We would like to set optional cookies to understand how the site is used. Essential cookies keep forms working. Cookie policy.

Home / Insights / “It will come in on budget”: advice, guarantee and an interior designer’s PI

Insights for interior designers

“It will come in on budget”: advice, guarantee and an interior designer’s PI

Clients remember the first figure they hear. When the tenders come back higher, the dispute turns on one question: did you advise on cost with reasonable care, or did you promise a number? A PI policy usually treats the two very differently.

Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.

How a budget claim starts

It usually starts as an argument about fees. The scheme goes to tender, the prices come back well above the figure in the client’s mind, and the client stops paying. A letter follows asking for the fees back and the cost of designing the scheme again.

In Riva Properties v Foster + Partners the court held that a designer must find out whether the client has a budget and take it into account (National Archives, [2017] EWHC 2574 (TCC)). In Freeborn v Marcal a home cinema was built to a design the clients never approved, and the failure to record the brief in writing was itself a breach (National Archives, [2019] EWHC 454 (TCC)).

The codes say the same. BIID members should tell clients without undue delay of anything that could adversely affect the budget (BIID, Code of Conduct, section 4). SBID members must keep the client informed of any issue that may affect quality or cost (SBID, Code of Conduct, clause 3.4).

Reasonable care, or a guaranteed result

The law implies a duty to use reasonable care and skill into a designer’s contract, with consumers (Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 49) and with businesses (Supply of Goods and Services Act 1982, section 13). PI is built around that standard. Wordings usually exclude duties more onerous than reasonable skill and care, including guarantees, express warranties and fitness for purpose promises.

So the same budget can be inside or outside cover, depending on how you put it.

How budget and suitability statements may be read, and the usual PI position
What you said or wroteHow it may be readThe usual PI position
“The scheme will be delivered within your budget of £400,000.”A promise of a resultMay fall within the guarantee exclusion
“Our current estimate is £400,000, excluding VAT, fees and loose furniture. We will check it at each stage.”Cost advice, with its assumptions statedNegligent cost advice is usually what PI is for
“All finishes will be suitable for hotel use.”A fitness for purpose promiseMay go beyond the standard the policy insures
“We will specify finishes with reasonable skill and care for the use described in the brief.”The ordinary professional standardMatches the standard the policy is written for

Why what you said in the pitch can bind you

With a consumer client, the promise does not have to be in the appointment. A contract to supply a service is treated as including anything said or written to the consumer about the service, by you or on your behalf, if the consumer takes it into account when deciding to appoint you or when making a later decision about the service (Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 50).

The same section gives the answer. A statement is subject to anything that qualified it and was said or written on the same occasion. An estimate given with its assumptions, exclusions and date is a different thing from a bare figure given in a first meeting.

Your terms cannot remove a consumer’s right to reasonable care and skill, or stop the consumer recovering the price paid (section 57). The wording of the estimate matters more than any disclaimer.

One letter, three different demands

A budget letter usually mixes three things. A PI policy may treat each differently, so the first job is to separate them.

  • Fees to be refunded. A consumer may be entitled to a price reduction where a service was not performed with reasonable care and skill, and it can be the full price (Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 56). Many PI wordings exclude the return or reduction of fees, so this part often stays with the practice.
  • Your unpaid invoices. These are your own debt, not a claim against you. PI does not collect them, though some wordings carry a fee recovery extension.
  • The client’s loss. Fees paid to others for abortive work, the cost of redesign and the cost of delay. This is the negligence allegation, and it is what PI is for.

A studio that argues about its invoices for three months may find it has not notified the third.

What to do when the client stops paying

  1. Send us the letter, or the email withholding payment, before you chase the invoices. A client who withholds fees after a complaint can be a circumstance under many wordings, even where no claim has been made.
  2. Do not issue proceedings for the fees first. That invites a counterclaim which insurers would first hear about from the court papers.
  3. Do not offer a refund or a discount without insurers’ agreement. A commercial gesture can be treated as an admission.
  4. Assemble the brief, every budget figure given or received, any cost plan, and what you said about allowances for furnishings, fees and VAT.
  5. If you are an SBID member, give the client your complaints procedure as the Code requires once a dispute is raised (clause 3.6), and notify at the same time.
  6. We would put the matter to insurers with the three demands separated, and ask them to appoint solicitors. Claims support

Appointment wording that keeps you inside cover

  • Record the budget in the brief, and say what it includes: works, furnishings, fees, VAT and contingency.
  • Say who gives cost advice. If it is a quantity surveyor or the contractor’s tender, not you, write that down.
  • Call an estimate an estimate, with its assumptions and its date.
  • Check the scheme against the budget at each stage, and record the client’s decision in writing when the figure moves.
  • Keep your duty at reasonable skill and care. Words such as “ensure”, “guarantee” and “fit for purpose” promise results that you may not control. Contract reviews

A client disputing your fees over the budget?

Send us the letter and the brief before you reply, and we will help you notify insurers in the right terms.

Speak to a PI specialistPI for interior designers

Related: PI for interior designers · Claims support · Contract reviews