI insurers want to see a written security policy: the minimum rating you accept, who approves an exception, what financial information you review, and the written warning a client receives when an insurer is unrated. Wordings can exclude or restrict claims arising from an insurer’s insolvency, so we check that point against the markets you actually use.

Handling claims for your clients

If you have no authority to deal with a claim, the FCA expects you to forward the notification to the insurer promptly, or tell the policyholder immediately that you cannot deal with it. If you arranged the policy for the client and intend to act for the insurer on claims, you must consider the conflict and tell the client (ICOBS 8.3).

Late or partial notification is a classic broker claim. We ask how claims arrive, who logs them, how absence is covered, and whether your handlers consider every policy that could respond, not only the obvious one. Claims advocacy for policyholders should also appear in the policy’s description of your business.

Wholesale placing and sub-broker chains

When you place through a wholesaler, or produce business for another broker to place, the client still looks to you. A firm may rely on others, but it cannot delegate its responsibility under the regulatory system (ICOBS 2.5.3G).

We ask who advises the client, who passes information to the insurer, and what each party’s terms of business say. Those terms matter for your PI: an indemnity you give, or a cap on what you can recover from the wholesaler, can engage the contractual liability and loss of recovery exclusions. Send them to us before you sign.

Online, non-advised and scheme sales

Selling without advice does not remove the duty to match the product to the customer. A contract you propose must be consistent with the customer’s demands and needs whether or not advice is given, and every sale must be accompanied by a demands and needs test (ICOBS 5.2). You should also take reasonable steps to ensure a customer only buys a policy under which they are eligible to claim (ICOBS 5.1.1G).

For PI the question is scale. One flawed question set or scheme wording is repeated in every sale, so we look at how question sets are approved and changed, and how the aggregation clause would treat a single flaw across many customers.

Your presentation

A proposal should explain the work behind the numbers

An unexplained label can make a modest exposure look broader than it is, while a vague one can hide an important responsibility. Here is how we turn brief answers into a picture insurers can underwrite properly.

Brief proposal answers and what we send instead
What insurers often seeWhat we send instead
“General insurance broker, commercial and personal lines.”Income by class and client size, advised or non-advised, and how much goes through wholesalers, schemes or online.
“We hold a couple of binders.”Each binding authority: insurer, class, premium, underwriting and claims limits, last audit, and who checks every risk is inside it.
“Two appointed representatives.”Each representative’s activities and income, the written scope you accepted, and your oversight and annual review.
“All client money is risk transfer.”Which insurers have agreed risk transfer in writing, what sits in a statutory or non-statutory trust, and your latest client money audit.
“We only use good security.”Your written security policy, who approves exceptions, the unrated or overseas insurers used, and what clients were told in writing.
“No claims, only a few complaints.”Every complaint, Ombudsman referral and declined client claim, its status, and what was notified to insurers and when.

Illustrations of common answers, not statements about particular clients.

How we handle your renewal

  1. You send what you haveSchedule, wording, endorsements, last proposal and your renewal date.
  2. We find what needs explainingIncome by class, binders, appointed representatives, client money basis, insurer security, complaints and declined client claims.
  3. We approach suited insurersFrom more than 30 insurers, specialist agencies and Lloyd’s, chosen for the work you do.
  4. We compare the wordingsCover, clauses, excess and limits side by side, with the differences explained.

Firm changes

When your firm changes, the insurance needs reviewing

Buying a book or broker

Tell us before completion. Wordings can exclude acts after a takeover or merger unless insurers agree, and you need to settle who insures the seller’s past work and its known complaints.

Appointing a representative

Agree a new appointed representative with insurers before it starts. The FCA expects notice at least 30 days before the appointment, and the representative’s income counts towards your PI minimum.

Leaving a network

A representative that becomes directly authorised needs its own PI from the day of permission. Settle in writing whether the old principal’s policy or your new one answers for past work.

A new binding authority

Declare it before the first risk is bound: insurer, class, limits and any claims authority. Cover for delegated authority work usually depends on that declaration.

Changing insurer

Notify every known complaint, declined client claim and discovered error to the outgoing insurer before expiry, disclose them to the new one, and carry the retroactive date across unchanged.

Sale, retirement or closure

Claims against brokers can arrive years after placement. MIPRU 3.2 sets no run off period for intermediaries, so the length and limit of run off is a decision to plan into the deal.

Run off cover explained

What if we add a new class, scheme or permission during the year?

Tell us before you start. A broker’s PI usually covers the business described to insurers and carried on with the right FCA permission, and wordings can exclude activity without that permission altogether. A new scheme may also bring a binding authority, delegated claims handling or a new insurer, each of which insurers expect to hear about. If your annual income rises, check the aggregate minimum again: it is the higher of €1,924,560 and 10% of annual income (MIPRU 3.2.7R). We ask insurers to confirm the change in writing, so there is no argument later about what was covered.

Alongside your PI

Crime and cyber cover to consider alongside your PI

PI answers claims about your broking. It is not built to replace money stolen from the firm or to get your systems working again, and brokers’ PI wordings commonly exclude cyber attacks and data breaches. Because you hold premiums, claims money and personal data, we recommend considering crime and cyber cover alongside it.

Which policy responds?

Tap a situation for the explanation. A general guide only: the answer always depends on the actual wordings.

SituationPICrimeCyber
A handler diverts client premiums to a personal accountMay respondBuilt for itNot built for it

PI may answer your liability to clients and insurers for the missing money. The firm’s own loss is a crime (fidelity) matter. Some broker PI wordings include a small fidelity extension, with conditions.

A fraudster posing as an insurer gets you to change its bank detailsNot built for itBuilt for itMay respond

Money you are tricked into paying away is a social engineering loss, usually insured under crime and sometimes under cyber, often with a lower sub-limit and call back conditions.

Ransomware locks your broking system in renewal seasonNot built for itNot built for itBuilt for it

Incident response, restoring data and the income lost while you cannot trade are cyber covers. PI does not pay to get you working again.

Client data, including health and conviction details, is stolenNot built for itNot built for itBuilt for it

Brokers’ PI wordings can exclude breaches of data protection law and the cost of notifying those affected. Cyber cover is built for the response, the notifications and the liability claims.

Your hijacked mailbox tells a client to pay its premium to a fraudsterMay respondMay respondMay respond

The client may claim against you, but a PI cyber exclusion may apply. Crime cover depends on whose money moved. This is where the three wordings must be read together.

Built for itMay respondNot built for it

Crime cover explained: staff dishonesty, outside theft and social engineering
  • Employee dishonesty. The firm’s own loss when someone inside takes money, including client money you must make good.
  • Third party crime. Theft by outsiders, such as transfers made by someone who has got into your banking.
  • Social engineering. Payments your own staff are tricked into making. Often a lower sub-limit, conditional on checks such as calling back on a number already held.
  • Whose money. Policies differ on client money held in trust, money held as agent of an insurer under risk transfer, and your own office account. We read the definition against how you hold money under the client money rules (FCA Handbook, CASS 5).
Cyber cover explained: response, recovery and liability
  • Incident response. Forensic and legal help from the first call. A notifiable personal data breach must be reported to the ICO within 72 hours of becoming aware of it (ICO, personal data breaches).
  • Restoration and interruption. Rebuilding systems and data, and the income lost while you cannot quote, bind or renew, including when a software house or cloud provider is down, if the policy covers dependent business interruption.
  • Liability. Claims by clients and others for data breaches, and regulatory investigation costs.

Read the cyber exclusion in your PI first. Where it removes cover for a client’s claim with a cyber cause, the cyber policy’s liability section has to carry it.

The other covers we arrange

Proposal form

Prefer to fill in a form?

Ask us for the appropriate proposal form, or send us your details when you request a quote.

Beyond the policy

Claims support and contract reviews

If you receive a complaint or become aware of something that could lead to a claim, email [email protected], or call 0333 222 4257 if it is urgent or sensitive. We report the matter, follow up with the insurer and explain updates. If a deadline is near, follow the notification instructions in your policy immediately. Do not admit liability before speaking to us.

Before you sign, send us the terms of business agreement, binding authority, appointed representative agreement or liability cap you have been asked to accept, with a short note of the clause that concerns you. Highlight the wording that concerns you. We can flag insurance points to discuss with you and, where needed, your insurer. Your solicitor can advise on the legal effect. A review cannot guarantee cover for a claim.

Claims support  ·  Contract reviews

Review your cover

Let a specialist read your PI cover

Send us your current schedules, wordings, endorsements and renewal information. Tell us about your binders, appointed representatives, client money arrangements, insurer security and any complaints or declined client claims. We will tell you where the cover fits your firm, where it does not, and what we would change.

Speak to a PI specialistSend us your renewalGet a quote

  • Your schedule, policy wording and endorsements
  • Renewal date and your last proposal form
  • Income by class, client type and distribution channel
  • Binding authorities, schemes and any claims authority
  • Appointed representatives and their agreements
  • Complaints, Ombudsman referrals and declined client claims